Holey Cream

Ice Cream Shop and Donut Shop$$$$
Hell's Kitchen, New York
Save
Share
7.1/10
262
ratings
  • Sabeen
    "Try the donut ice cream sandwich - totally worth it!"(7 Tips)
    Michele P.
    "lot of courage to eat one of those doughnut ice cream sandwiches"(6 Tips)
    A G.
    "your 30,000 calorie doughnut sandwich"(3 Tips)
    Will W.
    "Divine.. Red Velvet ice cream is the way to go!"(3 Tips)
114 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • ice cream
  • donuts
  • sandwiches
  • cookies
  • pretzels
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Recent
  • Popular
  • Nhm Tanveer Hossain K.
    Like this place, especially we tried their mint and pistachio ice cream
  • Josue S.
    Josue SotoJanuary 30
    Must try peanut butter cookie dough
  • Josue S.
    Josue SotoJanuary 24
    Great ice cream and very friendly staff
  • Asli S.
    Asli SinarDecember 8, 2016
    Oreo brownie looks amazing but was just ok.
  • Asli S.
    Asli SinarDecember 8, 2016
    Smores brownie 👍🏻
  • Dee D.
    Dee DeeNovember 5, 2016
    Food is pretty big I would recommend sharing. It was a unique experience
  • Sharon T.
    Sharon TsaoSeptember 8, 2016
    Surprised that it's not overwhelming sweet -- doughnut was light and fluffy. Huge variety of sauces and toppings
  • Lisa R.
    Lisa RodriguezAugust 13, 2016
    Lots of choices for ice cream. The customer service was not great-they were rushed and loud! Also, regular ice cream cones is $1 extra something not told till you pay! Not worth it for just ice cream.
  • Theresa R.
    Theresa RoldanApril 3, 2016
    Worth it. Chocolate crumb vanilla glazed donut with red velvet and Java ice cream was totally bomb. I LOVED it.
  • Ian G.
    Ian GeeMarch 19, 2016
    Staff ignored waiting customers for a good long time unapologetically. Laid out so poorly no one knew where to give an order, as a result staff accidentally helped customers in totally wrong order.
  • Michele P.
    Michele PiccaroMarch 16, 2016
    It takes a lot of courage to eat one of those doughnut ice cream sandwiches
  • Joey T.
    Joey TJanuary 21, 2016
    The donut sandwiches are huge
  • J P.
    J PDecember 31, 2015
    Doughnut sandwich is solid
  • Caitlin D.
    Caitlin DickerboomDecember 19, 2015
    Mmmmmhhh the best
  • Victor C.
    Victor ChenDecember 4, 2015
    Cool idea but the donut is average
  • Matt P.
    Matt PNovember 23, 2015
    Sea salt caramel ice cream donut sandwich with coco puffs
  • Natalie S.
    Natalie SmithNovember 17, 2015
    Donut sandwich is to die for!
  • Dil R.
    Dil RibeiroAugust 8, 2015
    The best ice cream and donut in town. If you have the chance go for the Nutella Donut with Belgian Chocolate, Pistachio and Cream and Cookies.... And almonds!
  • Allie I.
    Allie IaconoJuly 29, 2015
    Ice cream donut sandwich! 😍
  • Chris B.
    Chris BrethelJuly 19, 2015
    Incredibly inept & rude customer service. Nearly walked out in frustration.
  • Harry D.
    Harry DavisJuly 14, 2015
    donut sandwiches with house-made ice cream
  • Catherine P.
    Catherine ParkJuly 10, 2015
    Might not be the prettiest looking place but ice cream & doughnuts together is heaven.
  • Nicolette R.
    Nicolette RomeroJuly 1, 2015
    Mint chip ice cream on a donut dipped in chocolate with chocolate crunch crumbles on top. Done. 🍩
  • jacqueline r.
    jacqueline ryanJune 25, 2015
    Very good donuts – terrible service and very unprofessional and unpleasant.
  • drew t.
    drew tarvinMay 26, 2015
    Been here 5+ times
    You can definitely split this with another person. I recommend the Milky Way ice cream on whatever you decide to get.
  • Kate Y.
    Kate YanApril 27, 2015
    Donuts are stale at end of the day. Cool concept though.
  • Amanda T.
    Amanda TheilerFebruary 27, 2015
    donuts! brownies! ice cream donuts! oh my!
  • Kimmie O.
    Kimmie OhhFebruary 21, 2015
    Choose your donut & choose your ice cream to make a donut ice cream sandwich. Genius idea for those with a sweet tooth
  • Tara C.
    Tara ChiarulliJanuary 30, 2015
    Donuts cut and filled with your choice of ice cream flavors. Then iced with toppings!
  • Linnie D.
    Linnie DDecember 27, 2014
    Frozen yogurt.
  • Minnie K.
    Minnie KimDecember 16, 2014
    Soooo delicious, but also, a heart attack in a dessert
  • Wejdan
    WejdanDecember 16, 2014
    Perfect combination!! Doughnuts and ice cream. Better be shared.
  • LETTUCEDINE
    LETTUCEDINEDecember 7, 2014
    Donut and ice cream lovers' heaven
  • Abby K.
    Abby KayNovember 17, 2014
    Their HOME MADE ice cream choices are awesome- like LI. Raspberry and pretzel ice cream!
  • Brian M.
    Brian McGOctober 20, 2014
    Ice cream sandwiches on donuts! Try the pretzel ice cream
  • Charlene M.
    Charlene ManuelSeptember 27, 2014
    Avoid at all costs. $8 for a 4 scoop sundae but you're only allowed to sample one ice cream. Rude service and a cheap owner. Your money and time are better spent elsewhere.
  • Mariama R.
    Mariama RentoySeptember 15, 2014
    Donuts are heavenly!! The dough is sooo soft and fluffy.
  • Joan P.
    Joan ParkSeptember 8, 2014
    Slow service and way overpriced
  • Harumi U.
    Harumi USeptember 7, 2014
    Agree that service is bad here. Doughnuts ice cream sandwich is a bit more unique find but I rather go for a cookie sandwich with a good service than going back here
  • TV Food Maps
    TV Food MapsSeptember 3, 2014
    Check out Holey Cream as seen on Unique Sweets Read more
  • Mandy C.
    Mandy CSeptember 1, 2014
    Peanut butter caramel cookie dough ice cream. That is all
  • Jacob C.
    Jacob CassAugust 23, 2014
    Never have I regretted one of these bad boys (donut ice cream sandwich). Avoid the pre packaged ice creams though.
  • Janice K.
    Janice KarbachinskiyAugust 22, 2014
    Frosted Ice cream donut sandwich. Enough said.
  • Paige C.
    Paige CAugust 13, 2014
    We bought a dozen donuts for 8 people and it was still TOO much! They are amazing/rich/filling/authentic. Add ice cream if you dare!
  • Jeff F.
    Jeff ForbesJuly 29, 2014
    Doughnut ice cream sandwich. Go splitty-splitty though, unless you're a true glutton.
  • Sarah L.
    Sarah LukacherJuly 24, 2014
    The peanut butter cookie dough blew my mind
  • Anna K.
    Anna KimJuly 9, 2014
    There are tasting spoons!
  • L B.
    L BJuly 4, 2014
    Old fashioned donut with Salty vanilla w/chocolate covered pretzels
  • BuzzFeed
    BuzzFeedApril 23, 2014
    There's a donut sandwich covered with your choice of frosting and topping. Not for the faint of heart.
  • Deepak S.
    Deepak ShrivastavaApril 8, 2014
    Awesome craft ice cream. Staff is mean though :-/
  • Sabeen
    SabeenMarch 31, 2014
    Try the donut ice cream sandwich - totally worth it! The ice cream flavours by the cash are delicious and apparently homemade. You deserve it!
  • Kimberlee I.
    Kimberlee ImperatoMarch 16, 2014
    Awesome place, the kids love that they get to create their own donut
  • Michelle H.
    Michelle HamiltonMarch 15, 2014
    Worth the calorie & carb overload if you walk it off!
  • Aditi L.
    Aditi LuthraFebruary 17, 2014
    Craziest workers! So much fun
  • Dusty B.
    Dusty BrianJanuary 13, 2014
    Stopped in for late night treat; owner or manager yelled at employees over their lack of help in front of several customers. Milkshake was heavy on the milk... basically chocolate milk.
  • Gloria C.
    Gloria ChinOctober 8, 2013
    get the donut ice cream sandwiches!
  • JenKudu
    JenKuduSeptember 25, 2013
    Oh my god..... order anything with chocolate and coconut!
  • Jeremy G.
    Jeremy GastonSeptember 23, 2013
    So fat but so good!
  • Nana B.
    Nana BoatengSeptember 19, 2013
    The donut ice cream is a must
  • M&M
    M&MSeptember 9, 2013
    Try the chocolate brownie.
  • NIKKI N.
    NIKKI NumbasAugust 10, 2013
    the owner's a fuckin cunt, I've seen roaches running around and employees not wearing gloves, if he was half a decent human being he'd talk to his employees with an iota of respect. DO NOT EAT HERE
  • Terena P.
    Terena PatrickAugust 1, 2013
    Donuts were good, a bit dry for my taste but still good. Had mine with Nutella. The manager is a d-bag - was arguing with employees when we walked in.
  • Donna Mc
    Donna McJuly 28, 2013
    Tourist tip: 🍩 + 🍦= why didn't I think of that?!
  • Will W.
    Will WilliamsJuly 21, 2013
    Divine.. Red Velvet ice cream is the way to go!
  • DittoPost
    DittoPostJuly 16, 2013
    No fat yogurt? That's a deal with the devil.
  • @JaumePrimero
    @JaumePrimeroJuly 11, 2013
    never in my life have I seen so many people on a weekday at midnight snacking on a donut ice cream sandwich. Sinful.
  • Betty K.
    Betty KaplanJuly 9, 2013
    The owner refuses to serve his donuts on plates. Instead it's more plastic that pollutes my city
  • Valerie R.
    Valerie RodriguezJuly 9, 2013
    Great ice cream but the manager is a total asshole! He had a crazy attitude and sadly talked shit about his employees in front of customers! Extremely unprofessional and horrible customer service!
  • Tia W.
    Tia WaddyJuly 8, 2013
    Donut sandwich is amazing. Don't worry about your diet. :-)
  • Mike L.
    Mike LMay 31, 2013
    Great ice cream place! The java Guatemalan is incredible. Homemade donut ice cream sandy? C'mon. Do it.
  • Chuck C.
    Chuck ChiemeluMay 27, 2013
    Service is terrible.
  • Dina L.
    Dina LamdanyMay 4, 2013
    Super nice people will let you sample everything!
  • Guillo ..
    Guillo ...April 15, 2013
    Custom donuts.
  • Risa
    RisaMarch 23, 2013
    Skip the overly sweet cupcakes and design your own doughnut with their mix & match toppings. I highly recommend PB&J with vanilla icing. Top it off with a scoop of ice cream if you're feeling fancy.
  • Mariah S.
    Mariah StreetMarch 13, 2013
    Great place. If you want to indulge after dinner, this is the place to do it. So many non-traditional ice cream flavors and different kinds of sweets.
  • Nat H.
    Nat HarwardMarch 12, 2013
    What are you holed up for? Go crazy!
  • The Corcoran Group
    The Corcoran GroupMarch 6, 2013
    I don't care if the staff are on the incompetent side, and the manager is rude, if I'm going to break my diet, a doughnut ice cream sandwich with pretzel, red velvet and chocolate is the way to go.
  • Nicole
    NicoleFebruary 24, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Get the luscious cheesecake ice cream!: "Caramel Infused Ice Cream loaded with Oreo Cheesecake Chunks and a Chocolate Swirl"
  • Haley J.
    Haley JonesFebruary 8, 2013
    Seemed to be manager was really mean to super friendly employee helping me. LAME. But the donut sandwiches are delightful!
  • Athena C.
    Athena ChangJanuary 27, 2013
    Try the Brownie -
  • Irene H.
    Irene HsiehJanuary 7, 2013
    Really don't understand what the hype is About. Good experience tho!
  • Jonathan S.
    Jonathan SoohooNovember 26, 2012
    Ice cream sandwich is made for 2, but can be eaten by 1. It's 3 scoops of ice cream of your choice in between a doughnut with your choice of icing and topping. Get the Guatemalan truffle ice cream.
  • Jordan K.
    Jordan KongSeptember 28, 2012
    Cash only. Unusual ice cream flavors (try the Pretzel!)
  • A G.
    A GAugust 23, 2012
    Eat in the window so you can enjoy your 30,000 calorie doughnut sandwich while laughing at the pouty boys with 0% body fat going in to Flaming Saddles across the street.
  • Kaleigh N.
    Kaleigh NeubergerAugust 7, 2012
    It is heaven in your mouth. Just do it.
  • Alicia R.
    Alicia ReneeAugust 5, 2012
    99 cent iced coffee...alas, not so-great.
  • Jaime C.
    Jaime ChengAugust 3, 2012
    The customer service here is so bad it's hilarious
  • Nandi K.
    Nandi K.July 2, 2012
    The daytime manager is a total douche. He harassed his new employee and never made my donut sandwich. I will never go back to a place where management treats their employees with such disrespect
  • Erin S.
    Erin SolanoJune 17, 2012
    doughnut ice cream sandwich; chocolate covered pretzels
  • Laura C.
    Laura ChinMay 31, 2012
    Homemade ice creams are so good. I like s'mores and Guatemalan java
  • Kristin S.
    Kristin S.May 21, 2012
    Try the black raspberry on a chocolatey sprinkle waffle cone. Eat quickly so it doesn't melt and get on your pants.
  • Krissy M.
    Krissy MApril 28, 2012
    Koolest idea ever! Absolutely worth the calories. It's the adult version of "Build a Bear"!
  • Mollly G.
    Mollly GrayApril 21, 2012
    Get the dream doughnut sandwich with pretzel and red velvet ice cream! Delish!
  • John T.
    John TanApril 13, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    Donut ice cream sandwich = new underwear needed
  • Chris S.
    Chris StubblefieldApril 10, 2012
    As far as I am concerned this is hands down the best desert I ever had. What a great concept.
  • Camille R.
    Camille R.April 1, 2012
    The brownie explosion sundae is for TWO people. So yummy!!
  • Ryan C.
    Ryan ChavisDecember 14, 2011
    Love the Birthday Cake ice cream.
  • Shareef J.
    Shareef JenkinsNovember 6, 2011
    Red Velvet cupcake ice cream
  • Patrick M.
    Patrick MOctober 16, 2011
    Hot fudge Sunday may as well come in a bucket. A delicious amazing bucket. Awesome as hell.
  • Amanda
    AmandaOctober 2, 2011
    Cute in theory but I would skip this place. Saw an employee drop an uncapped marker into sprinkles and not throw out the sprinkles. Also saw another marker resting in some almond topping. Unsanitary!
  • Aline K.
    Aline KleinApril 3, 2015
    Eu amei o cupcake red velvet. O lugar é pequeno, não tem mto espaço pra comer lá, mas vale a pena.
345 Photos

Related Searches

  • holey cream new york
  • holey cream new york photos
  • holey cream new york location
  • holey cream new york address
  • holey cream new york
  • holey cream new york
  • holy cream new york
  • holey cream hell's kitchen new york

Foursquare © 2017  Lovingly made in NYC & SF