McGillicuddy's Restaurant & Tap House

Pub, American Restaurant, and Bar$$$$
New Paltz
Save
Share
6.9/10
107
ratings
  • Rachel M.
    "free fishbowl"(2 Tips)
    Bradley S.
    "Try the bourbon chicken wings they are awesome!!"(17 Tips)
    Bola B.
    "awesome coconut BBQ wings"(3 Tips)
    Katherine M.
    "They do have a good beer selection though."(3 Tips)
32 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • chicken wings
  • fishbowl
  • Irish nachos
  • DJs
  • great value
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent
  • JT T.
    JT TeranMarch 8, 2016
    The famous McGillicuddy's lives up to its name with its world-renowed wings and sauces. Extremely underrated though are its burgers and sandwiches. Pick whatever you want, it'll all be good.
  • Bradley S.
    Bradley SacksJanuary 1, 2014
    Go here for appetizers especially the chicken wings. Also try ordering an Adam's apple or a cuddys shandy! #newpaltz @mcgillcuddys
  • Anthony D.
    Anthony DedrickJanuary 2, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Best wings, IMO, in the Hudson Valley. Really great atmosphere and people who work and patronize there. One of the reasons I miss living in New Paltz
  • Rachel M.
    Rachel MarabellJuly 15, 2014
    Been here 25+ times
    awesome place to hang with your friends...you get a free fishbowl on your birthday!
  • Emma T.
    Emma TulipJuly 19, 2015
    Mac and cheese bites were delish. Another order please!
  • Joe P.
    Joe PruntyFebruary 13, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    Great wings and the irish nachos rule! However what's with the renovations to the bathroom? Those urines are way small..
  • Nicole P.
    Nicole PelletiereOctober 16, 2011
    Sweet hot BBQ wings are amazing...sit at the bar...don't bother waiting for a table
  • Steve D.
    Steve DermentzisAugust 13, 2013
    Don't see the chicken and ribs on the menu. Used to love that meal when I went to college here.
  • Cailin W.
    Cailin WelchMay 1, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    Good place to chill with friends! I recommend going on nights with the live bands.
  • Flo Flo
    Flo FloJuly 30, 2013
    Do not come here! The worst service of my life...oohhh and the waitress decided to charge us whatever she wanted for the meal. I had to get the manager involved. The food is not worth the service!
  • Greg T.
    Greg ThompsonSeptember 13, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    3 wings for $20 every night! $9 bud lights! Best deals in town!
  • Bradley S.
    Bradley SacksJanuary 1, 2014
    Try the bourbon chicken wings they are awesome!!
  • Joe M.
    Joe MooreSeptember 18, 2011
    Been here 100+ times
    Party Rock Saturdays with NYC's DJ Joe Fresh every Saturday night.
  • Bola B.
    Bola BOctober 2, 2011
    awesome coconut BBQ wings
  • Nick M.
    Nick MorrisAugust 20, 2011
    Monday night, wing night 35 cent wings
  • Katie G.
    Katie GambinoAugust 6, 2011
    They serve food til 4am fjucking awesome!!!
  • K.C. J.
    K.C. JonesJuly 20, 2016
    My wife loves the wings!
  • Amber B.
    Amber Button-NoseFebruary 1, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Love the photo booth!
  • Carrie K.
    Carrie KovacsDecember 25, 2011
    Awesome food great service.
  • Joseph H.
    Joseph HainesAugust 25, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    The food sucked but it was cheap and there was a lot of it. The kitchen is open late.
  • La. Y.
    La. YilmazJanuary 18, 2015
    Been here 5+ times
    Warm beer!
  • Suzy B.
    Suzy BerkowitzNovember 26, 2011
    Waffle fries and onion rings!
  • Katherine M.
    Katherine MeyerinkApril 6, 2011
    The food was a little disappointing, but decent. They do have a good beer selection though.
  • DJ Z.
    DJ ZamzamJune 27, 2010
    Monday Wing Night! 35 cent wings!
  • Pete S.
    Pete SosMay 18, 2012
    woah, attractive wait staff
  • Theresa F.
    Theresa Florio💍🎀January 27, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    Fishbowl Fridays.... nuff said!
  • Alix P.
    Alix PerlmanFebruary 18, 2010
    Great bar food, good drinks. Get wings!
  • Daniel M.
    Daniel MaxsonNovember 16, 2010
    Yo wing nite bro. Miller lite girls here tonite
  • Sebastian N.
    Sebastian NorenaMay 9, 2010
    $1 taco thursdays!
  • La. Y.
    La. YilmazMay 6, 2015
    Been here 5+ times
    Worst wings in town...
  • Nicole C.
    Nicole CaroleiJanuary 16, 2012
    Horrible service hair in my food n the wings look like shit
  • Tanye W.
    Tanye WestOctober 2, 2011
    Dont bother. Terrible food, terrible service, warm beer
64 Photos

Related Searches

  • mcgillicuddy's restaurant & tap house new paltz
  • mcgillicuddy's restaurant & tap house new paltz photos
  • mcgillicuddy's restaurant & tap house new paltz location
  • mcgillicuddy's restaurant & tap house new paltz address
  • mcgillicuddy's restaurant & tap house new paltz
  • mccillicuddy's resturant& bar new paltz
  • mccillicuddy's resturantand bar new paltz
  • mccillicuddys resturant& bar new paltz
  • mcgillicuddy's new paltz
  • mcgillicuddy's restaurant & tap house new paltz
  • mcgillicuddy's restaurant & tap room new paltz
  • mcgillicuddy's restaurant and tap house new paltz
  • mcgillicuddy's restaurant and tap room new paltz
  • mcgillicuddys new paltz
  • mcgillicuddys restaurant & tap house new paltz

Foursquare © 2017  Lovingly made in NYC & SF