I thought the zucchini chips weren't as crispy as they could have been, but the atmosphere was great, even in the winter!
Great service, coffee, and cocktails.
Zucchini chips all day
The ultimate Hamptons experience. Order the Watermelon Cucumber Smash, Fettuccine with Shrimp, and Polenta Fries.
Fettuccine with arugula pesto and grilled shrimp = awesome
Keep your eye out for Alec Baldwin.
The food is pretty good, but it's definitely worth it to listen to the obnoxious rich idiots sitting around you bragging about everything they can.
Tartuffo is amazing!
Modern Italian at its finest. It's hard to get a table, but worth it if you can. Go in the fall, the menu and the service are both better. Whatever you order, get the roasted cauliflower as a side.
Nick & Toni's makes a mean Mai Tai with Diplomático Blanco. Enjoy one on their patio in the beautiful weather. Don't forget, Newsday did name it one of the top-ten cocktails on Long Island!
Sitting across from Nathan Lane on the patio is pretty cool! I'm actually star-struck! :)
Good service, great food, and prices that aren't 100% ludicrous. Finally, a Hamptons restaurant that has it all down.
ME: "Get the striped bass." YOU "But Sam! I don't li..." ME "shhhhh, get the striped bass."
Highly recommended: ricotta gnocchi with Gorgonzola, toasted pine nuts and poppy seeds, wood-oven-roasted striped bass or the spice-rubbed hanger steak, and for dessert: the chocolate honey cake.
Our waiter "wasn't into pasta". Worst service.
They have reservations-less tables on the porch and patio, so as long as you get here 20 minutes before you want to eat, you'll be fine
Caesar salad and zucchini chips are incomparable. Service is always friendly and professional. It's not about the fancy hamptons celebrity scene, but the rooms have great energy, & the food is delish.
The new table #7 replaces table #24 as the must have seat in the house!
Try the Chocolate Honey Cake - Honey tuile, cocoa nib, local honey comb, whipped cream
Try the Caramel Tart, Pancetta Brittle, Pancetta Gelato, Amagansett Sea Salt - No longer on the menu, but quite amazing!
Try the Champagne Gelee Cheesecake - Blood orange segments, blood orange chip
Try the Lemon Almond Torta - Candied almonds, amoretto gelato, candied lemon
Love the warmth and humor of the staff. A wonderful compliment to the great food.
The veal was perfect. Also, get a free glass of wine by checking in on Yelp!
Try the Penne - An incredibly consistent dish.
Tartufo is ONE word and it's also one of my favorites here. I have a Love/hate romance with this place, during Summer. Shame they cut the trees down; looks like a parking lot and lost its elegance.
The patio makes an enjoyable location on a warm summer night – the wait is worth it, we promise.
Still East Hampton’s most coveted reservation. Chef Joseph Realmuto sources from the best local purveyors for such dishes as dandelion greens and pork-belly croutons in a white-anchovy vinaigrette.
Pizzas are amazing as well as salt crusted fish.
Go in off season when you can just walk in without a resi. Good beer selection. The crispy rabbit is a TON of food. Octopus salad doesn't skimp on octopus meat. And ricotta gnocchi is very good.
Best steak must have !! Might even see gwenyth paltrow or another celebrity
Be sure to get olives for the table. Amazing!
Watermelon salad is fantastic. Large! Combination of olives with watermelon is surprisingly addictive.
The zucchini chips are great and enough for 4!
The pork is amazing. The poppyseed pasta is to die for. And the Hendry zin is perfect.
Don't miss the zucchini chips!
come here to ogle at celebrities and have a drink. the food is average. overly flavored and spiced (like what an amateur chef would do). if there was a stand out dish, it would be the Cavatappi.
Two words. Tartufo.
The Penne alla Vecchia Bettola is to die for.
Don’t forget to visit the other Nick & Toni’s restaurants in East Hampton- La Fondita for take-out Mexican, and Rowdy Hall for refined bohemian style pub atmosphere.
After dinner, check out their selection of tea.
They'll do half-orders of the pastas as appetizers (or light entrees). The lobster-pesto tagliatelle is really nice.
I realize its the hot place to go in the summer, its better in the winter
Great place to go for a celebrity sighting!