il Colosseo

Italian Restaurant$$$$
Bensonhurst, Brooklyn
Save
Share
8.2/10
38
ratings
  • Albert F.
    "Love the grilled octopus"(4 Tips)
    Steve G.
    "fennel salad a home style"(3 Tips)
    Penn M.
    "Pizza, inexpensive wine"(2 Tips)
    FDITTIE
    "... was fantastic and a stripe bass which was just as good! If your looking for..."(2 Tips)
21 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • fennel salad
  • Italian food
  • mista
  • good for dates
  • authentic
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent
  • Steve G.
    Steve GMarch 24, 2013
    Great , cordial mgmt. Like a small vibrant trattoria in SIcily. Mista Mare excellent, fennel salad a home style treat , pasta pescatore one of the best I've had. Reasonably priced I'll be back again.
  • FDITTIE
    FDITTIEJanuary 13, 2013
    Great Service... The food was excellent. I had the grilled octopus which was fantastic and a stripe bass which was just as good! If your looking for real Italian this is it!
  • Michele H.
    The food was delicious especially the grill octopus. The specials of the night for lent was on point
  • Serious Eats
    Serious EatsMarch 18, 2014
    The old school Italian wears its age well. Chicken Marsala and seafood salad are especially nice.
  • Mashka
    MashkaOctober 6, 2014
    Zuppa di pesce is really good. Definitely not typical Brooklyn style. Interesting spices in the thin sauce. Very fresh seafood.
  • Sandra M.
    Sandra MOctober 24, 2015
    Best authentic italian food you can find in Brooklyn
  • Mashka
    MashkaOctober 6, 2014
    Pizza is so fresh, sauce is good but on the salty side
  • Mashka
    MashkaOctober 6, 2014
    Huge mussels but the red sauce has weird after taste, chemical like or like burned plastic
  • Michele H.
    Clams were tasty and delicious
  • Michele H.
    Great fennel salad
  • Mashka
    MashkaOctober 6, 2014
    Risotto was over cooked but the branzino was good
  • Albert F.
    Albert FazioMay 10, 2014
    Always great food. Love the grilled octopus
  • Sandra M.
    Sandra MApril 29
    Best italian food in the neighborhood
  • Anne
    AnneApril 6, 2013
    Get the grilled octopus.
  • Nico
    NicoOctober 28, 2013
    Food was very good and serving time quite fast.:)
  • Perry S.
    Perry SchafferDecember 6, 2014
    Ricotta Cheesecake #perfect
  • Matty C.
    Matty CitoDecember 14, 2014
    The fennel salad is abfab
  • Penn M.
    Penn MarchaelAugust 10
    Pizza, inexpensive wine
  • Michele H.
    Lent specials
  • Zinika P.
    Delicious!!! Highly recommend!!!
  • Rindaanne R.
    Rindaanne RiccioFebruary 19, 2012
    All about the fried calamari!
21 Photos