• Photo taken at Nicolitalia Pizzeria by Levi S. on 3/4/2014
  • Photo taken at Nicolitalia Pizzeria by Willy L. on 6/18/2013
  • Photo taken at Nicolitalia Pizzeria by Brady L. on 1/3/2013
  • Photo taken at Nicolitalia Pizzeria by Jacob P. on 12/21/2012
  • Photo taken at Nicolitalia Pizzeria by Steven W. on 8/18/2012
  • Photo taken at Nicolitalia Pizzeria by Eric P. on 6/24/2012
  • Photo taken at Nicolitalia Pizzeria by Mark D. on 6/12/2012
  • Photo taken at Nicolitalia Pizzeria by Steven H. on 5/30/2012
  • Photo taken at Nicolitalia Pizzeria by Steven H. on 5/9/2012
  • Photo taken at Nicolitalia Pizzeria by Steven H. on 5/9/2012
  • Photo taken at Nicolitalia Pizzeria by Adam H. on 10/18/2011
  • Photo taken at Nicolitalia Pizzeria by Aaron T. on 7/5/2011
  • Photo taken at Nicolitalia Pizzeria by Heidi B. on 6/8/2011
  • Photo taken at Nicolitalia Pizzeria by Heidi B. on 6/8/2011

Nicolitalia Pizzeria

Pizza Place$$$$
Provo
Save
Share
6.8/10
27
ratings
  • James J.
    "Mt. Dew meatball calzone and chocolate dipped cannoli."(2 Tips)
    Steven H.
    "I love their Meatzza Chiena, wings, and breadsticks!"(2 Tips)
20 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • pizza
  • Greek salad
  • chicken wings
  • good for dates
  • authentic
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Recent
  • Popular
  • Ron D.
    Nicoitalia combination, crust and sauce
  • Kaden P.
    Kaden PorterFebruary 23
    Pizza was amazing! Great customer care! Just awesome!! 10/10!
  • Kaden P.
    Kaden PorterFebruary 23
    Amazing place, Really good food and an interesting place to eat out! 10/10!
  • Rhett R.
    Rhett RogersApril 2, 2015
    Get the yummy house dip with your breadsticks. It's super good. They have awesome pizza there too.
  • Travis H.
    Travis HarleyMay 22, 2013
    Best pizza ever homes
  • Kira R.
    Kira RasmussenApril 16, 2013
    The Italian dressing is heaven. We go to Nico's at least 3X each time we visit Utah. We've never had a less-than-amazing pizza.
  • C.David C.
    C.David CaceresApril 12, 2013
    New owner has changed the feeling. ... Not the same. Customer service is lacking that familiar homie feeling.
  • Josh G.
    Josh GuestJuly 7, 2012
    You know what happens when you put spinach and broccoli on a pizza? Order a Pesto and find out.
  • Steven H.
    Steven HallJuly 6, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    I love their Meatzza Chiena, wings, and breadsticks! Simply the best.
  • Steven H.
    Steven HallMay 9, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    Try the Greek salad! Delicious.
  • Rob W.
    Rob WeidmannJanuary 22, 2012
    My favorite isn't on the menu anymore, but Nick will make it if you ask nicely. It's called the Lugano.
  • Alvaro S.
    Alvaro SAugust 24, 2011
    The Nicolitalia Special is the best you can get. Delicious to the very last slice.
  • Aaron T.
    Aaron ThompsonJuly 1, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    This is the best pizza in the area. Period.
  • Heidi B.
    Heidi BuolJune 8, 2011
    i recommend the baby limonata sanpelligrino drinks. =)
  • Jacob Barlow
    Jacob BarlowMarch 13, 2011
    I'd avoid it, I tried three kinds and its the only pizza I've ever disliked enough to not finish.
  • Tommy D.
    Tommy DraschilNovember 9, 2010
    Been here 10+ times
    What ever pizza you order, pay the extra to make it deep dish (also recommend extra cheese on it too). It's worth every penny.
  • Aaron D.
    Aaron DommerNovember 3, 2010
    Best Pizza in Happy Valley!
  • Don L.
    Don LaVangeJanuary 15, 2010
    Pizza Margharita and a cannoli.
  • James J.
    James JolleyOctober 21, 2009
    Been here 10+ times
    Mt. Dew meatball calzone and chocolate dipped cannoli. Read more
  • lu c.
    lu carrJanuary 19, 2010
    Best pizza in town
14 Photos