Mama Theresa's

Pizza Place, Italian Restaurant, and Wine Bar$$$$
Garden City Park
Save
Share
8.4/10
121
ratings
  • justmush
    "bruchetta and salad slices"(2 Tips)
    Christina C.
    "The spinach & broccoli bocconcini is surprising light."(2 Tips)
    Doug B.
    "Try the buffalo pizza or chicken roll."(3 Tips)
    Bobby B.
    "Rice balls and chicken roll with a side of marinara."(2 Tips)
43 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • pizza
  • chicken
  • bocconcini
  • salads
  • good service
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent
  • Leslie M.
    Leslie MartinezJuly 4, 2014
    Anything is amazing, but if I had to narrow it down I would say the buffalo style chicken pizza with blue cheese....AMAZING!!!!
  • Peter ☎💺📈
    Peter ☎💺📈August 27, 2014
    Been here 5+ times
    Excellent selection of various toppings for their pizzas. Italian sandwich selection us awesome. Eat in or take out you can't go wrong here.
  • Rich G.
    Rich GallagherAugust 18, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    As good as any slice on Long Island, which is why they can get away not delivering their pies. Aside from the regular, the sicilian and buffalo chicken are unparalleled.
  • Keira M.
    Keira MahoneyFebruary 26, 2013
    Been here 10+ times
    The most AMAZING salad I've ever had. I've been going here since I was about 4...I love it!!! Sooo delicious
  • H B.
    H BombzMarch 25, 2012
    It looks busy but that ppl waiting for take out. Request a table. The sauteed broccoli rabe is to die for!
  • Christina C.
    Christina C.May 5, 2013
    The spinach & broccoli bocconcini is surprising light. Tasty filling. Eggplant roll was also light but filling.
  • Isabel M.
    Isabel M.July 22, 2011
    One of my favorite restaurants! Try any dish! I bet you'll love #24 and the pecan salad is to die for!
  • Julia Kwan
    Julia KwanJuly 12, 2015
    Staff is always lovely! Portions are small for lunch. Get the chicken masala pizza!
  • Carlos E.
    Carlos EnriqueMay 2, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    Buffalo slice is like no other around. And that's a good thing also try the grilled chicken panini
  • Gregory S.
    Gregory StepanianAugust 24, 2011
    The house salad with cheese & grilled chicken is a must! Crispino/grandma slice is the best!
  • JR C.
    JR CashinNovember 5, 2011
    Been coming here my whole life. The best around. When I come back to LI. Its a must!!
  • Steve D.
    Steve DietrichJanuary 7, 2011
    Been here 25+ times
    Every time I come home to visit my family, I just gotta have a slice from here. Some of the best pizza on Long Island!
  • Marvin B.
    Marvin BzuraJanuary 8, 2010
    Been here 100+ times
    platters come with huge salads. Buffalo Chicken wing pizza w/ blue cheese is amazingFriends in Manhattan & Brooklyn ask me to bring them frozen slices.
  • Isabel M.
    Isabel M.July 22, 2011
    The food here is delicious! Try dish #22 it's uhmazing! The pecan salad is to die for!
  • justmush
    justmushAugust 3, 2010
    Been here 50+ times
    The bruchetta and salad slices are awesome, vegetarian, AND dairy-free. Talk about healthy!
  • Karen S.
    Karen S.July 18, 2012
    Yes the food is good, but I was disappointed they removed their Italian Ices machine for a beer cooler!
  • Travis L.
    Travis La MarrNovember 20, 2014
    Been here 10+ times
    The buffalo chicken pizza is the thing to get here.
  • Colleen
    ColleenJuly 21, 2012
    One word: Bocconcini. Veggie or meat... either way, you'll thank me.
  • Ashley N.
    Ashley NicoleDecember 14, 2010
    Been here 25+ times
    They're house salads are the best! So is they're chicken parm and heros
  • Martin M.
    Martin MongoniJuly 8, 2012
    Been here 100+ times
    Higher quality cheese means less grease. Get the hint?
  • Tobi S.
    Tobi StonichMay 26, 2013
    The chicken marsala slice is really tasty!
  • Appa V.
    Appa VMay 13, 2013
    Been here 10+ times
    Eggplant and Pepper Panini is fantastic
  • Charlie A.
    Charlie AnnunziatoJune 15, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    great food, and best stromboli i ever had
  • Bobby B.
    Bobby BrownDecember 31, 2010
    Rice balls and chicken roll with a side of marinara. Best salad on earth!
  • Russ L.
    Russ LangeJune 18, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    THE BEST SALADS AROUND HANDS DOWN!!!!!!!!!!!
  • Erik W.
    Erik WeeseDecember 30, 2009
    Regular slice, grandma slice, buffallo chicken slice, salad slice. Baked ziti. Chicken parm.you can not go wrong
  • Russ L.
    Russ LangeJune 18, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    Been coming here since 1982 still rocks!!!!!!!!
  • Zachary S.
    Zachary StephenFebruary 14, 2013
    Been here 10+ times
    Good pizza, just a lil pricy...
  • Matthew B.
    Matthew BermanDecember 22, 2011
    Been here 25+ times
    Chicken parm is the best but its all mine lol
  • Jessica M.
    Jessica MonahanAugust 4, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    The best house salad and bread ever.
  • Magdolen K.
    Magdolen KellelNovember 24, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    everything and anything is amazing.
  • John E.
    John ErigoJuly 21, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    BEST salad dressing in the World!!!!!!!!!
  • Cris G.
    Cris GJanuary 22, 2011
    the grandma and buffalo slices are orgazmic
  • Howie W.
    Howie WAugust 24, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    Best Buffalo Chicken pizza bar none!
  • Steve C.
    Steve CerrutoFebruary 25, 2014
    Food was very good
  • Rachele D.
    Rachele DaltonJuly 4, 2011
    Such good food! Miss this place!
  • Sandy E.
    Sandy EugeneJuly 29, 2013
    My slice was a little salty:/
  • Stefanie D.
    Stefanie DSeptember 18, 2010
    They have no variety and the regular slice isn't very good. Not enough room to sit without having waitered service, either.
  • Doug B.
    Doug BernsteimJanuary 14, 2010
    Try the buffalo pizza or chicken roll.
  • Greg G.
    Greg G.February 9, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    Best pizza in the area!
  • AdotRobles
    AdotRoblesFebruary 11, 2010
    Been here 25+ times
    Grilled Chicken Parm is the best!!
  • Chris V.
    Chris ValentinoSeptember 28, 2011
    Found a hair in my salad pizza and they didn't even offer to comp the $3.25 out of the $30 check..wow
  • Jillian S.
    Jillian SchwartzOctober 28, 2010
    Love the food
35 Photos

Related Searches

  • mama theresa's garden city park
  • mama theresa's garden city park photos
  • mama theresa's garden city park location
  • mama theresa's garden city park address
  • mama theresa's garden city park
  • mama theresa garden city park
  • mama theresa's garden city park
  • mama theresa's - garden city park garden city park
  • mama theresa's pizzeria & restaurant garden city park
  • mama theresa's pizzeria and restaurant garden city park
  • mama theresas garden city park
  • mama theresas garden city park garden city park
  • mama theresas pizzeria & restaurant garden city park

Foursquare © 2016  Lovingly made in NYC & SF