Voted Best Pizza in Wisconsin by Food Network Magazine. Original home of the Mac n' Cheese. As seen on The Travel Channel, CNN, NY Times, and The Cooking Channel. Stop in for unique pizza flavors or a fresh, local salad.
Best pizza downtown. Try everything!!
Sweet potato chorizo pizza
If you're all about BBQ either get Smokey the Bandit or the brisket but I like smokey better cause both the chicken and bacon have a really nice crunch to it without being overcooked. It's not soaked
So good!!! Love the Mac and cheese pizza
You literally can not get a bad slice here. Be adventurous and get the monthly/weekly specials
Salads are a good size for a low price
One of the best pizza places in Madison. Be adventurous, & try something new!
Mac n cheese pizza!!!
The mac and cheese pizza is something you can't miss!
Large open space with the most inventive topping combinations you'll ever see. It's a Madison staple.
Stray from the usual cheese or pepperoni. They're famous for their crazy combinations!
Mac and cheese pizza was good. Slow delivery (1.25 hrs).
Mac n Cheese & Smokey all day
This place is phenomenal, get the bbq brisket slice, love the hipster vibe. So many toppings to choose from, reminds me of a better Mesa Pizza from Iowa City.
THE PIZZA & BREADSTICKS ARE THE BEST!!!!!!
Seriously the best pizza I have ever had. Crunchy great all around. Love it.
If you don't see a long line they must be closed.
Thin and crispy crust. Great!
Everything is good, especially dipped in Ian's ranch
Really inventive pizza
If you reuse your to-go box from Ian's when you go back, you get an extra punch!
The gluten-free is really good here. I got a Florentine made when I went. The only downside with going gluten-free is that you get one 12' instead of the choice of several different slices.
Try the Mac & Cheese pizza, it's delicious.
Spinach feta is bomb.
Definitely coming back here again.
Chicken bacon ranch is awesome!!
Great pizza. Almost like being back in NYC.
Check out your slice options before getting in line so you don't miss something.
Try something unique!
I was skeptical, but the Mac 'n cheese pizza is one of the top ten foods I've eaten in my life! Do it!
Try the Mac 'n Cheese pizza. It's good!
Sang here until 2:30 never leave
The Reuben pizza is awesome! California Burger and Bacon Ranch Potato, too!
I mean, you gotta go here late night. I was politely playing trumpet noises with my mouth to go with the music and they gave me a discount. Let that pizza soak up whatever evils you've been up to.
The staff here is REALLY awful and pushy. Two team members were extremely rude and one acted like she didn't even work here when I had an issue! Ask for Trevor next time! He'll take good care of ya
Buffalo Chicken 'za was awesome!!!!
AWESOME! Mac 'n Cheese pizza is the bomb
Ian's wifi password: newenglandclamchowder
Hungrier than a hostage!!!!!!!!!!
Best salad in town! Ingredients are always fresh...always a few specials or extensive 'build your own'.
They have new breadsticks with some really good dipping sauces now. Gold star.
The slice of Macaroni and Cheese pizza is a must try pizza.
The potato bacon ranch is very tasty.
I don't know why everyone is so stoked about this place, it's really not that good.
If u have self control, then 3 bite rule a mac n cheese slice. If u dont have self control, dont order it. Get a salad, they are customizable- leave out dried fruit & get dressing on the side
This new location is really nice! The food is still amazing.
Get a salad too! They are amazing!