New York Pizza Suprema

New York Pizza Suprema

Pizza Place$$$$
Chelsea, New York
295 Tips and reviews
  • pizza
  • penn station
  • upside
  • casual
  • good for a quick meal
Log in to leave a tip here.

  • Recent
  • Popular
  • Appropriately C.
    Perfect inexpensive, served hot n fast By the slice favorite margarita Tomato was sweet mozzarella flavorful long cheesy pull basil fresh crust perfectly thin had appropriate sweetness of the dough
  • Kevin S.
    Kevin S3 weeks ago
    Cheese. Slice. Wait for it.
  • John P.
    John ParkesNovember 12
    Salivating just remembering how good this was. As everyone else says, upside down is incredible (that velvety tomato sauce: yum). But also recommend the buffalo chicken. Just the right amount of heat.
  • Ahmad S
    Ahmad SOctober 15
    Big slices, new York style pizza, lots of cheese!
    Upvoted Oct 15
  • Nelly T.
    Nelly TejedaOctober 11
    Best pizza eveeeeer!
  • HM L.
    HM LuuSeptember 30
  • Quentin G.
    Great plain and chicken parm slices - not bad prices!!
  • Steven B.
    Steven BreaAugust 10
    One of the greatest New York style pizzas I've tried!! Will come back!!
  • Ahuva
    AhuvaJuly 27
    The sauce is really rich a(almost meaty), go for extra fresh mozzarella or upside down
  • Robert G.
    I tried this place the other day and I can honestly say it was amazing. Great food, great atmosphere, and excellent service. Will definitely be returning next time i'm in the area.
  • Tom C.
    Best Pizza I've ever had in NY hands down!
  • Jeffrey Y.
    Jeffrey YJune 23
    Been here 5+ times
    Upside down slice is superb!
  • Bryan L.
    Best slide in NY? Not an specialist but I've tried better NY slices in other countries. They are ok, but probably not the best
  • Alex R.
    still really like the slices, but it doesn't get much more expensive per unit besides like di fara or whatever
  • Karl S.
    some of the best pizza in the city
  • Kate Y.
    Kate YanApril 24
    Best option for food around Penn Station. They sell pizza by the slice and it's absolutely delicious, fast, and cheap.
  • Richard C.
    the pizza of course
  • Zsuzsanna M.
    Amazing pizza, just the right amount of crunchiness and cheese, great sauce, nice service and plenty of place to sit down. Don't be fooled by the dodgy looking facade!
  • MAQ
    MAQMarch 21
    Without a doubt, one of the best Pizza place in New York ( I've tried their Margarita, Chicken Buffalo & Fresh Mushroom and all were amazing 👌🏻)
  • Ron L.
    Ron LMarch 10
    Sausage pizza top notch
  • Herve L.
    What a spectacular place with a spectacular staff. They are a wealth of knowledge of the extensive drink menu and masters at preparing a cocktail.
  • Amy C.
    Amy CummingsFebruary 21
    Omg the upside down slice...
  • William D.
    William DoonanFebruary 6
    New York is known for it's great pizza, but I must say that this is the best I have ever had.
  • Ben W.
    Ben WongJanuary 31
    Way overpriced, even for NY standards. I would go across the street to Amadeus instead.
  • Alex R.
    Alex RobertsonJanuary 11
    Certainly one of the best slices I've had in New York
  • Sam S. J.
    Sam S. JainJanuary 11
    The upside-down slice is life changing. Highly recommend getting that.
  • Dionysis Z.
    Chicken onion bacon jalapeños slice was good.
  • David Z.
    David ZhangJanuary 7
    Some of the best pizza in the city, legitimately. Try the upside down (sorta like a mix between grandma and Chicago style), the white, or the suprema special.
  • Sascha R.
    Sascha RJanuary 6
    Real pizza, affordable! Try the Grandma Sicilian - it's awesome!
  • Ashlyn A.
    Ashlyn AiuDecember 28, 2016
    Best New York pizza. Will be back often. :)
  • Natalia S.
    Natalia SniegurDecember 26, 2016
    Cosy place with amazing pizza, loved Upside down and Hawaiian.
  • Jarel H.
    Jarel HillDecember 24, 2016
    Pepperoni Sicilian
  • Polina W.
    Polina WeitzDecember 10, 2016
    Love this place. Great success, large variety.
  • Drewski
    DrewskiDecember 3, 2016
    Upside down slice lived up to the hype. Everything else was legit too.
  • Rudy G.
    Rudy G.December 1, 2016
    Been here 5+ times
    Classic NY Pizza!!
  • Liat B.
    Liat BandielNovember 15, 2016
    Fresh & not expensive
  • Ryan Q.
    Ryan QuigleyOctober 29, 2016
    Either they make it bigger or they make the pizza worse.
  • Lance F.
    Lance FiascoOctober 29, 2016
    You won't leave without trying one of everything 👌
  • Mike F.
    Mike FriedlichOctober 17, 2016
    The pizza here is the best yet that I have had in NYC. I had the plain slice, and the sauce on it is so good I dont know how they do it. They are so good I could eat a whole pie.
  • Elizabeth L.
    Elizabeth LeeOctober 13, 2016
    Hands down, the best slice of pizza I have eaten in nyc. Upside down and white pizza!
  • Ricard T.
    Ricard TorresSeptember 25, 2016
    $9,5 for 2 slices of pepperoni and a soda. Good, big slices.
  • Serhan U.
    Serhan UygurAugust 29, 2016
  • Eric H.
    Eric HoAugust 20, 2016
    They serve delicious pizza by the slice! 🍕🍕🍕
  • Ahmed A.
    Ahmed AljabriAugust 12, 2016
    The vegetarian pizza is awesome
  • Omer D.
    Omer DaninAugust 12, 2016
    Superma special and the upside down pizza is pretty much all you need to get.
  • Rebecca G.
    Rebecca GAugust 5, 2016
    Been here 10+ times
    Grandma pie is amazing, get a slice if it's available!
  • Robert A.
    Robert AccetturaAugust 1, 2016
    Been here 10+ times
    Very good pizza, you can't really go wrong here. Sicilian is pretty hardy and surprisingly not terrible as most places that attempt it are, though slightly on the oily side.
  • Cassidy
    CassidyJuly 21, 2016
    best consistently good plain cheese slice in Manhattan.
  • Jonathan F.
    Jonathan FlorezJune 24, 2016
    White pizza and meat lovers were awesome. True, delicious NY pizza!
  • Lorenzo
    LorenzoJune 24, 2016
    Best pizza near Penn station.
  • Carlos S.
    Carlos SarziJune 10, 2016
    the best pizza ever!
  • Kodi M.
    Kodi McKinneyJune 7, 2016
    Been here 5+ times
    This is the type of place I hope tourists never have on their maps. Plain slice is better than Joe's. Easily in the top 3 cheese slices I've ever found.
  • Seline J.
    Seline JungJune 6, 2016
    Plain cheese pizza is on the salty side and the crust can get hard. But it is tasty enough.
  • ETC (.
    ETC (eaucanada)June 3, 2016
    The pizza!
  • Dennise M.
    Dennise MarieJune 1, 2016
    Loved The Suprema Special Pizza. Really great Sauce And big slices.
  • Leonardo V.
    Leonardo VillaMay 31, 2016
    Amazing. The place is welcoming and warm. The pizza is nearly-perfect. Yet, very casual. Try the siciliana with sausage. The price is super fair.
  • Nhm Tanveer Hossain K.
    Our last experience was completely bad, pizza was quite bland and dry.
  • Eric
    EricMay 27, 2016
    Been here 10+ times
    Grab a plain slice!
  • Bruno A.
    Bruno AlvesMay 21, 2016
    Amazing Pizza!
  • Patricio R.
    Patricio RuizMay 21, 2016
    This pizza lives up to the expectations. If you're looking for something different, try the white (garlic) pizza, or ask for the upside down. The latter shows what a good pizza sauce tastes like.
  • Roman T.
    Roman TemkinMay 12, 2016
    Best pizza spot in NYC!
  • Mischa
    MischaMay 10, 2016
    Best slice ever, you can't go wrong by being simple...order a cheese slice
  • David M.
    David MilbergMay 3, 2016
    Best pizza in NYC!
  • Percy C.
    Percy ChangMay 3, 2016
    Pizza lol!!!
  • David A.
    David AsabinaApril 23, 2016
    Good option for a quick meal
  • Xitij S.
    Xitij ShahApril 18, 2016
    It's good, but a little overrated.
  • Gennady B.
    Gennady BarskyApril 13, 2016
    Best pizza in NY hands down!
  • Gulam S.
    Gulam SamdaniApril 6, 2016
    best food guys go again
  • Gulam S.
    Gulam SamdaniApril 6, 2016
    Great food ssn
  • Gulam S.
    Gulam SamdaniApril 5, 2016
    very good food
  • Dan S.
    Dan SohaydaApril 5, 2016
    Quality pizza in a location with a good amount of booths to sit in, but one of the smallest bathrooms in NYC!
  • Carl F.
    Carl FigueiredoMarch 20, 2016
    As authentic as it gets. Stand in line, wait until you're spoken to, and be ready to shout out your order. All the classics, perfectly executed in a NY kind of way.
    Upvoted Nov 12
  • Kasey M.
    Kasey MaMarch 10, 2016
    Um. The upside-down slice is the bomb. I've never had a Sicilian like that before. Sauce was sweet AND savory. Unheard of. I just died and went to heaven. I would starve all day to eat 4 slices here.
  • Levant P.
    Levant PandaFebruary 25, 2016
    Good for quick slice
  • Levant P.
    Levant PandaFebruary 25, 2016
    I only had one slice late evening, but great for single slice. It's the sauce that really sets it apart from other places. Just get a couple cheese slices and you'll know how good this place is.
  • Josh A.
    Josh AFebruary 21, 2016
    Is there a pizza in New York which isn't delicious? The slice of pepperoni was solid.
  • Adam L.
    Adam LaiacanoFebruary 20, 2016
    Been here 5+ times
    Quite possibly the best slice shop in NYC. I go every time I'm in the area.
  • Rock Raines
    Rock RainesFebruary 17, 2016
    Upside down slice, chicken parm slice
  • chris c.
    chris campFebruary 9, 2016
    Been here 25+ times
    Upside down slice!
  • Gabriel H.
    Gabriel HayesJanuary 18, 2016
    Best place for pizza by the slice near Penn Station.
  • Kimmie O.
    Kimmie OhhDecember 8, 2015
    Like everyone has been saying - the best pizza around Penn Station!
  • Sahajesh
    SahajeshDecember 6, 2015
    Great slices - if you're at Penn Stn or MSG come here 👍🏻
  • Tricia
    TriciaDecember 4, 2015
    Everything is good - seriously you can't go wrong here.
  • Josh D.
    Josh DantoDecember 1, 2015
    Been here 5+ times
    Good stuff! Always try to stop on by when I come through Penn Station.
  • Hector
    HectorNovember 23, 2015
    Best crust for a classic NYC pizza slice. Get the plain slice, and for toppings - ask for cold mozzarella.
  • Rosie H.
    Rosie HendersonNovember 22, 2015
    Great place for a quick bite. Not the best pizza in the city but pretty good.
  • Ben S.
    Ben SNovember 2, 2015
    Quick and cheap.
  • Carlos S.
    Carlos SevillaOctober 31, 2015
    Plain slice is perfect ny style pizza
  • natalie k.
    natalie kayOctober 27, 2015
    late night cheese and pepperoni
  • Elia C.
    Elia ClementeOctober 26, 2015
    The specialty slices are overflowing with choices. A simple 'regular' slice is a winner every time. Whatever your pizza craving is, these guys will have it. And it will be amazing.
  • Rod S.
    Rod SteedOctober 24, 2015
    Pricey, but it was worth every penny
  • Abdul
    AbdulOctober 10, 2015
    Pizza and spinach roll
  • Sammy L.
    Sammy LifsonOctober 10, 2015
    Been here 5+ times
    Best slice in Manhattan, according to Colin Atrophy Hagendorf who has eaten at every sliceria. He chronicles the story of Suprema in his new book, Slice Harvester!
  • Jen W.
    Jen WOctober 7, 2015
    Been here 5+ times
    best slice of pizza in NY! get a plain slice and let it cool down. perfect temperature to eat it at is room temp.
  • Yelimar R.
    Yelimar RodriguezOctober 3, 2015
    Best pizza in town!!! Their sauce is on pointe. Love their basil mozzarella, white slice, mushroom slice and the vegan slice (no cheese but HUGE on flavor).
  • Reeya S.
    Reeya ShahSeptember 30, 2015
    Amazing slices, very convenient to penn station, penn plaza, and MSG. Loved the sausage sicilian
  • Lily
    LilySeptember 27, 2015
    Quick and simple. Love the mushroom pizza
  • Tom W.
    Tom WrennSeptember 20, 2015
    So so so good white pizza slice
  • Gothamist
    GothamistSeptember 18, 2015
    A plain slice here runs $3, and is exactly what a slice of pizza should be—cheesy, crusty, and doused with a not-too-sweet, not-too-oniony tomato sauce. Read more
    Upvoted Sep 29
  • Karen F.
    Karen FormagioSeptember 18, 2015
    White pizza is the most exclusive and tastes really good!
  • Jack O.
    Jack OsborneSeptember 15, 2015
    There's a reason Slice Harvester rates this as his best reg slice in Manhattan. The crisp base folds perfectly, the cheese is packed full of flavour & the sauce is sweet. I went back for seconds.
  • Somnath S.
    Somnath SureshSeptember 7, 2015
    Best NYC slice ever
  • Andreana O.
    Andreana OccesSeptember 3, 2015
    Awesome selection to choose from and super friendly staff. Supreme Indeed! 🍕🍕
  • Bogdan G.
    Bogdan GunăSeptember 3, 2015
    Great pizza, lively place, good for groups
  • Ronnie R.
    Ronnie RothAugust 31, 2015
    Amazing slice! Probably the best in NY
  • Cole K.
    Cole KennedyAugust 24, 2015
    Sure, the slices are good (I liked the Margherita; the Sicilian had too much bread) but it feels criminal to pay $4 for a pizza slice.
  • D C.
    D C🐧August 22, 2015
    The pizza was so so...
  • Janet D.
    Janet De bieJuly 28, 2015
    The pizza crust was awesome
  • Ryan
    RyanJuly 25, 2015
    Solid stop next the MSG. Expect more given the hype. Stick with a plain slice
  • Thomas G.
    Thomas GayvertJuly 10, 2015
    Sicilian slices were delicious!
  • A S.
    A SJuly 4, 2015
    Every time I take the bus back to Boston, I stop here and grab a slice of pizza for the ride. The veggie medley was excellent and so was the mozzarella basil.
  • Emily
    EmilyJune 24, 2015
    One of our favorite quick slice stops
  • Garud I.
    Garud IyengarJune 21, 2015
    Undoubtedly the best pizza I've ever had. Start with the margherita and the upside-down.
  • Jake C.
    Jake CohenJune 15, 2015
    Best pizza by the slice around.
  • Bryan K. E.
    Bryan K. Emery Sr.May 22, 2015
    The food is great
  • James C.
    James ChandlerMay 19, 2015
    Best pizza place ever. Order 2 slices not 3 - way too much
  • Jeremy B.
    Jeremy BassinderMay 15, 2015
    Sausage pizza was great
  • Jeremy B.
    Jeremy BekerMay 10, 2015
    Really good classic NYC pizza. Don't hold up the line!
  • Kris B.
    Kris BulmanApril 18, 2015
    Cheese pizza, the best.
  • John M.
    John MichaelApril 12, 2015
    Best pizza in midtown
  • Nick L.
    Nick LeeApril 4, 2015
    If you're at Penn Station and in a rush, Don Pepi makes a good slice. If you have more time, come here.
  • Maria A.
    Maria Arshad-OsmanApril 4, 2015
    Wow wht a pizza!! The crust, the toppings, everything was delicious. Def on of the best NY style pizzas in town.
  • David A.
    David AitkenMarch 20, 2015
    Great slice - marinara sauce is great!
  • Justin M.
    Justin MoyMarch 13, 2015
    Upside down pizza!
  • Mehan J.
    Mehan JayasuriyaFebruary 28, 2015
    The platonic ideal of the New York plain slice. A well-balanced, perfectly cooked, deeply satisfying slice every time. I really doubt there's a better way to spend $3 in Manhattan.
  • Joe E.
    Joe EdgarFebruary 28, 2015
    The sauce is great
  • Kevin B.
    Kevin BullockFebruary 24, 2015
    Perfect for a quick slice
  • David G.
    David GreenbergerFebruary 21, 2015
    Listen to 4sq! Didn't trust the rating, went with it. Didn't trust the upside down slice, got it, bc 4sq said. One of the best slices I've had in the city.
  • Melanie W.
    Melanie W.February 1, 2015
    Been here 5+ times
    Best slice near Penn Station. Go for the chicken parm slice.
  • Sourabh S.
    Sourabh SanghaviJanuary 29, 2015
    Basic plain pie is a must try. Go ahead and you will not regret it.
  • Alberto D.
    Alberto Diaz-LealJanuary 18, 2015
    This is what I though NY pizza should taste like.
  • Claudia T.
    Claudia TamachiroJanuary 10, 2015
    Great pizza in NY city! Very cheap
  • Bu W.
    Bu WhiteyJanuary 5, 2015
    Best sauce ever
  • Kimmie O.
    Kimmie OhhJanuary 4, 2015
    The classic plain slice is superb
  • Kimmie O.
    Kimmie OhhJanuary 4, 2015
    Order the upside down pizza
  • Phil K.
    Phil KenchJanuary 3, 2015
    Great range of slices to choose, 1-2 is plenty for lunch.
  • Michael D.
    Michael DiscenzaDecember 30, 2014
    Been here 10+ times
    Best Margarita pizza around!
  • Rodrigo T.
    Rodrigo TeixeiraDecember 26, 2014
    Best NYC pizza ever! Have a Sicilian slice. It's really delicious!
  • İpek A.
    İpek A.December 18, 2014
    If you're close to 34 Penn Station and you're starving give it a try. This is not one of the pest pizza in that area but it's ok.
  • Daniel M.
    Daniel MoraesNovember 22, 2014
    Great stuff
  • Nick R.
    Nick RunyanNovember 16, 2014
    Get a plain slice.
  • Alex F.
    Alex FishNovember 10, 2014
    Been here 10+ times
    Best slice in the city, hands down. Get the white slice
  • Rock Raines
    Rock RainesNovember 6, 2014
    Only decent slice near msg. I like the upside down slice even though I think that makes me not a New Yorker.
  • Jazmin L.
    Jazmin LuiOctober 17, 2014
    This is the New York pizza I've been looking for. Get the upside-down pie!
  • Cezar L.
    Cezar LenciOctober 13, 2014
    Pepperoni and Suprema Special are excellent.
  • Emily H.
    Emily HacheSeptember 30, 2014
    Excellent margherita and suprema special
  • Amadeo P.
    Amadeo PlazaSeptember 21, 2014
    Holy shit. The upside down slice...
  • Phoenix 💥💥💥
    Phoenix 💥💥💥September 21, 2014
    Go for a slice after leaving MSG
  • Jason
    JasonSeptember 19, 2014
    Best Midtown pizza
  • Andrew D.
    Andrew DiMarcangeloSeptember 16, 2014
    Been here 10+ times
    Easily the best (American) pizza I've ever had.
  • Omar E.
    Omar EllisSeptember 15, 2014
    Been here 5+ times
    Very solid pizza place. Everything is good, consistently.
  • esther
    estherSeptember 3, 2014
    The upside down slice was good and cheap... good service also
  • Philip H.
    Philip HovAugust 27, 2014
    Very good pizza , i'd go with the fresh Mozzarella , BUT the Place isnt cozy... Pretty cold . Turn the A/C of and the music up please!
  • Leigh Anne Z.
    Leigh Anne ZinsmeisterAugust 26, 2014
    Grab a classic New York slice if you're near Penn Station!
  • Saranya M.
    Saranya ManoharanAugust 22, 2014
    The mozzarella and basil pizza super thin crust and yummy
  • William H.
    William HAugust 20, 2014
    Service is a bit surly and $3 is steep for a plain slice, but the pizza is top-notch. Keep it simple, the toppings look better than they taste.
  • Jins
    JinsAugust 17, 2014
    The pepperoni pizza is the best. Each slice is $4 but a while pizza is $25
  • Nancy K.
    Nancy KimAugust 17, 2014
    Tons of varieties of fresh pizzas. Personal favorite was fresh mushroom pizza and the creamy white pizza with garlic. My daughter loved the marinara pizza and wants to try the upside down pizza next
  • David Z.
    David ZawitzAugust 13, 2014
    Upside down slice is pretty good.
  • Vic C.
    Vic C.August 11, 2014
    Amazingly good slice...great crust
  • Jordan H.
    Jordan HAugust 10, 2014
    Best pizza in midtown
  • Julia L.
    Julia LienAugust 7, 2014
    Great place to grab a quick bite before taking a bus somewhere. Get the upside down pizza!
  • Noah L.
    Noah LemenAugust 6, 2014
    Been here 5+ times
    some of my favorite plain & fresh mozzarella slices in manhattan
  • Stevo
    StevoJuly 17, 2014
    Awesome awesome, pizza
  • Susan L.
    Susan LynneJune 22, 2014
    Best place to get a slice ! Love the plain , sausage and upsidedown
  • Sage W.
    Sage WohnsJune 6, 2014
    Note for Alan: the upside down pizza is only figuratively upside down
  • Esther C.
    Esther ChoiMay 27, 2014
    Amazing plain slice! Great cheese-free Vegan option: Vegetable medley
  • XP
    XPApril 23, 2014
    Plain and upside down are my 2 favorite. This place reps NY style pizza in every way.
  • e M.
    e MLApril 21, 2014
    Pizza's ok but definitely pricier than most.
  • Dana M.
    Dana MaeieApril 15, 2014
    Three dollars for plain slice. Hit the spot. Not the best cheese and sauce and seats in back smelled like urine bums.
  • Jimmy J.
    Jimmy JordanApril 11, 2014
    This is the best pizza and is right by Penn Station. Bring cash if you plan on spending less than $10 otherwise there is a ATM inside.
  • Danny K.
    Danny KaplanApril 3, 2014
    Been here 10+ times
    Best pizza north of downtown
  • Greg W.
    Greg WeinsteinMarch 8, 2014
    Best regular slice in NYC hands down.
  • Teresa M.
    Teresa MansbachFebruary 28, 2014
    Wow $3 for a plain slice and no cheese less pizza
  • Teresa M.
    Teresa MansbachFebruary 28, 2014
    Chill place by penn station. The bar tender with the gap in his teeth is cute
  • Dinis P.
    Dinis PassarinhoFebruary 24, 2014
    Don't get anything else but plain!
  • David M.
    David MichaelFebruary 2, 2014
    Been here 10+ times
    Best pizza in NYC
  • Robert E.
    Robert EllisJanuary 14, 2014
    Don't let them heat up your slice or it's gonna gain that re-heated too crispy/stale taste :(
    NJ.comJanuary 13, 2014
    The brightly-lit, cafeteria-like dining room and plain-talking, wise-cracking staff make for a quintessential New York experience. Read more
  • Michael C.
    Michael CinquegranaDecember 29, 2013
    Try the upside down slice!
  • Michael J.
    Michael JaccarinoDecember 16, 2013
    Best pizza and Greek salad! Worth the wait!
  • Jill
    JillDecember 9, 2013
    Chicken Parm Pizza is delicious! Make sure you know what u want to order before they ask or they will yell at you!
  • Dan. M.
    Dan. MastrettaNovember 16, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Pizza this good can change your day, month or life for the better. The plain slice is blissful.
  • Guidone
    GuidoneNovember 6, 2013
    Perfect place to go after a match of the Knicks. Good quality ingredients and tasty pizzas!
  • Ken Y.
    Ken YehOctober 21, 2013
    Perfect crust. Def one of the better slices in the 5 boroughs
  • Tamara R.
    Tamara RussellSeptember 14, 2013
    Mushroom slice was pretty tasty! I will be going back
  • Matthew W.
    Matthew WrightSeptember 6, 2013
    A really great slice! Don't miss it when you come to New York.
  • Shermaine P.
    Shermaine PrinceAugust 26, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    expensive but its worth it
  • Dan H.
    Dan HoodAugust 8, 2013
    Great regular slice, upside down is also highly recommended. It's not only good for the area (midtown pizza is generally pretty mediocre), it's good for the city.
  • P.J. O.
    P.J. OzakAugust 6, 2013
    everybody likes da pizza
  • Annemarie C.
    Annemarie CullenAugust 3, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Surprisingly good slice. Didn't think you could get that in midtown!
  • Adam K.
    Adam KubanJuly 31, 2013
    Don't leave without trying the "upside-down" slice, which has a rich, savory-sweet sauce and a light crust. And there's just something satisfying about the way the cheese melds with the dough.
  • Chris B.
    Chris BarredoJuly 25, 2013
    don't get creative with your ordering. stay with the tried and true ny-style pizza offerings.
  • Ride Above
    Ride AboveJuly 24, 2013
    The flavor of the "Grandma Slice" is incredible. Nice booths and air conditioning. Workers are very efficient.
  • S. N.
    S. NewlandJuly 15, 2013
    Friggin' awesome pizza! I don't even like mushrooms, and I loved their mushroom slice. Go there now!
  • Dev H.
    Dev HiraJuly 11, 2013
    Sign says no credit cards, but they accept it. Liars...
  • Gr000ver
    Gr000verJuly 11, 2013
    Upside down slice. So much sauce!
  • Douglas W.
    Douglas WidickJuly 6, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Fresh cheese, sweet onion sauce...what's not to like?
  • Brian D.
    Brian DeVitoJune 26, 2013
    Allegedly ranked the best slice in the city with news articles to prove it.
  • Nick P.
    Nick PatrickJune 12, 2013
    Been here 10+ times
    Waiting for a train at Penn Station? Hungry? Go here.
  • Kara
    KaraMay 29, 2013
    The most authentic and delicious Italian New York pizza. Chicken parmigiana pizza is to die for.
  • Aaron J.
    Aaron JohnsMay 18, 2013
    A friend sent me here and I can't get enough now. EVERY time I fly in I eat here. It's the best - hands down.
  • Lisa M.
    Lisa MMay 10, 2013
    Possibly the best slice in the city. Try the upsidedown
  • Joseph C.
    Joseph CutrufoApril 11, 2013
    Been here 10+ times
    Be ready to order as soon as you walk in, and bring cash. $15 minimum to use a card (and you'll hold up the line).
  • Steve F.
    Steve FApril 7, 2013
    Lives up to the hype
  • Social N.
    Social News NetworkMarch 31, 2013
    It's some of the best pizza in the city. All you need to get is a slice of cheese, perfect as is.
  • Serious Eats
    Serious EatsMarch 21, 2013
    The best pizza near Penn Station. Order an 'upside down' slice.
  • Jamison N.
    Jamison NgMarch 19, 2013
    You can get a free massage if you dine in since the LIRR trains are beneath this establishment
  • Appa V.
    Appa VMarch 9, 2013
    Been here 50+ times
    Plain is fantastic
  • James S.
    James SpotaFebruary 17, 2013
    great pizza, terrible service. The guy at the counter couldn't tell the difference between sausage & pepperoni
  • Ian S.
    Ian SpalterJanuary 11, 2013
    plain slice gives a great fold/crease and the cheese actually has flavor -sauce is on the sweet side but its a great basic NYC slice
  • Hector C.
    Hector CamineroJanuary 2, 2013
    Best pizza in manhattan hands down.
  • SuperNat13
    SuperNat13November 14, 2012
    upside down slice
  • jillian d.
    jillian dinoNovember 11, 2012
    This is really great pizza. A wonderful balance.
  • Jay N.
    Jay Naz 👍November 5, 2012
    Top 10 pizza joint in NYC. Recommend the margharita slice. Sauce is amazing
  • Tom B.
    Tom BakerOctober 17, 2012
    Plain slice is the way to go....
  • Rich K.
    Rich KearneySeptember 20, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    Pizza is good. Definitely best in the immediate area. Rolls are good too.
  • Desmond C.
    Desmond ChowJune 18, 2012
    Try the Mushroom Slice - If you like mushrooms on your pizza this is the place to go! Fresh mushrooms, not the white ones you get from a can. Tastier difference!
  • Niketa P.
    Niketa PatelMay 1, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    Upside down and white pizza are so delicious!
  • Summer S.
    Summer SMay 1, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    Best Pizza in Manhattan! Get the Margarita Slice. Say hi to Valentino!
  • Sarah M.
    Sarah McClutchyApril 23, 2012
    Only pizza spot with a perfect rating on Slice Harvester
  • Zach Aarons
    Zach AaronsApril 18, 2012
    Upside down slice is really solid. The supreme slice looks very good as well. Definitely a great option after a Knicks or Rangers game. (3 of 4 petals via Fondu) Read more
  • Cutter H.
    Cutter HouckApril 2, 2012
    Save yourself some dough before going into Madison Square Garden and grab a slice.
  • Steve C.
    Steve CarusoMarch 22, 2012
    pizza this good is truly wasted in this location. or really any location that I don't live adjacent to.
  • Joe M.
    Joe MaronMarch 19, 2012
    Try another place.....
  • Max M.
    Max MarshMarch 18, 2012
    Best pizza by the slice in NYC!
  • Shelley Y.
    Shelley YangFebruary 22, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    Amazing authentic new york slice!
  • John D.
    John DeMaioFebruary 9, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    The upside down is out of this world!
  • Whitney S.
    Whitney SnyderJanuary 28, 2012
    Been here 25+ times
    Almost everything is amazing, but the plain, upside down and marinara slices are the best
  • Jonathan M.
    Jonathan MoroJanuary 4, 2012
    Slice harvester calls it the best slice in manhattan.
  • penguin
    penguinJanuary 1, 2012
    This place is disgusting and never use their bathroom. Plumbing has seen better days
  • Gary G.
    Gary GibbonsDecember 29, 2011
    Voted best pizza in New York
  • Ava L.
    Ava LuDecember 17, 2011
    $3 for ANY slice after 12am! people there are super awesome and pizza were awesome! :]
  • Amanda S.
    Amanda SNovember 30, 2011
    Best pizza in NYC hands down.
  • Marc P.
    Marc PelinaNovember 16, 2011
    Been here 100+ times
    One of the best pizza places in the neighborhood! Their plain slice is awesome and all you really need! I come here for lunch all the time!
  • Jeffrey A.
    Jeffrey ANovember 15, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    Best pizza!!
  • Morgan L.
    Morgan LNovember 7, 2011
    Crunchy Pizza
  • Mike C.
    Mike ChristensenOctober 21, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    Here's the tip: eat here. I've been coming to the city for years on business and the Fresh Mozz & Basil (Margherita) is the best there is. Train, cab, walk, skip, whatever. You can't go wrong!
  • Danny M.
    Danny MolinaOctober 9, 2011
    The mushroom slice. ..great!
  • Riks F.
    Riks FloresSeptember 24, 2011
    I been to over 200 pizza spots and this is one of my top 10!!!
  • Shaun F.
    Shaun Farrugia🌹September 15, 2011
    Been here 50+ times
    Plain slice is best in the city!!!!!!!! My taste buds crave it!
  • William N.
    William NikoseySeptember 2, 2011
    There is a layer of parmesan between the sauce and the mutz. That's what makes the difference. Location sucks, pizza is legit.
  • Lenny G.
    Lenny GalloAugust 12, 2011
    Surprisingly very good Pizza. There slices ate thin and greasy but that's my personal favorite pizza.
  • Dan S.
    Dan SJuly 8, 2011
    The upside down slices are AMAZING!
  • Elizabeth
    ElizabethMay 25, 2011
    Meat lovers is delicious. By far one of the best pizza places in NY!
  • Daniel S.
    Daniel StillmanMay 23, 2011
    so. good. upsidee-down slice is almost like spumoni gardens' Read more
  • Joe and Lisa A.
    Upside-down and the regular are a must!
  • Lacey S.
    Lacey S.May 5, 2011
    GOOD pizza! One of the best slices of white pizza I've ever had :)
  • Katherine S.
    Katherine SungApril 28, 2011
    The best pizza made fresh with quality ingredients, I'm not kidding!
  • Diego R.
    Diego RufoApril 5, 2011
    The Upside Down Pizza and the NY Cheese are the two best (and famous). Read more
  • Melissa B.
    Melissa B.February 12, 2011
    Pizza so full of deliciousness that you need to use 3-4 paper plates to contain it all. Expensive for a non-NYC person, but worth it.
  • PizzaSnobo p.
    If you find yourself at Penn Station or Madison Square Garden, this is the best pizza in the hood.
  • Roze B.
    Roze BraunsteinJanuary 29, 2011
    I like that they are concerned with whether u want it cold warm or hot...
  • Kenny L.
    Kenny LoweJanuary 6, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    My 1st time here.. I'm a pizza snob and think this is one of the better slices in NYC!
  • Mitch W.
    Mitch WagnerDecember 1, 2010
    Like a pizza lapdance in your mouth, it's so good.
  • Carola C.
    Carola CassaroNovember 30, 2010
    white slice with spinach is sublime
  • shaun q.
    shaun quigleyNovember 12, 2010
    Buffalo chicken
  • Amy L.
    Amy LOctober 11, 2010
    The Chicken Parmigiana slice rocked!
  • E B.
    E BSeptember 21, 2010
    The only pizza i would eat in NYC.
  • Michael D.
    Michael DyeSeptember 4, 2010
    My favorite pizza in this neighborhood, stick to the plain with a bit of parm
  • Ken. B.
    Ken. B.August 16, 2010
    Been here 10+ times
    The best Pizza in mid-town Manhattan
  • hales
    halesJuly 6, 2010
    Best pizza in the neighborhood
  • Cindy T.
    Cindy TJuly 2, 2010
    Been here 5+ times
    A slice of cheese (aka "a regular"), which is its signature pie, costs $2.50. There is a $10 minimum for credit cards.
  • Mike D.
    Mike DrawbackJune 18, 2010
    you can skip the line if you're there for a plain slice
  • Mike I.
    Mike IrisJune 5, 2010
    Great NYC Pizza!
  • Thomas S.
    Thomas SopkovichMay 12, 2010
    Always a hot cheese pie on hand, great mushroom slice as well. Best in the neighborhood by far.
  • Christopher B.
    Christopher BradyApril 29, 2010
    Have the Fresh Mozzarella & Basil pizza. It's awesome.
  • Valerie G.
    Valerie GreenApril 14, 2010
    Delicious pizza. You'd never know. Check it out. Grandma's slice is fantastic.
  • Josh M.
    Josh MaxeyMarch 6, 2010
    Been here 10+ times
    The upside down shines too.
  • Stefan H.
    Stefan HaydenFebruary 24, 2010
    Been here 25+ times
    Stick to the plain slice. It's where they shine.
  • Ульяна О.
    Пицца кстати очень вкусная! $5 за слайс
  • Anouar A.
    Anouar Aziouzi2 weeks ago
    Best pizza ever, not expensive
  • Igor P.
    Igor PoloniSeptember 15
    Muito bom o lugar, é simple, para uma refeição rápida e muito barato. Comemos 2 pedaços de pizza e 2 coca cola média por $ 8.50 dólares total.
  • Fulya S.
    Fulya SuzhunMarch 31
    Been here 5+ times
    Grandma ve fresh mushroom bir harika!
  • Tony M.
    Tony MarasciuloJanuary 15
    Pizza Americana buona, totalmente differente dall'italian style
  • Fernanda A.
    Fernanda AraujoDecember 13, 2016
    Realmente uma típica pizza americana! Ótimo custo benéfico!!!
  • Hazel H.
    Hazel HernándezDecember 5, 2016
    Servicio muy rápido, un precio muy económico y una pizza de buen sabor! La de hongos es deliciosa!
  • Nalan M.
    Nalan MeydanOctober 18, 2016
    İyi fiyata lezzetli New York pizzası😊
  • Jeroen D.
    Jeroen DevrieseMarch 19, 2016
    Goede pizza stukken! Redelijk goedkoop
  • girl
    girlJanuary 13, 2016
  • Allison M.
    Allison MacambiraDecember 23, 2015
    Pizza muito boa! 😃
  • Daniela V.
    Daniela VogelDecember 21, 2015
    Recomendo para todos que vão a Manhattan. Ela é pequeninha, familiar, simples, relativamente barata e muuuuuuito gostosa!
  • OsiDan
    OsiDanOctober 28, 2015
    Pizza de 3 quesos increíble!
  • Alexandre J.
    Alexandre JamardOctober 20, 2015
    Les pizzas sont excellentes et c'est très bon marché.
  • Primo T.
    Primo Tacca NetoAugust 27, 2015
    Ogro mas incrível
  • Glaucia B.
    Glaucia BoenoJuly 17, 2015
    Uma delícia!! e super barato, 5 dolares por uma fatia gigante de pizza e uma coca.
  • Annie R.
    Annie RomanJuly 7, 2015
    Es la cosa más deliciosa!!! Además que nos atendieron como reyes!! Siempre da gusto ver a nuestros paisanos!! Simplemente la mejor pizza en NewYork! Un must!!! Y mi favorita!!!
  • Pepe P.
    Pepe PinedaJune 25, 2015
    Opinión de 1 mexicano les daría 8/10 no creo q sean las mejores!!
  • Zeki A.
    Zeki AkyolApril 14, 2015
    Ugramadan ny'dan gitmeyin
  • Bu W.
    Bu WhiteyJanuary 5, 2015
    O atendimento é, além de bom, carinhoso. Muita preocupação com a satisfação do cliente. O molho, o melhor que já comi na vida. Sério. E os pedaços de pizza são enormes. Imperdível.
  • Indra S.
    Indra Sarmiento DeMorenoDecember 26, 2014
    Special Supreme super deliciosa.
  • Bruno N.
    Bruno NascimentoAugust 16, 2014
    Ótima pizza, vale a visita.
  • Jérôme T.
    Jérôme TomasiniAugust 10, 2014
    Référence de la pizza new-yorkaise, ce restaurant familial a bâti sa légende sur sa part de "plain cheese". Les gourmands se régaleront aussi avec la "Fresh Mozzarella & Basil".
  • Maxim M.
    Maxim MakarovMarch 24, 2014
    Действительно лучшая пицца на Манхэттене! 3$ слайс. Тонкая, сочная и хрустящая одновременно. Итальянцы ее готовят здесь уже 40 лет. Маргерита попробуйте обязательно.
  • Mac _.
    Mac _ccsDecember 18, 2013
    Excelente las pizza!s son divinas!!!
464 Photos

Related Searches

  • new york pizza suprema new york
  • new york pizza suprema new york photos
  • new york pizza suprema new york location
  • new york pizza suprema new york address
  • new york pizza suprema new york
  • new york pizza suprema new york
  • ny pizza supreme new york
  • pizza suprema new york
  • pizza supreme new york
  • suprema pizza new york
  • new york pizza suprema chelsea new york

Foursquare © 2017  Lovingly made in NYC & SF