Jimmy's Grotto

Pizza Place and Italian Restaurant$$$$
  • Mishal S.
    "Ponzas are the most awesome ever"(21 Tips)
    Jason G.
    "Mmmm! Ponza Rottas are awesome!"(6 Tips)
    Jon S.
    "ponzarotta's are amazing"(3 Tips)
    Susan F.
    "Heart attacking waiting to happening."(2 Tips)
50 Tips and reviews
  • ponza
  • ponza rotta
  • ponzarotta
  • casual
  • pizza
Log in to leave a tip here.

  • Recent
  • Popular
  • Joshua L.
    You want bad service, bad customer service and a messed up order? Come here. This place used to be amazing. Now no one cares. They mess around in the kitchen and ignore the customers
  • Cody D.
    Cody DuddLesDecember 27, 2016
    Ponza rottas are my favorite so i go here. I have some bad stuff to say about this place. I have order many times for years here. The food was cold and the delivery driver took for ever sometimes.
  • Brandon M.
    Brandon MSeptember 9, 2016
    Been here 10+ times
    Jimmy's is a staple.of the 'Sha. The Ponza Rotta is a must-have, but their pizza, meatball sandwich and Italian sausage sandwich are also favorites of mine. LOVE this place!
    Upvoted Sep 4
  • Elle M.
    Elle MarieAugust 20, 2016
  • Craig M.
    Craig MuellerSeptember 11, 2015
    Ponzas are great
  • Kyle H.
    Kyle HenselSeptember 9, 2015
    Deep fried greatness
  • Sydney R.
    Sydney RappisJuly 28, 2015
    Panzas are a Waukesha must if you are in the area.
  • joanne c.
    joanne cookOctober 4, 2014
  • Kelly S.
    Kelly SelbyAugust 15, 2014
    Ponzarotta deluxe very yummy. 2 could share easy.
  • Nick W.
    Nick WierzbaAugust 11, 2014
    Been here 5+ times
    One word....PONZAS
  • Werner L.
    Werner LehmanAugust 8, 2014
    Ponzas are a must. Pizza is great too.
  • Richi R.
    Richi RochaAugust 7, 2014
    Been here 5+ times
  • John B.
    John BolkaMay 27, 2014
    No less than 30,000 calories, but worth it
  • Jessica T.
    Jessica TrovatoMarch 20, 2014
    The best ponza you ever ate!
  • Susan F.
    Susan FisherOctober 27, 2013
    Heart attacking waiting to happening. Its worth it if you grew eating there and its well worth it too.
  • Tamara L.
    Tamara LancasterAugust 19, 2013
    Any time I am within half hour, I male the special detour to Grotto and load up...have turned many onto the ponza rotta addiction.
  • Craig H.
    Craig H.August 16, 2013
    a months worth of calories but well worth it
  • Ryan S.
    Ryan SchwenknerAugust 6, 2013
    Awesome food! Be careful for the local Waukesha crazies.
  • Matthew S.
    Matthew SchultzJuly 10, 2013
    Worth the impending cardiac arrest...
  • Sarah H.
    Sarah HJuly 7, 2013
    A 40 minute wait when they're slow and standing around for a still cold calzone. Ignorant employees who won't fix a problem. I won't be back!
  • Jason P.
    Jason PrillJune 22, 2013
    So bad for you, yet so yummy. You probably should never have a ponza, which means you definitely should have a ponza.
  • Paul G.
    Paul GorzalskiMay 24, 2013
    Great Ponzi's
  • Micaela U.
    Micaela UniqueMay 10, 2013
    I loveeee jimmys alot. But tonight I ordered a side salad and found a spider in my salad. Worst experience ever. I don't think I cam eat there ever again.
  • Jacob W.
    Jacob W.May 2, 2013
    Been here 25+ times
    This place is AMAZING! Call in your order for your ponza and avoid the wait. Double cheese, 1/2 sausage is the best.
  • ChrisTina
    ChrisTinaApril 13, 2013
    Best ponza's ever!!!!!! Makes the drive from Milwaukee all worth the drive :)
  • Nayland G.
    Nayland GonzalezNovember 11, 2012
    Ponza Rottas are gifts from God!!
  • Chris P.
    Chris PerezSeptember 27, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    They take Visa, MC, discover
  • Jeani W.
    Jeani WidishJuly 5, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    Now taking credit cards! :)
  • Jason G.
    Jason GuerreroMay 10, 2012
    Mmmm! Ponza Rottas are awesome!
  • tanya h.
    tanya holmesFebruary 28, 2012
    my favorite place to eat since i moved here a year ago ...love this place :)
  • Eric Z.
    Eric ZiglerFebruary 16, 2012
    One of those down-to-earth, little hole-in-the-wall joints you only see in 1980s sitcoms, Jimmy's Grotto is up there with 'Cheers' for being a legend of its own. Have a Ponza, settle in, and be happy.
  • David
    DavidFebruary 9, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    Try a ponza. They are tasty and cheap.
  • Jeff O.
    Jeff OJanuary 20, 2012
    Grease bad... Ponza good.
  • Claire K.
    Claire KruckJanuary 8, 2012
    Best food in town just be prepared to wait but its worth it
  • Kim T.
    Kim TDecember 28, 2011
    Plan on ordering your food an hour before you pick it up
  • Jamie P.
    Jamie PrevortNovember 8, 2011
    Been eating the same ponza, since I was a very little girl; my kids are growing to on them as well!!! Have a ponds over pizza anyday!!!!!
  • Mishal S.
    Mishal SchubertOctober 16, 2011
    Ponzas are the most awesome ever
  • Mike C.
    Mike COctober 15, 2011
    Been here 100+ times
    Love the shrimp dinner
  • Amanda D.
    Amanda De La PazAugust 16, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    Ponzas are what dreams are made of. This place is TRULY a Waukesha landmark but if you order delivery be prepared...it takes over an hour.
  • Tami G.
    Tami GravesJuly 29, 2011
    Ponza = deep fried heaven, even just the plain cheese one is sheer delishiousness. Super affordable too. They also have a very good fish sammiches
  • LeAnne
    LeAnneJuly 29, 2011
    Been here 50+ times
    I make sweet love to my ponza as often as I can.
  • Natasha F.
    Natasha FergusonMay 23, 2011
    The Ponza's are worth the drive all the way back to Waukesha when you are in need of greasy delicious-ness Read more
  • Brandon W.
    Brandon W.May 17, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    Been coming to grotto's since it was in the standing room only building, still great. Gotta have a ponza bring someone whos never had one.its the stuff of legends.
  • Scot V.
    Scot Van Der BuntMarch 27, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    Deep fried heart attack. But its damn well worth it!
  • Tanner W.
    Tanner WestonOctober 11, 2010
    I like cheese
  • Kelly N.
    Kelly NimmerSeptember 22, 2010
    Ponzas are delicious! Remember that Jimmy's Grotto is cash only!
  • Mary Jane S.
    Mary Jane SanchezApril 11, 2010
    Been here 25+ times
    Love the pepper rings
  • Scott S.
    Scott SingerMarch 26, 2010
    One of my favorite places to eat in Waukesha. The italian beef and ponzarotta is my food of choice.
  • Jon S.
    Jon SingerMarch 26, 2010
    ponzarotta's are amazing
  • Charlie W.
    Charlie WhiskeyOctober 16, 2009
    Been here 5+ times
    Dine in or carry out and eat a Jimmy's Grotto Ponza Rotta without allowing the ponza to spill grease or cheese on your cardboard plate or styrofoam container.
63 Photos

Related Searches

  • jimmy's grotto waukesha
  • jimmy's grotto waukesha photos
  • jimmy's grotto waukesha location
  • jimmy's grotto waukesha address
  • jimmy's grotto waukesha
  • jimmy's grotto waukesha
  • jimmys grotto waukesha

Foursquare © 2017  Lovingly made in NYC & SF