Planning a trip to Atlanta?

Foursquare can help you find the best places to go to.

New York Pizza Exchange

Pizza Place$$$$
Atlanta
Save
Share
7.6/10
78
ratings
  • Jim S.
    "Best pizza in ATL the Tuesday trivia is fun as well"(3 Tips)
    Divah
    "... NY style) Even better stromboli! I like the pizza rolls appetizer. I'll be..."(3 Tips)
    Christine M.
    "authentic italian pasta dishes"(2 Tips)
    P. Darrell K.
    "Live music on Friday & Saturday evenings"(2 Tips)
37 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • pizza
  • trivia
  • baked ziti
  • outdoor seating
  • live music
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent
  • James Floyd K.
    James Floyd KellyMarch 17, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Some of the reviewers here must be neurotic. Half toppings are allowed and the food is great. Get to know a waiter/waitress and they'll really try to get to know your typical order. Great place 4 kids
  • Christine M.
    Christine MorrisonFebruary 23, 2013
    Been here 10+ times
    New York Pizza Exchange is one of my favorite restaurants in Atlanta! Real NY style pizza & authentic italian pasta dishes in a relaxed, cozy environment. Enjoy!!
  • Divah
    DivahMarch 16, 2014
    Loccated next to RR tracks. Nice atmosphere with good music.Good pizza (tried the P.M.S NY style) Even better stromboli! I like the pizza rolls appetizer. I'll be back!
  • Moori A.
    Moori AbdulMarch 1, 2014
    Very delicious and filling. The medium pizza was huge. Way to much for a family of three. The name speaks for it's self. Tastes just like a NY brick oven pizza
  • Sean K.
    Sean KelleySeptember 30, 2011
    The dinner salads are amazing. Don't listen to the complainers. Most pizza places don't allow half toppings and I used to cook, mistakes happen anywhere. The customer service here is great!
  • Moori A.
    Moori AbdulMarch 1, 2014
    Superb. Medium pizza was to big for a family of three. The pizza was like an authentic NY brick oven pizza. Two thumbs up
  • Tam B.
    Tam ButlerSeptember 3, 2012
    They do DO half toppings, suggested to me by take-out cashier. White pizza is delicious, their crust is so tasty!
  • P. Darrell K.
    P. Darrell KimbrellAugust 11, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    always great pizza & the baked ziti is fantastic.... Live music on Friday & Saturday evenings
  • John S.
    John ScaleraSeptember 28, 2011
    Things needed if you eat here; 1. BYOPC, bring your own pizza cutter 2. Bring an old shirt our preferably a towel for the grease. 3. A sense of humor, because you will laugh at what you had to pay for
  • Bertelie
    BertelieDecember 21, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    I got a pie and they put meat on only two slices for me, so they definitely accommodate you and make the customer happy!!
  • David C.
    David CantwellOctober 4, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    Ask for the foreign waiter (not sure about the name). He freakin' amazing. Always knows my order.
  • Bobby A.
    Bobby AsareApril 10, 2010
    my friend owns this place... its beautiful right next to the railroad, sit outside and have a pizza... specially if you have a kid, your kids will love the train passing by
  • Christopher M.
    Christopher MuseDecember 30, 2015
    We go every Tuesday for the great food and Trivia.
  • Kim N.
    Kim NNovember 23, 2010
    Been here 10+ times
    They frequently have a two slices for 4.99+drink special. Ask your server about it, and/or check the sign outside!
  • Chai O.
    Chai OdomDecember 13, 2013
    Excellent pizza joint, and half off for military in uniform!
  • Ryan S.
    Ryan ShannonAugust 4, 2013
    Good stuff! Kind of expensive, but you won't be disappointed.
  • Kurt
    KurtFebruary 13, 2011
    We ordered the "Special" Pizza and the waitress said we HAD to choose 5 toppings or else the manager would yell and cause a scene!
  • Kerry M.
    Kerry MannOctober 13, 2011
    Take-out wings and garlic bread. Great for a night in front of the ball game on tv.
  • Roger
    RogerApril 20, 2013
    Awful experience today! Stephanie, our waitress, was great. Jason, on the other hand, was very rude! We asked to leave a slice worth of toppings off our pizza (for our nephew) and he said no. Really?
  • Jim S.
    Jim StevensonMarch 7, 2012
    Best pizza in ATL the Tuesday trivia is fun as well
  • Heena P.
    Heena PatelAugust 15, 2014
    Been here 10+ times
    The Joe Boli pizza is soooo good!!
  • Lindsay W.
    Lindsay WilliamsJuly 3, 2016
    Pizza, beer and patio
  • Gina
    GinaApril 27, 2012
    Been here 50+ times
    The meatball roll is delicious !
  • Tip
    TipNovember 27, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    Don't forget to check in with My Fav Eats
  • Brooke H.
    Brooke HeinzFebruary 15, 2012
    Come play trivia Tuesday Nights at 8pm!
  • Jeremy L.
    Jeremy LindemannAugust 17, 2014
    Try the stromboli!
  • Kerri
    KerriMay 4, 2012
    Used to have awesome food, just ok now. Hadn't been in years and was a little disappointed:(
  • Chris E.
    Chris E.January 23, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    Try the pink sauce! Its awesome!
  • Bob 💲☎🍒Ⓜ♒ M.
    Yes very similar to Chuck n Cheese
  • Turo R.
    Turo RamirezJune 20, 2013
    Never will we ever eat at this place again they dare to serve a burnt Sicilian to us.. very disappointed giving New York Pizza a bad name
  • Kurt
    KurtFebruary 13, 2011
    Also, she said they do NOT do half toppings because the manager will get mad.
  • Robby C.
    Robby CainSeptember 1, 2014
    Awesome pizza
  • Mike L.
    Mike LaddOctober 18, 2013
    At 10:01 they won't make a chicken Parm sub to go?
  • Kurt
    KurtFebruary 13, 2011
    I asked for no tomatoes on my salad, and guess what? Tomatoes!
  • Bobby A.
    Bobby AsareAugust 17, 2011
    Amazing pizza
  • Ray E.
    Ray EdwardsOctober 8, 2011
    Ew- the Stromboli was a no go, and pricey for what you get.
  • Leah B.
    Leah BugMay 11, 2010
    Try the bobby and leah special
54 Photos

Related Searches

  • new york pizza exchange atlanta
  • new york pizza exchange atlanta photos
  • new york pizza exchange atlanta location
  • new york pizza exchange atlanta address
  • new york pizza exchange atlanta
  • new york pizza exchange atlanta
  • ny pizza exchange atlanta

Foursquare © 2017  Lovingly made in NYC & SF