Ithaca Bakery

Ithaca Bakery

Bakery, Sandwich Place, and Coffee Shop$$$$
Ithaca
Save
Share
9.1/10
205
ratings
  • Kevin R.
    "Brooklyn bagel is the best deal."(2 Tips)
    Dianne R.
    "... made with fresh, local ingredients."(2 Tips)
    Owen
    "Awesome breakfast sandwiches!"(4 Tips)
    Mel G.
    "Grab a bagel and a cuppa joe or tea."(2 Tips)
52 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • sandwiches
  • bagels
  • healthy food
  • good for a quick meal
  • breakfast food
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Recent
  • Popular
  • Andrew C.
    Andrew Casper3 weeks ago
    Always loved this place, so many speciality meals plus made-to-order sandwiches and buffet foods too!!!
  • Tony T.
    Tony Tandeski3 weeks ago
    Focused on locally sourced, fresh foods. Had the J's meal. It was great. Definitely go from breakfast and get one of the many delicious breakfast sandwiches.
  • Michael S.
    Great food and fantastic friendly staff. Excellent coffee, baked goods, sandwiches and food
  • Phillip D.
    Phillip DeonApril 22
    Horseradish
  • Deepti A.
    Deepti AllaOctober 28, 2015
    Spoilt for choice! Look at their menu .. Such an extraordinary spread of breakfast options and smoothies!
  • Michael S.
    Michael SimpsonAugust 24, 2015
    Everything! :-)
  • ILYA S.
    ILYA SPEKHOVAugust 17, 2015
    Crazy big menu. Great sandwiches
  • Emily C.
    Emily CharltonJuly 11, 2015
    Great little bakery. They take a while to make the coffee, but it's good!
  • Aniket D.
    Aniket DharapApril 12, 2015
    Coffee and sandwiches
  • Catherine F.
    The roasted eggplant and red bell pepper were delicious! (And they have Buchi kombucha 💚)
  • Jazzy V.
    Jazzy VandemarkMarch 27, 2015
    There canolies are fantastic :)
  • Liana C.
    Liana CascianiJanuary 24, 2015
    Chili was on point today, and of corse were the #javajoltcoffees #caffeineaddict
  • Olek M.
    Olek MalahoffJanuary 24, 2015
    Good food, staff is friendly, prices are a tad high.
  • Stephanie S.
    Stephanie StuartJanuary 4, 2015
    Definitely the chocolate mice they look weird but it is one of my favorite things to eat the soup is phenomenal and anything they make sorry that's not real specific because everything is rad.
  • Alyssa
    AlyssaDecember 8, 2014
    Check out the monthly specials!
  • Abby G.
    Abby G.August 10, 2014
    vegetarian bagel
  • Brenda A.
    Brenda AustinMay 1, 2014
    Lots of sandwich combinations, plus you get a free eyeroll from the cashier along with your order.
  • Megan S.
    Megan SiegleMarch 30, 2014
    Get the sweet Rachel sandwich! Delicious ☺️
  • Cass V.
    Cass VasDecember 20, 2013
    Cheddar bagel - oh my lanta - heaven...
  • Kim G.
    Kim GOctober 19, 2013
    Love the Le Garden Gluten Free/Grain Free Products! Such a wide variety and super delicious!
  • Beth R.
    Beth RosenAugust 23, 2013
    Try the sunrise an interesting mix with eggs and avocado
  • Owen
    OwenJuly 21, 2013
    Awesome breakfast sandwiches!
  • Claire E.
    Claire EllenJuly 6, 2013
    Splurg and get the raspberry truffle
  • Frank F.
    Frank FazzalariJune 29, 2013
    Great smoker
  • Katie B.
    Katie BMarch 24, 2013
    The iced coffee is delicious and refreshing.
  • Michelle B.
    Michelle BerryMarch 5, 2013
    Yvonne is amazing!
  • Ariel M.
    Ariel MerkelFebruary 16, 2013
    Ordered two items and both items were completely messed up: my huevos sonaro wasn't on a bagel and his "breakfast sandwich" didn't have eggs.
  • Andrew B.
    Andrew BuraczenskiJanuary 28, 2013
    For breakfast, keep it simple and get the Brooklyn Bagel.
  • Nat W.
    Nat WosseneJanuary 13, 2013
    Chedder's beck bread loaf is amazing! As is the sourdough bread w cheddar and jalapeno's.
  • Dianne R.
    Dianne RifenburgDecember 30, 2012
    The hot chocolate is great on a cold day! Cozy atmosphere & good sandwiches made with fresh, local ingredients.
  • Katelyn M.
    Katelyn MadisonNovember 3, 2012
    J's Meal breakfast sandwich is AWESOME
  • Gregg S.
    Gregg SAugust 26, 2012
    Unless you love the taste of mint Do not get any flavor of the Metromint water. Everything thing great!!!
  • Eric G.
    Eric GuggenheimerJuly 22, 2012
    Great food great coffee
  • PurpleDog F.
    PurpleDog FarmApril 15, 2012
    Best bakery/deli around never fails to please buy their cookbook great tomato tortellini soup
  • Charlotte R.
    Charlotte RobinsonApril 7, 2012
    Get here early on the weekends, it gets busy!
  • Bethany G.
    Bethany GregoryMarch 28, 2012
    Even though I am no longer vegan I can't say no to a vegan chicken salad sandwich soooooo yummy .... Also highly recommend the jibs jaybird
  • Mick B.
    Mick BMarch 18, 2012
    Try not to gag as a woman who just wrapped a grueling Bikram session wanders about the bakery air drying herself while looking for oolong.
  • Grant B.
    Grant BraswellMarch 11, 2012
    Great hot sauce and local goods selection
  • State Theatre of Ithaca
    Love the cookies that are for sale during State Theatre of Ithaca shows? They're baked by Ithaca Bakery and for sale at all Ithaca Bakery/Collegetown Bagels locations!
  • Kerry F.
    Kerry FlanneryFebruary 28, 2012
    Cheesecake brownie for breakfast!
  • Veronica A.
    Veronica ArmstrongJanuary 7, 2012
    Amazing sandwiches but employees don't seem to know right ingredients. I got the wrong sandwich 2x. Finally I gave up & ate the random sandwich. It was delicious though. So delicious.
  • Kevin R.
    Kevin RoweNovember 6, 2011
    Brooklyn bagel is the best deal. Throw some swiss cheese
  • Jaqueline D.
    Jaqueline DillmanOctober 15, 2011
    Great soup, sandwiches
  • Best W.
    Best Western InnSeptember 26, 2011
    Awesome place to hang out on Sundays!
  • J9 S.
    J9 S.August 5, 2011
    Toasted Rosemary salt bagel with nova cream cheese. Oh so yummy!
  • Richard M.
    Richard MeekerJuly 17, 2011
    Gluten free friendly and I can actually order just about anything for my fiancé here that is available to everyone else! Love how caring they are about allergies!
  • Laura K.
    Laura Krueger roweJuly 15, 2011
    Every time we go to Ithaca we come here! Love the cheddar chive bread! Yummy lunch items for the whole family.
  • Maria W.
    Try getting the Michigan Hollow on focaccia!!! So delish
  • Jackie D.
    Jackie DongNovember 10, 2010
    The pumpernickel bread is addictive! Treat yourself to a loaf.
  • Meagz G.
    Meagz GoodwinAugust 31, 2010
    Chai Charger is amazing!!!
116 Photos