Planning a trip to Atlanta?

Foursquare can help you find the best places to go to.

New York Pizza Exchange

Pizza Place$$$$
  • Jim S.
    "Best pizza in ATL the Tuesday trivia is fun as well"(3 Tips)
    Jeremy L.
    "Try the stromboli!"(3 Tips)
    Christine M.
    "authentic italian pasta dishes"(2 Tips)
    Devin W.
    "Get the wings!"(2 Tips)
37 Tips and reviews
  • pizza
  • trivia
  • Stromboli
  • baked ziti
  • outdoor seating
Log in to leave a tip here.

  • Popular
  • Recent
  • James Floyd K.
    James Floyd KellyMarch 17, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Some of the reviewers here must be neurotic. Half toppings are allowed and the food is great. Get to know a waiter/waitress and they'll really try to get to know your typical order. Great place 4 kids
  • Christine M.
    Christine MorrisonFebruary 23, 2013
    Been here 10+ times
    New York Pizza Exchange is one of my favorite restaurants in Atlanta! Real NY style pizza & authentic italian pasta dishes in a relaxed, cozy environment. Enjoy!!
  • Divah
    DivahMarch 16, 2014
    Loccated next to RR tracks. Nice atmosphere with good music.Good pizza (tried the P.M.S NY style) Even better stromboli! I like the pizza rolls appetizer. I'll be back!
  • Moori A.
    Moori AbdulMarch 1, 2014
    Very delicious and filling. The medium pizza was huge. Way to much for a family of three. The name speaks for it's self. Tastes just like a NY brick oven pizza
  • Sean K.
    Sean KelleySeptember 30, 2011
    The dinner salads are amazing. Don't listen to the complainers. Most pizza places don't allow half toppings and I used to cook, mistakes happen anywhere. The customer service here is great!
  • Moori A.
    Moori AbdulMarch 1, 2014
    Superb. Medium pizza was to big for a family of three. The pizza was like an authentic NY brick oven pizza. Two thumbs up
  • Tam B.
    Tam ButlerSeptember 3, 2012
    They do DO half toppings, suggested to me by take-out cashier. White pizza is delicious, their crust is so tasty!
  • P. Darrell K.
    P. Darrell KimbrellAugust 11, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    always great pizza & the baked ziti is fantastic.... Live music on Friday & Saturday evenings
  • John S.
    John ScaleraSeptember 28, 2011
    Things needed if you eat here; 1. BYOPC, bring your own pizza cutter 2. Bring an old shirt our preferably a towel for the grease. 3. A sense of humor, because you will laugh at what you had to pay for
  • Bertelie
    BertelieDecember 21, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    I got a pie and they put meat on only two slices for me, so they definitely accommodate you and make the customer happy!!
  • Christopher M.
    Christopher MuseDecember 30, 2015
    We go every Tuesday for the great food and Trivia.
  • Bobby A.
    Bobby AsareApril 10, 2010
    my friend owns this place... its beautiful right next to the railroad, sit outside and have a pizza... specially if you have a kid, your kids will love the train passing by
  • David C.
    David CantwellOctober 4, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    Ask for the foreign waiter (not sure about the name). He freakin' amazing. Always knows my order.
  • Kim N.
    Kim NNovember 23, 2010
    Been here 10+ times
    They frequently have a two slices for 4.99+drink special. Ask your server about it, and/or check the sign outside!
  • Chai O.
    Chai OdomDecember 13, 2013
    Excellent pizza joint, and half off for military in uniform!
  • Ryan S.
    Ryan ShannonAugust 4, 2013
    Good stuff! Kind of expensive, but you won't be disappointed.
  • Kurt
    KurtFebruary 13, 2011
    We ordered the "Special" Pizza and the waitress said we HAD to choose 5 toppings or else the manager would yell and cause a scene!
  • Kerry M.
    Kerry MannOctober 13, 2011
    Take-out wings and garlic bread. Great for a night in front of the ball game on tv.
  • Roger
    RogerApril 20, 2013
    Awful experience today! Stephanie, our waitress, was great. Jason, on the other hand, was very rude! We asked to leave a slice worth of toppings off our pizza (for our nephew) and he said no. Really?
  • Jim S.
    Jim StevensonMarch 7, 2012
    Best pizza in ATL the Tuesday trivia is fun as well
    Upvoted Aug 16
  • Heena P.
    Heena PatelAugust 15, 2014
    Been here 10+ times
    The Joe Boli pizza is soooo good!!
  • Lindsay W.
    Pizza, beer and patio
  • Jeremy L.
    Jeremy LindemannAugust 17, 2014
    Try the stromboli!
  • Gina
    GinaApril 27, 2012
    Been here 50+ times
    The meatball roll is delicious !
  • Brooke H.
    Brooke HeinzFebruary 15, 2012
    Come play trivia Tuesday Nights at 8pm!
  • Tip
    TipNovember 27, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    Don't forget to check in with My Fav Eats
  • Kerri
    KerriMay 4, 2012
    Used to have awesome food, just ok now. Hadn't been in years and was a little disappointed:(
  • Turo R.
    Turo RamirezJune 20, 2013
    Never will we ever eat at this place again they dare to serve a burnt Sicilian to us.. very disappointed giving New York Pizza a bad name
  • Chris E.
    Chris E.January 23, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    Try the pink sauce! Its awesome!
  • Kurt
    KurtFebruary 13, 2011
    Also, she said they do NOT do half toppings because the manager will get mad.
  • Devin W.
    Devin WebbJanuary 1, 2014
    Get the wings!
  • Robby C.
    Robby CainSeptember 1, 2014
    Awesome pizza
  • Mike L.
    Mike LaddOctober 18, 2013
    At 10:01 they won't make a chicken Parm sub to go?
  • Kurt
    KurtFebruary 13, 2011
    I asked for no tomatoes on my salad, and guess what? Tomatoes!
  • Bobby A.
    Bobby AsareAugust 17, 2011
    Amazing pizza
  • Ray E.
    Ray EdwardsOctober 8, 2011
    Ew- the Stromboli was a no go, and pricey for what you get.
  • Leah B.
    Leah BugMay 11, 2010
    Try the bobby and leah special
54 Photos

Related Searches

  • new york pizza exchange atlanta
  • new york pizza exchange atlanta photos
  • new york pizza exchange atlanta location
  • new york pizza exchange atlanta address
  • new york pizza exchange atlanta
  • new york pizza exchange atlanta
  • ny pizza exchange atlanta

Foursquare © 2016  Lovingly made in NYC & SF