Hey the eggplant pie, it's the best one on the menu!
Doors open at 3:00 p.m. on Sunday
Best pizza ever
Pretty much all their pizza.
Try the Clams Casino
We just had a Margherita pizza, but it was some of the best I've had. Definitely going back!
Love the pizza and bruschetta to start
Best pizza ever!!!
One of my favorite places
Pizza is great !
Get there early because you will wait in line. Everything is good and the pies are huge
Nice love it there
ITLALIAN BOMB blows all the competition away
modern is just as good as pepe's can't go wrong with a classic pepperoni pie!
Amazing pizza - freshly made dough and cheese. Try the eggplant!
Came here solo and got half Clan Casino, half Italian Bomb. Very generous portions of meat, amazingly crispy and crunchy pizza.
Magnificent. BEST PIZZA EVER ! A must-eat in New Haven. With so much pizza restaurants in town, I could not believe another place could even survive. Seriously, get pizza here. It's life-changing.
Not my favorite.
Whats not good here?????
Pizza is great
The pizza is really good and the calzone is even better.
If you can deal with the line worth the wait--park on a side street
Really good traditional New Haven pizza. Delicious
Italian bomb: bacon, sausage, pepperoni, garlic, mushrooms, onion and pepper
Try the Italian Bomb Pizza - Bacon, sausage, pepperoni, mushroom, onion, pepper, garlic
Try the Chicken Cutlet Grinder - Awesome
Off the Hook !!!
Takeout window get you a pie in 15 in a busy night.
Eggplant pizza is to die for!
Very gd pizza
Pizza with clam is the best!!! Love it
Eggplant and mushroom pizza makes the world go round
Try the white crab pizza for a truly worthwhile experience.
Great, GREAT pizza (apizz) at good prices and in abundance. And here, the wait is 1/3 the time you endure at Frank Pepe's up the street, and dare I say it?, the pizza is nearly as good. Go!
Spinach, onion, garlic. Mmmm!
pepes and sallys are both for tourists! go modern or go home
best of the New Haven style pizza places even though less hype
Crabmeat is imitation crab not real crabmeat. Otherwise great pizza!
Modern is probably the best pizza in New Haven. Try the veggie bomb!
Try the American Cheese Pie! Add tomatoes and bacon too!!
Pie with cherry peppers hits the spot
The Italian Bomb is the signature apizza here - if you like meaty, veggie-laden slices, it's the
Love love love Modern! By far the best around!
Modern is the BEST for pizza! No one compares!!
Order the white clam pie. Ask no questions.