Kittery

Kittery

Seafood Restaurant, American Restaurant, and Bar$$$$
Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn
Save
Share
6.6/10
211
ratings
  • Dave L.
    "Lobster Roll and Tots are outstanding."(16 Tips)
    JoJo D.
    "Happy hour at the bar 5-7pm, $1 oysters, $5 wines, $4 drafts!"(4 Tips)
    Ashley
    "... That beer, paired with $1 oysters, a lobster roll and patio dining makes for..."(5 Tips)
    Fauzia D.
    "The scallops and truffled cauliflower are kind of amazing."(2 Tips)
68 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • oysters
  • 4 drafts
  • happy hour
  • truffle cauliflower
  • clams
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Recent
  • Popular
  • Ryan B.
    Happy hour
  • Eddy C.
    Eddy CFebruary 4
    Big fan, lots of seafood variety on the menu. Great prices.
  • Jeans
    JeansDecember 25, 2016
    $1 blue points & jumbo shrimp cocktail M-F 5-7
  • sne345
    sne345October 18, 2016
    It's okay... best is the lobster rolls but I've had better.
  • Jeshua B.
    Jeshua BorgesSeptember 13, 2016
    Happy hour and patio is hard to beat.
  • Dave L.
    Dave LazSeptember 4, 2016
    Lobster Roll and Tots are outstanding.
  • Deon D.
    Deon DApril 24, 2016
    Hard to say what's good when the menu changes pretty regularly. Only been there once and it seemed that they were already phasing out items. I enjoyed the chicken findings and truffle crusted salmon.
  • Deon D.
    Deon DApril 24, 2016
    The food was great, even for a person that doesn't care much for seafood. I went for the braised short ribs but got the truffle mushroom "crusted" salmon. It was great.
  • Frederic B.
    Frederic BonnApril 17, 2016
    It takes for hours to get your plate. Terrible service (or more likely, kitchen organization)
  • Adam
    AdamMarch 12, 2016
    After eating here tonight I'm reminded that sometimes looks can be deceiving. Just because a place looks good, doesn't mean that it is.
  • Drew
    DrewMarch 12, 2016
    I left unimpressed. The appetizers came out timely but the entrees took a long time to arrive. The clam chowder, the muscles and clams, the lobster gnocchi were overlooked and chewy.
  • Ashley
    AshleyAugust 15, 2015
    Been here 10+ times
    When I went they had a beer of their own on draft. That beer, paired with $1 oysters, a lobster roll and patio dining makes for good times.
  • David G.
    David GreenbergerAugust 12, 2015
    Been here 5+ times
    Monday night: $1 oysters. Tuesday night: Burger night. Wednesday night: 1/2 price bottles of wine
  • David G.
    David GreenbergerAugust 12, 2015
    Been here 5+ times
    Happy hour 4-8pm Weekdays: $1 oysters, $4 drafts, $5 lobster sliders 🙏🏼
  • Walter
    WalterJuly 25, 2015
    Lobster roll was chunky and buttery. Outstanding.
  • Gideon O.
    Gideon OlshanskyJuly 6, 2015
    Been here 5+ times
    The lobster rolls have a generous amount of lobster. Get the chips, not the fries.
  • Sabrina
    SabrinaJune 20, 2015
    Lobster roll is solid, but not the best. Crab chips were a miss.
  • Willem V.
    Willem Van LanckerJune 14, 2015
    Pretty solid New England seafood joint with cheap Oysters. Terrible, slow service.
  • Jessica P.
    Jessica PMay 6, 2015
    Remarkably terrible service, not even that busy. Slow and clueless staff.
  • Christopher B.
    Christopher BMarch 29, 2015
    Food is ok. Good service. Great location though.
  • Eric H.
    Eric HerasMarch 22, 2015
    Lobster Club is must! Solid Bloody Mary +variations hit the spot :)
  • Alex R.
    Alex RavenelMarch 12, 2015
    Good, not great. Nice space, though, and the wine list is better than it needs to be.
  • lw l.
    lw leeFebruary 7, 2015
    Avoid. Super slow service, below average food.
  • Daniel M.
    Daniel McDonoughJanuary 25, 2015
    Been here 10+ times
    Start with some oysters and then go with the fish & chips or the halibut.
  • WillMcD
    WillMcDJanuary 11, 2015
    Been here 10+ times
    All oysters are $1 on Monday's all night. Tues = burger + beer night. Wed = 1/2 off bottles of wine!
  • Kev S.
    Kev SkinnyAugust 28, 2014
    Oysters were fresher than those new kicks I just got.
  • Saif D.
    Saif DiaAugust 23, 2014
    The lobster roll is great value. I'd avoid the fish and chips; the batter comes out too similar to a beignet
  • Brandon W.
    Brandon WolfAugust 6, 2014
    This place has a great happy hour. $1 oysters and $4 draft beers, and outdoor seating. Check it out if you like any of those things.
  • Rob S.
    Rob StengelJuly 1, 2014
    Solid food. Terrible service. Not worth the hassle IMO.
  • David G.
    David GreenbergerJune 28, 2014
    Been here 5+ times
    In the summer their outside stand sells lobster rolls, fried clams etc. Grab a beer, enjoy the sun, and if this doesn't make you the happiest person in the city, for even 30 min, you're doing it wrong
  • Daniel M.
    Daniel McDonoughJune 20, 2014
    Been here 10+ times
    They don't accept AMEX.
  • Nikki W.
    Nikki W.May 21, 2014
    Great weekday happy hour 5-8pm and weekends 4-6pm.
  • william v.
    william verondaFebruary 13, 2014
    Top NY seafood. Great Cioppino with top quality. Occasional special of stuffed sole.
  • Uber NYC
    Uber NYCSeptember 23, 2013
    Happy hour is Mon - Friday from 5-7 with oyster and drink specials. Awesome/huge outdoor patio, Blue Point oysters, and crispy oysters are all delish.
  • sonia
    soniaSeptember 14, 2013
    Eat at the bar. Table service is ridiculously bad.
  • Erin M.
    Erin McReynolds DavisSeptember 13, 2013
    To get happy hour prices outside, you have to order inside at the bar, and then go sit outside (or stay in).
  • Abigail C.
    Abigail ChristinaAugust 30, 2013
    So expensive. But the food was good.
  • Massimo C.
    Massimo ChibbaroAugust 12, 2013
    Don't try the mussels. Lobster roll was ok. I was expecting much more.
  • Eric H.
    Eric HarrisJuly 28, 2013
    Nice to have a piece of Maine in Brooklyn
  • Brenda C.
    Brenda CervantesJuly 21, 2013
    Try the Lobster roll! Yum!
  • Kevin K.
    Kevin KearneyJuly 14, 2013
    Pretend there's an emergency and rush out of here before you make the mistake of ordering anything.
  • JPaz
    JPazJune 23, 2013
    Gotta try "El Dorado" rum awesome!!!!!
  • Cassandra B.
    Cassandra BradbyJune 22, 2013
    The clam chowder was great. :)
  • Jackie G.
    Jackie GordonJune 16, 2013
    Always solid and consistent.
  • Steph H.
    Steph HJune 16, 2013
    Lobster bake special on national lobster day is freakin' delicious. +++ would lobster again.
  • JoJo D.
    JoJo DemirelJune 5, 2013
    Been here 10+ times
    Happy hour at the bar 5-7pm, $1 oysters, $5 wines, $4 drafts!
  • Colin M. F.
    Colin M. FordMay 26, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Lobster roll is a must.
  • Colin M. F.
    Colin M. FordMay 26, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    It seems like this place should have an oceanfront view. A great addition to the neighborhood!
  • Janice M.
    Janice MatasiMay 25, 2013
    Amazing mind bread pudding!
  • peter k.
    peter kafkaMay 12, 2013
    Ok. Go with shack stuff - ie fried calamari > grilled trout smothered in hollandaise. Staff cheerful but overwhelmed.
  • Vanessa S.
    Vanessa SotoMay 2, 2013
    This place is delicious and friendly, portions huge!
  • Jacqueline G.
    Jacqueline GriecoApril 14, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    I had the mussels, shrimp cocktail and swordfish. All were delicious and beautifully presented. Great restaurant!
  • Andy R.
    Andy RoweMarch 31, 2013
    The secret ingredient is bacon!!! #yum
  • Mickie Q.
    Mickie QuinnMarch 10, 2013
    Seared scallops with truffled cauliflower. Amazeballs. Just do it. Beware the frozen oyster, however.
  • REP
    REPMarch 9, 2013
    If you never had the lobster roll at Fish Camp, this is fine. And it is great to have a place where you can have dinner with a bottle of wine for $100.
  • Jill
    JillFebruary 23, 2013
    Stuffies even a Rhode Island girl can get behind. The fried seafood platter was delicious, but split it!
  • Mario L.
    Mario LangFebruary 22, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Happy hour from 5-7pm daily. $4 drafts. So worth it!!
  • Mario L.
    Mario LangFebruary 20, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Try the vegetable platter!! Best I've ever had! The food is amazing! Go and check it out.
  • Erez S.
    Erez SchnaittacherFebruary 16, 2013
    Great dark and stormy. Fried calamari, baked clams and shrimp cocktail were delicious. Lobster roll and lobster strew were tasty and substantial portions.
  • Natalie P.
    Natalie PappacodaFebruary 3, 2013
    Could be so much better.
  • Fauzia D.
    Fauzia DawoodJanuary 8, 2013
    The scallops and truffled cauliflower are kind of amazing.
  • Melissa S.
    Melissa SepeDecember 30, 2012
    Lobster stew is phenomenal.
  • Sarah F.
    Sarah FirsheinDecember 22, 2012
    Lobster roll is solid. Skip the crab dip. Place actually takes reservations.
  • Jennifer H.
    Jennifer HicksDecember 18, 2012
    Generous and delicious lobster roll. Clam chowder hit the spot on a cold night.
  • 7th.List
    7th.ListDecember 8, 2012
    Just opened. Seafood shack. Features - chowders, fried fish, lobster rolls. Chef Josh Moulton from the Monkey Bar. Read more
  • Madison C.
    Madison CruzDecember 7, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    Lobster Dinner
  • Madison C.
    Madison CruzAugust 31, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    Opening Soon!! Can't wait.
  • Chris F.
    Chris FohlinAugust 26, 2012
    The buildout of the facade is coming along; this place should open "in the next few weeks."
177 Photos