Maysville

New American Restaurant, Cocktail Bar, and Southern / Soul Food Restaurant$$$$
NoMad, New York
Save
Share
9.1/10
952
ratings
221 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • bourbon
  • crispy grits
  • cocktails
  • oysters
  • lively
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent
  • Luciefer
    LucieferNovember 9, 2014
    Came here for brunch and had the chef's plate. Fried eggs were perfect, sausage and potatoes were great, biscuit was amazing and the Whiskey Milk Fizz blew my mind. Can't wait to go back.
    Upvoted Dec 3, 2016
  • Risa
    RisaJanuary 4, 2013
    Boasts the largest Amer. whiskey collection in the world. Order the Poached Egg or Brussels Sprouts apps FTW, and follow up w Braised Pork Shoulder & Belly. Wash it down w a Spicy Buck cocktail.
  • 7th.List
    7th.ListNovember 12, 2012
    Features New American fare with quite a bit of seafood on the menu, as well as seasonal dishes. A selection of bourbon cocktails, a diverse beer list, and wines by the glass. Read more
  • Seth M.
    Seth McGuireOctober 1, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Great for tasting variety. Top shelf is $$, but selection is great. BMH is $50/1oz glass; I get bottles for $42. But at lower level they have old Taylor & heaven hill for $3/glass which is amazing
  • Nora R.
    Nora RawnJune 22, 2013
    Great bourbon list, if a bit overloud. Service is brisk to perhaps a fault but the corn muffins are fresh from the oven and the beef carpaccio is one of the most tender out there. From Char 4's owner.
  • Layla K.
    Came for brunch and had my mind blown by those Hay Roasted Oysters. Very good Bloody Mary and tasty pulled pork sandwich with whiskey pickles. Will be back for crispy grits & Brussels sprouts!
  • Russell H.
    Russell HirschornSeptember 14, 2015
    Huge selection of whiskey and bourbon. Modern bar, across from hill country. Can put a dent in your pocket just for a few drinks. Very informative bartenders.
  • Monica C.
    Monica CullenJune 23, 2016
    Had the Arctic Char in a cream sauce with peas and roasted strawberries! So delicious! Maysville also has an affordable wine list and a really good Sancerre Rosé. Reservations are recommended!
  • G I.
    G IApril 25, 2014
    Been here 5+ times
    Very nice place. Order any fish meal and you won't be disappointed. Slow cooked char (spring recipe) is very nice. Smoked trout is great as well.
  • Christopher T.
    Christopher TaiJune 30, 2013
    Been here 10+ times
    Start with the fluke tartare and the crispy grits. The duck breast medium rare with strawberries, spring onions and fois gras was divine. Get a 2 oz glass of Lagavulin Distiller's Edition!
  • IrmaZandl T.
    PHENOMENAL. Wonderful cocktails and the food was great. We started with the grits appetizer and shared the brick chicken and the arctic char dishes. Only miss: the key lime pie.
  • SELENA
    SELENAFebruary 3, 2014
    why they choose to oversalt the beautiful ingredients in the dishes is beyond me. fresh, delicious product masked by a heavy hand makes for a sad diner in me.
    Upvoted Dec 29, 2016
  • Eric V.
    Eric VenkerAugust 30, 2015
    Consistently good food at the bar (even when the kitchen is closed and menu is limited), and the whiskey selection is hard to match. Good cocktails to go along with it, you won't be upset.
  • Andie S.
    Andie SleemanDecember 14, 2016
    If you consider yourself a whiskey lover you must go here. You will discover something new or find that rare bottle you've been searching for. The food is really wonderful too!! Go here now!
  • Maire G.
    Maire GriffinJuly 12, 2013
    The pulled pork sandwich was lick the juice off dripping down your hand good. And the homemade chips were addictive. Will definitely return to make better use of the bourbon selection!
  • Ranu R.
    Ranu RajkarnikarJanuary 10, 2015
    Great bourbon selection and a nice place for cocktails in NoMad. They have food too. Brussel sprout something smelled insanely good.
  • suz q.
    suz qMarch 23, 2015
    Great bourbon selection. Good meal. Portions vary to very small to huge depending on what to order. Fish and chicken were good. Flatbread yummy.
  • Erika P.
    Erika PerziOctober 22, 2013
    I really liked this place: something super for everyone with solid cocktails and wines by the glass. Loved the autumn salad and hay roasted oysters; nice bourbon martinis!
  • Mandi V.
    Mandi VanceNovember 20, 2014
    The crispy grits & smoked whitefish mousse are amazing app's to share. Don't order the pasta appetizer-- the 4 small pieces of ravioli with a sliver of crab on top is offensive for a $18 price tag.
  • Marlynn W.
    Marlynn WestDecember 11, 2015
    The "Guns n Roses" is a shot of Four Roses Bourbon and a bottle of Rum aged Innis&Gunn beer. $14. How perfect is that??
  • amy p.
    amy pelletierFebruary 21, 2015
    Been here 10+ times
    Happy to have Maysville as a neighborhood spot. Chicken under a brick is incredible, along with the crispy grits & cornbread. Amazing crudos as well.
  • sara n.
    sara ngFebruary 24, 2014
    Try the poached farm egg with duck confit to start, the sea bass as a main, and the goat cheese cheesecake to finish. Aside: Menus change seasonally.
  • Jerry J.
    Jerry JosephJune 15, 2016
    Pork belly does not taste as fatty as its namesake would suggest. It's soooo goooood!!! The free cornbread is delicious and of course, whiskey. 'Nuff said.
  • Jason N.
    Jason NewbergMarch 15, 2015
    The smoked whole trout was amazing, as were the roasted oysters. Bonus, Bill Nye was eating next to us!
  • Ben W.
    Ben WOctober 13, 2013
    Smoked trout was outstanding. "Gold in the River" drink pairing delicious. Hay oysters a must. Stuffed pasta less successful, and Royale cocktail a miss.
  • Ryan J.
    Ryan JorgensonJanuary 10, 2015
    Chat No 4 with Manhattan prices, but the quality is on point. The whitefish mousse is a highlight, as well as the whisk(e)y selection, of course.
  • Serious Eats
    Serious EatsMarch 20, 2013
    As good as sophisticated southern food gets in New York. Amazing pulled pork sandwich on the lunch menu.
  • Christine L.
    Christine LustigMay 17, 2013
    Great spot! Loved the decor and I loved everything we tried on the menu! Must Orders: Crab Toast, Roasted Oysters, Crispy Grits & Smoked Trout.
  • Chris T.
    Chris ThurberMarch 1, 2015
    Amazing service, delicious food, and an unbelievable selection of bourbon and whiskey. Great date spot.
  • Abbie W.
    Abbie WAugust 8, 2014
    R29: Southern restaurant, 200-plus bourbon collection. The chef is from Alabama. Crispy grits, beef tartare, quiche, bacon bourbon Bloody Mary.
  • Benjamin B.
    Benjamin BlackOctober 31, 2016
    Incredible Arctic char fish dish. Bourbon harvest cocktail is a perfect match for the experience.
  • @HungryEditor B.
    @HungryEditor Ben SetiawanSeptember 15, 2015
    Been here 10+ times
    The highlights are the crispy grits, any drink with bourbon & meat dishes...especially pork. There's a back room great for private events.
  • Cameron M.
    Cameron MadduxNovember 23, 2015
    The crispy grits is one of my favorite dishes in all NYC - the hay roasted oysters also makes the list. So many bourbons!
  • Mohnish S.
    Mohnish SaniJuly 17, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    It's all about those crispy grits. Get them for the table and you won't regret it. Top it off with a Bulleit and Gunn from the cocktail menu
  • Ashley M.
    Ashley MaNovember 5, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    Amazing bourbon selection, great southern-inflected menu, eat anything involving duck. Or marrow. Or pig. Great addition to the neighborhood!
  • Emily S.
    Emily SchlossmanOctober 26, 2016
    The flatbread was fantastic. Enjoyed everything we got- other standouts were the delicious Manhattan and the boneless chicken wings app.
  • Michelle C.
    Michelle C.April 2, 2013
    American whiskey bar & restaurant with a menu of smoked & charred food and raw/ chilled seafood- Try the crispy grits, poached egg and bread pudding
  • Spotted by Locals - city guides by locals
    Try one of their many bourbon-based drink. The bartenders will be happy to guide you through their extensive menu of bourbon-based libations. Read more
  • Josephine S.
    Josephine SonJanuary 20, 2014
    Been here 10+ times
    Want to learn about American whiskey? Get yourself here pronto! Bartenders will take you on a great journey. Wonder how long it will take me to get through all the bottles?
  • Cynthia L.
    Cynthia LinJanuary 8
    Really well priced and unique food! Crispy grits, white fish mousse, under brick chicken and all desserts were great!!!
  • citizenM
    citizenMApril 7, 2015
    Dine there for the raw seafood and smoked fish, and some traditional Southern comfort items Read more
  • Sarah R.
    Sarah RaymondFebruary 6, 2013
    Duck confit and grits; hay-roasted oysters; smoked whitefish mousse; brussels sprouts; crispy chicken leg and roulade; smoked trout; apple granita.
  • Robert R.
    Robert RobinsonSeptember 21, 2014
    This place knows whisky! After the kitchen closes, the table seating opens up for drinking as well. Be adventurous with your drink choice.
  • Mark J.
    Mark J.January 31, 2015
    Fabulous oysters, donuts and brunch fare. The bacon is TO DIE FOR.
  • Zack P.
    Zack PackerAugust 13, 2014
    If you want everything bourbon-themed, you've come to the right place. Rich and sophisticated comfort food is the name of the game.
  • jon f.
    jon ferrerMarch 10, 2015
    Nice selection of bourbon and surprisingly good food. The shrimp toast, crispy grits, and smoked trout are highlights.
  • Kenny T.
    Kenny TApril 6, 2015
    Beautiful bar and delicious crispy grits, fluke tartar and donut!
  • Jennifer K.
    Jennifer KFebruary 20, 2013
    Brussels sprouts are incredible! We almost ordered a second as we loved it so much. Don't bother with the winter veg salad- nothing special
  • The Tastes that Make the City
    The old fashioned is the best bourbon cocktail in NYC, making our list of "The Tastes That Make the City: NYC Edition." Read more
  • Eric T.
    Eric TashFebruary 5, 2013
    Great scotch/bourbon selection. The table ordered the grits, brussel sprouts and I got the steak -- all superb.
568 Photos