Our lobster shacks offer fresh and delicious lobster rolls, crab rolls, shrimp rolls, crab claws, bisques and beer straight from Maine!
Step 1: Get a boyfriend. Step 2: Order the Noah's Ark. Step 3: Repeat 3x / week
Blueberry soda was great!
Taste of Maine: 1/2 lobster, 1/2 crab and 1/2 shrimp roll with 2 crab claws and slaw
Menu oct 2015
My friends all love the $16 lobster rolls
The lobster roll is awesome. They have a decent soda selection too.
In my opinion one of the best lobster rolls in the country!
Get the sampler
Simple, fresh, fast. A bit pricey but you know it's the real deal. Great for lunch.
my go-to lobster roll in nyc, primarily for proximity. (don't plan on staying here to eat, though -- way too crowded always.)
Have to admit - it lives up to the hype. Incredibly fresh lobster rolls, reasonably priced, authentic decor / scene / staff. Wish I could afford this for lunch every day!
Per my last tip, I blame @dens for this addiction. Luke's Lobster rolls changed my perspective on lobster rolls. I didn't know a lobster roll love like this could exist until Luke's came along.
Lobster rolls are great but expect to wait in line for a table as the space is small.
Best Lobster Roll in the city. Noah's ark is the way to go. The lobster is fresh and spiced perfectly, but the roll tops everything: toasted to nirvana and buttered so right. Rock on Luke!!!!!!!!
Lobster roll and crab roll are great!
Simply the best lobster roll. They invented the roll, nature invented the lobster.
Yummy lobster roll, served up quickly. Yum!
At Luke's they serve a very hearty lobster roll on a nice buttery bread. The place may be small but the chunks of slobby lobstah certainly aren't!
The lobster roll is meaty and worth it!
This is the best lobster roll I've ever eaten. And I've eaten a lot of lobster rolls. Fresh, lightly toasted bun: check. Abundant chunks of luscious, pristine lobster: check. Easy on the mayo, also.
A meaty, simple lobster roll like they should be. Get the combo deal with soda and chips and walk over to Thompson square park for a summer date -- brownbag beer optional.
This lobster roll joint has expanded through out the city (and beyond) and it's all thanks to their huge chunks of lobster meat not masked by anything but a little butter and mayo. And a toasted bun.
One of the best lobster rolls in the city, mostly due to their obvious focus on the lobster itself. PLUS they hand pack your lobster roll with such care you'd think they were handling a baby
Lobster roll is wonderful
Lobster roll nirvana. Luke's proudly sources their lobsters from small Maine fisheries and the quality is apparent. The rolls here are incredible with a huge amount of claw meat, just a tiny butter
It may not be the largest, but their lobster roll packs a ton of flavor in a small package.
The reviews don't lie. This place is the best (and worth the splurge)
love this place!
Shrimp roll is cheap!
Great place for Lobster roll. Take it out and eat it on Union square:)
You can't go wrong with a lobster roll, bag of chips and a diet coke. Take it to nearby Tompkins Square Park for the best meal ever.
There isn't a better lobster roll in NYC. Meat is chunky and fresh and the rolls are buttered and toasted to perfection
The golden standard for lobster rolls in NYC.
The best Lobster Role I have ever eaten! ... and this means something.
Best lobster roll
just get the taste of Maine, you'll weep tears of joy
Get the Noah's Ark. A great sampler to split between two people, two half rolls of shrimp, crab, and lobster. Fresh and delicious ingredients. Limited seating.
Lobster rolls my precious...
Do you like lobster? You are at the right adress!
Simply yum! Just try the 15$ Lobster Sandwich! Very good for the small apetite. 🌟🌟🌟🌟
The captains combo is the way to go. Soup and a lobster roll!
Lobster sub obviously
Went here yesterday and noticed that they currently have a limited Captain's Special, which adds a small soup to any combo ;) Great shrimp rolls.
Quite expensive. Clam chowder soup was good, but it's better in 'The Mermaid Inn' nearby
Shrimp Roll: $8.00
The lobster tastes "fresh out the ocean wet." Delicious. Yes, the best around. Treat yourself.
Get the big order that comes with the half sandwiches and the claws. It's so delicious you'll be hungry for more.
Amazing rolls! So delicious.
Best crab roll I ever tasted.