Pizza Place and Italian Restaurant$$$$
Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn
191 Tips and reviews
  • pizza
  • calzones
  • BYOB
  • good for dates
  • cozy
Log in to leave a tip here.

  • Recent
  • Popular
  • Jessica
    Jessica1 week ago
    Forgot - also get the crispy side of pepperoni! Sooo sinfully amazing!
  • Jessica
    Jessica1 week ago
    Amazingly charming place, with a great story. Get a pizza. And a calzone. Bring your own wine. Toppings? Shallots, Basil - they load it!!!; and garlic. That is all.
  • Jay M.
    Jay MuntuNovember 2
    BYOB, be prepared to wait 2 hours.
  • Raquelle J.
    Raquelle JessieOctober 24
    get the calzone, everything comes w. fresh basil and it's BYOB !
  • James K.
    James KiernanOctober 7
    Lucali has vaulted to #1 in my pizza rankings. Outstanding pizza and calzones and a real friendly vibe. Bonus points for BYO!
    Upvoted Oct 31
  • Vijay D.
    The best pizza. That's really all there is to say. Oh - the calzones are great too.
  • Lily
    LilySeptember 30
    Get extra sauce for dipping everything in.
  • Monica M.
    Monica MarziglianoSeptember 17
    Best pizza in NY- no question. Don't miss the calzone either... Buon appetito!👌🏼
  • Carolina A.
    Best pizza in Brooklyn according to Jay-Z
  • Guest of a Guest
    Lucali is home to Beyonce and Jay-Z's favorite slice, so it's gotta be good. This Brooklyn spot is also BYOB. Read more
  • Alana W.
    Get extra sauce for your pizza
  • Branden S.
    All beef pepperoni
  • Adrienne H.
    really good! ONLY COME IF YOU HAVE A RESERVATION. Was told the wait would be 1.5 hours and it ended up being exactly three hours. Not worth my impatience, but worth it if there is some prior planning
  • Latha S.
    Latha SJuly 1
    Calzone's a No for me
  • Latha S.
    Latha SJuly 1
    You can watch when he makes the Pizza while you wait for your order to come in.
  • Sam B.
    Sam BearJune 20
    They open at 6pm, but they start taking names at 5pm. If you arrive at 6 the wait might be 2 hours, but they'll text you when the table is ready!
  • Warren L.
    Pure. Pizza.Hop over to the corner store to get some beer, it's BYOB.Mark is a family man. You'll see his family dining there often.
  • Noura S.
    Noura S.June 16
    Been here 10+ times
    Best pizza in the world. Prepare yourself to wait up to 2 hours
  • Michael C.
    Don't miss out on the pepperoni pie and calzone. Great ambience.
  • Gus F.
    Gus FarnesApril 19
    Margarita Pizza is fantastic, reminiscent of of how pizza tasted in Sardinia as a kid. Combination of great ingredients and care👌.
  • Ezra P.
    Incredible pizza and calzones.
  • Joe D.
    Joe DApril 6
    Semi-pro move: order your pie(s) pick-up and scoot over to the picnic tables at Cobble Hill Park if the weather's nice
  • Graham L.
    Simple and delicious. BYOB for the win.
  • Adam D.
    Adam DruckerApril 1
    Been here 25+ times
    Calzones are amazing
  • Ben K.
    Top 5 pizza places for me. Get there before 6 or expect a 2 hour wait. Pizza is excellent but the calzone is the real star. Perfect meal: pepperoni pizza and shallot, basil, garlic calzone. It's BYOB!
  • Emily L.
    Emily L.March 19
    This place is divine. Get a pie for two and add a small calzone. BYOB!
  • Pia F.
    Pia FouillouxMarch 18
    Been here 10+ times
    Best pizza and calzone in NYC!
  • Stina P.
    Stina P.March 7
    OH MY GOSH THE SAUCE IS UNREAL. also if you order a calzone, you get a big side of it for dipping. calling for pick up is the best to beat the wait if you live in the neighborhood.
  • Brad K.
    Brad KleinMarch 1
    Been here 5+ times
    1st: small, focused menu ensures every/anything is good. Pro tip: pepperoni on side = oven-cooked crispylicious. Pro tip2: call ahead! Pro3: basil, garlic on everything. Pro4: side sauce calzone!
  • Chrissy K.
    Chrissy KFebruary 28
    Pizza and simple toppings. Yum
  • Pizza Lover 1.
    Pizza Lover 1February 8
    Place rocks !
  • David B.
    David BanDecember 31, 2015
    Lemme guess, 2 hr wait on a Monday? Pro move: order a pie takeout, head to Floyd on Atlantic (they allow food), and dine like a king on leather couches.
  • I A.
    I AmosDecember 24, 2015
    The calzone is sublime. Order it with garlic. Drink any leftover marinara.
  • Danny
    DannyDecember 22, 2015
    Best Wood fired pizza and the calzones in NYC and just when you thought it couldn't get better? BYOB!!
  • R20 R.
    R20 R20December 4, 2015
    Best pizza in brooklyn....hands down. Perhaps all of nyc.
  • Soo Mi
    Soo MiDecember 1, 2015
    Cozy and casual. BYOB is a beautiful thing. Worth the wait. Love the simple, no frills menu. Atmosphere is lively and warm.
  • Liz O.
    Liz OhNovember 15, 2015
    Calzone cut up evenly with our party size
  • Memo S.
    Memo S.November 3, 2015
    The pizza is great and rivals many of the New York giants, but the calzone is amazing and stands alone.
  • Burak M.
    Burak MOctober 27, 2015
    Currently closed for renovations (10/27/2015)
  • Courtney L.
    Courtney LeonardOctober 21, 2015
    Jay-Z recently named Lucali Brooklyn's best pizza place during an interview with Jimmy Kimmel, and that's the only reason you need to go here.
  • Jack C.
    Jack CoyneOctober 18, 2015
    Pizza is unreal
  • Gozde H.
    Gozde HostenSeptember 27, 2015
  • A W.
    A WriterSeptember 12, 2015
    Decent pizza, no more. The toppings are good quality but the crust is too cracker-y for my taste. If you don't get there BEFORE it opens, expect to wait. Don't believe the hype.
  • Hattie B.
    Hattie BrownAugust 11, 2015
    It's a warm, welcoming, family-run spot. They really take care of you, even when you're waiting outside. Drop by an hour before opening to put your name down - at least 1 hour wait but SO WORTH IT.
  • Steven G.
    Steven GantmanJuly 31, 2015
    Fresh ingredients but very long wait, don't go with more than 4 people or in the summer- it's a mosquito fest outside
  • Kirill K.
    Kirill KukuruzaJuly 11, 2015
    Just one world.. Calzone!
  • Sofia U.
    Sofia UzJune 29, 2015
    Well this one is the legend. 2 pizzas only, try both. Be there at 5.
  • Paul L.
    Paul LauJune 15, 2015
    Pretty solid. Get the Bey-Z special: 15 layer pizza.
  • Soraya D.
    Soraya DarabiJune 5, 2015
    Ask for pepperoni on the side extra crispy as all the locals know to do
  • Jenna O.
    Jenna OdettMay 15, 2015
    Cash-only, BYO, no reservations, get the calzones. For Sunday group dinner arrive by 5:15p, worth the wait.
187 Photos

Related Searches

  • lucali brooklyn
  • lucali brooklyn photos
  • lucali brooklyn location
  • lucali brooklyn address
  • lucali brooklyn
  • lucali brooklyn
  • lucali pizza brooklyn
  • lucalis brooklyn
  • waiting on line for lucali brooklyn
  • lucali carroll gardens brooklyn

Foursquare © 2016  Lovingly made in NYC & SF