Our lobster shacks offer fresh and delicious lobster rolls, crab rolls, shrimp rolls, crab claws, bisques and beer straight from Maine!
Go there to get a great lobster roll with pickles !
I don’t know Luke, but he manages to make what is likely the best lobster roll in the city. The Connecticut style rolls (warm with butter) aren’t huge, but are packed with delicious and tender lobster
Amazing! The lobster is my favorite.. The shrimp is good too.. Keep in mind these are small.. I took half shrimp and half lobster and they weren't enough 😱 very small
Great lobster, crab and prawn rolls!
Best New England Clam Chowder in NY!
4th time: lobster roll is still perfect
the lobster roll here is perfect. that's all you need. Riesling is decent; didn't like the honey blueberry lemonade.
Amazing lobster rolls.
Crab and Shrimp Rolls > Lobster Rolls
The lobster roll is super! It's to die for. If you're with some company try ordering the smorgasbord Noah's Ark! The price is truly worth the value and the staff are as good as hospitable.
Buttery sweet lobster rolls and a beer. Perfect salve for a summer day.
Great UES outpost of the LES version for awesome Lobster Rolls
Lobster rolls are delicious. I always get the crab roll too. Don't forget to try their mexicane soda. I think I like this more than coca cola!
Lobster rolls are amazing but a bit small. If you're really hungry get a shrimp roll and a clam chowder for about the same price.
Fantastic lobster sandwiches
Taste of Maine to see what I like best.
Taste of Maine way to go! Small but sweet beer selection
Shrimp Roll: $8.00
Noah's Ark -$38
Tried the crab roll and it was awesome with sriracha. The rolls are on the small side, so I'd go for the taste of Maine if you're hungry.
Not sure where their pickles are from, prob just a supermarket jar brand, but I like them. I don't think they charge extra for it so just ask for one.
The quintessential of shellfish sandwiches in a tiny lovely place on the UES.
Lobster rolls are amazing
Nice and cozy place. Best clam chowder in the UES
Great place, amazingly tasty lobster roll! Reasonable price
Just high quality lobster roles, minus lol the other garbage you often find in the recipe.
Authentic New England style lobster roles! Yum!
Lobster rolls mmmm
A lobster roll is magnificent.
Had the Noah's ark with all three kinds of rolls for two people. Lobster roll was the best. Next time would just order full size for that one.
Friendly staff, make sure to stamp your loyalty card. Order the Noah's Arc for two or more people.
Don't let the name fool you. The crab and shrimp rolls are best in class.
My fav place so far! Try the shrimp & crab! I'm sure the lobster is better somewhere else.
Authentic Lobster Rolls, and good beers to go with em'
Order the Noah's Arc! Its perfect for two people. Lobster, crab & shrimp rolls with a pickle on the side. Plus your choice of chips & soda. The Mexican cola is must!
Very tasty sampling menu - though pretty pricey. Sat on the bench outside & people watched. Artisan root beer was gorgeous - alongside the crab claw, pickle, lobster, crab & shrimp rolls w/ CC chips
Best lobster rolls in town
Just order the damn lobster roll....dont bother with anything else. the hot sauce is a nice option, but it's not for purists.
Great place to hang out with friends. Nice food and drinks. Love the music here.
Met Alex the GM who is very customer focused. Clam chowda is awesome!
Wish the lobster roll were longer!
Killer lobster rolls
The mayor deal is no longer valid :(
Overpriced, but worth to try at least once. The orange soda tastes great.
Lobster Roll is great!
There is never anyone at the register. At least they will double stamp your card for the wait. Don't forget to ask.
The best lobster roll I've ever had. What a place