Maysville

New American Restaurant, Cocktail Bar, and Southern / Soul Food Restaurant
17 W 26th St (at Broadway), New York, NY 10010, United States
Hours:
Open until 11:00 PM (Show more)
  • Mon–Thu
    • 11:30 AM–11:00 PM
  • Fri
    • 11:30 AM–Midnight
  • Sat
    • 11:00 AM–Midnight
  • Sun
    • 11:00 AM–11:00 PM
Price:
$ $ $ $
Menus:
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks:
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
Credit Cards:
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi:
Yes
Outdoor Seating:
No

American Restaurant & Whiskey Bar

9.1/10

Based on 594 votes

People like this place

Save
Share
  • What you need to know
    Kenny T.
    "Beautiful bar and delicious crispy grits, fluke tartar and donut!"(20 Tips)
    Derk D.
    "Excellent selection of bourbons, ryes and whiskers."(7 Tips)
    Erika H.
    "Loved the autumn salad and hay roasted oysters"(4 Tips)
    Gordon M.
    "The duck confit is so good here."(4 Tips)
Log in to leave tips at this venue!
Sort:
  • Recent
  • Popular

171 tips and reviews.

  • Filter by taste:
  • all tips and reviews
  • bourbon
  • crispy grits
  • oysters
  • cocktails
  • pulled pork sandwich
  • lively
  • trendy
  • good for dates
  • tartare
  • authentic
  • desserts
  • brunch food
  • poached eggs
  • duck
  • wine
  • bone marrow
  • whitefish
  • great value
  • good for a late night
  • cozy
  • Eric V.

    Consistently good food at the bar (even when the kitchen is closed and menu is limited), and the whiskey selection is hard to match. Good cocktails to go along with it, you won't be upset.

    Eric Venker · 1 day ago
    Save
  • James M.

    Pricey side, more of a work related gathering

    James Mullany · July 31
    Save
  • Marc M.

    everyrhing!

    Marc Maynard · July 27
    Save
  • Mike M.

    Bring the corporate Amex. And a solid knowledge of bourbon.

    Mike McBryan · July 21
    Save
  • Jessica C.

    Shrimp toast, blueberry milk sherbet, cornbread and bourbon chocolate on the house :)

    Jessica Cheng · July 14
    Save
  • Trae F.

    Hay roasted oyster and bourbon. The perfect combination.

    Trae F · July 12
    Save
  • Catherine P.

    My boyfriend from Kentucky approves of this spot !

    Catherine Park · July 11
    Save
  • Jacqueline V.

    Try the French Toast....amazing!

    Save
  • Cindy S.

    Crispy oyster sandwich

    Save
  • Neil C.

    Bourbon selection

    Neil Caron · June 2
    Save
  • Nick J.

    The arugula salad at lunch is a great choice.

    Nick Jordan · June 2
    Save
  • Josh B.

    Huge selection of bourbon and whiskey. Bartenders know their stuff. Delicious old fashioned!

    Josh Berkowitz · May 17
    Save
  • miles l.

    Huge whisky selection. Brunch portions are large. For dinner get the flatbread

    miles lennon · May 3
    Save
  • April Kate 🍴

    Get the old fashioned

    April Kate 🍴 · April 23
    Save
  • April Kate 🍴

    Get the duck and finish with an old fashioned

    April Kate 🍴 · April 18
    Save
  • citizenM

    Dine there for the raw seafood and smoked fish, and some traditional Southern comfort items Read more

    citizenM · April 7
    Save
  • Kenny T.

    Beautiful bar and delicious crispy grits, fluke tartar and donut!

    Kenny T · April 6
    Save
  • suz q.

    Great bourbon selection. Good meal. Portions vary to very small to huge depending on what to order. Fish and chicken were good. Flatbread yummy.

    suz q · March 23
    Save
  • Liz D.

    Crazy whiskey selection. Recommend committing to dinner and getting a table, bar gets very crowded because of layout.

    Liz Dell · March 22
    Save
  • David S.

    Great bourbon selection and bartender's recommendations were spot on.

    David Stephens · March 16
    Save
  • Jason N.

    The smoked whole trout was amazing, as were the roasted oysters. Bonus, Bill Nye was eating next to us!

    Jason Newberg · March 15
    Save
  • jon f.

    Nice selection of bourbon and surprisingly good food. The shrimp toast, crispy grits, and smoked trout are highlights.

    jon ferrer · March 10
    Save
  • Ryan

    Crispy Grits and Crispy Oysters 😍

    Ryan · March 6
    Save
  • Shah

    The drinks are on point and the chicken (under brick) is spectacular. Also, great horse drawings.

    Shah · March 6
    Save
  • Chris T.

    Amazing service, delicious food, and an unbelievable selection of bourbon and whiskey. Great date spot.

    Chris Thurber · March 1
    Save
  • Brynne Z.

    The grilled oysters are served on top of smoky hay, and smell amazing.

    Brynne Z · March 1
    Save
  • Matt S.

    Incredible selection of rye and whiskey - and solid bar snack game. It's a keeper.

    Matt Spector · February 25
    Save
  • amy p.

    Happy to have Maysville as a neighborhood spot. Chicken under a brick is incredible, along with the crispy grits & cornbread. Amazing crudos as well.

    amy pelletier · February 21
    Save
  • Mike M.

    Extensive bourbon list and very tasty food - but probably better left for dinner with the parents and / or the corporate amex.

    Mike McBryan · February 17
    Save
  • Liva

    Try the grits. Go if you like whisky, they have a very decent choice.

    Liva · February 16
    Save
  • Luis A.

    Ir por ut o

    Luis Alban · February 13
    Save
  • Vaibhav P.

    The craft whiskey tasting is delicious. Fascinating to see the new variety being created in US

    Vaibhav P · February 3
    Save
  • Mark J.

    Fabulous oysters, donuts and brunch fare. The bacon is TO DIE FOR.

    Mark Jahnke · January 31
    Save
  • Jamie F.

    Old Fashioned

    Jamie Friedman · January 29
    Save
  • Tara T.

    The food. The Bourbon. The service. Awesome lunch NoMad spot!

    Tara Tara · January 29
    Save
  • Harish H.

    Try every bourbon you can.. And the food is pretty good too!

    Harish Hoon · January 29
    Save
  • Gordon M.

    The duck confit is so good here.

    Gordon Mei · January 29
    Save
  • The Tastes that Make the City

    The old fashioned is the best bourbon cocktail in NYC, making our list of "The Tastes That Make the City: NYC Edition." Read more

    Save
  • Hannah B.

    Braised beef filled pasta 👌

    Hannah B. · January 25
    Save
  • Ricky S.

    I recommend this place for drinks or dinner. They have a nice selection of bourbon. The food is very good.

    Ricky Sherrill · January 19
    Save
  • Denrael

    Best Whiskey Bar I've visited. Thanks to Jane for being so knowledgeable and making it a great experience.

    Denrael · January 14
    Save
  • Ranu R.

    Great bourbon selection and a nice place for cocktails in NoMad. They have food too. Brussel sprout something smelled insanely good.

    Ranu Rajkarnikar · January 10
    Save
  • Ryan J.

    Chat No 4 with Manhattan prices, but the quality is on point. The whitefish mousse is a highlight, as well as the whisk(e)y selection, of course.

    Ryan Jorgenson · January 10
    Save
  • kate k

    If you have a choice between coming for dinner or brunch, choose dinner, ambience is cosier.

    kate k · December 30, 2014
    Save
  • Michael M.

    Bourbon menu so long it should have a table of contents.

    Michael Muse · December 14, 2014
    Save
  • Daniel M.

    The Nor'easter cocktail is amazing. And I am not a lover of fancy cocktails.

    Daniel Motta Mello · December 14, 2014
    Save
  • DK H.

    Great selection of drinks!! Luv Luv this place!!!

    DK Hayes · December 13, 2014
    Save
  • Jennifer T.

    Get the pumpkin popcorn dessert. Seriously, stop looking at your phone and just order it.

    Jennifer Terry · December 7, 2014
    Save
  • Melissa R.

    Whiskey and baked oysters. What more could you ask for?

    Melissa Rosenthal · November 27, 2014
    Save
  • Dylan B.

    Great bourbon line up. Bartenders can make some good suggestions.

    Dylan Boyd · November 24, 2014
    Save

Appears on 840 lists

See all »

Is this your business? Claim it now.

Make sure your information is up to date. Plus use our free tools to find new customers.