NY Pie

Pizza Place$$$$
Hillwood, Nashville
Save
Share
8.4/10
102
ratings
  • Tim R.
    "Best pizza in Nashville - and they sell by the slice!"(6 Tips)
    Krissy R.
    "Sriracha chicken slice = one of the best slices I've ever had."(2 Tips)
    Amber F.
    "The margarita pizza is amazing!!"(2 Tips)
    Matthew R.
    "The cannolis are really fresh too."(2 Tips)
42 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • pizza
  • good for a quick meal
  • great value
  • lively
  • family-friendly
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Recent
  • Popular
  • Brandon S.
    Brandon SmithJanuary 7
    Two words: Garlic Knots!
  • MyHappyness
    MyHappynessMarch 4, 2016
    So happy I found this place. The staff was wonderful!!!
  • John C.
    John CodyJanuary 26, 2016
    Been here 10+ times
    Great "real" New York style pizza. As a NY transplant so glad I found this place.
  • Miguel D.
    Miguel De JesusAugust 19, 2015
    Do yourself a flavor and get a Sriracha Chicken slice!
  • Tim G.
    Tim GerstAugust 2, 2015
    Get it by the slice! They are huge!
  • Suzanne E J.
    Suzanne E JonesDecember 31, 2014
    Order the pan white Sicilian pizza. It's cheese only and SO good!!
  • Bob Z.
    Bob ZeglarskiAugust 9, 2014
    Pizza is almost as good as the real thing and better than any other I've had in Nashville.
  • Matthew R.
    Matthew RogersJanuary 18, 2014
    Wireless PW is realnypie. Buying by the slice is a better deal than the 11" rounds. The Sriracha chicken is my favorite, but I add jalapeño slices. The cannolis are really fresh too.
  • Paul W.
    Paul WilliamsDecember 30, 2013
    This place does a huge disservice to my home state of NY...All these other tips lied to me. The search for good pizza in Nashville continues.
  • DD
    DDDecember 30, 2013
    Best pizza in Nashville = terrible pizza. Poorly made, questionable cleanliness, and most certainly not NY Style pizza at all.
  • J. S.
    J. SeemanDecember 17, 2013
    Sloooowwww
  • Tim E.
    Tim EdwardsDecember 12, 2013
    Very Friendly staff and the Pie was the best ever!!
  • Alysse R.
    Alysse ReddingDecember 3, 2013
    Seriously great pizza. The service is great. I love it here
  • Krissy R.
    Krissy R-HarrisNovember 3, 2013
    Sriracha chicken slice = one of the best slices I've ever had.
  • Robert B.
    Robert BrewerOctober 6, 2013
    The cannoli is pretty good
  • Stephanie H.
    Stephanie Hooten StillSeptember 14, 2013
    Excellent as always. I love the Margarita Pizza.
  • Jennifer B.
    Jennifer BlasdelAugust 21, 2013
    Best pizza I have had in years !
  • Brendan P.
    Brendan PurcellAugust 3, 2013
    Best Pie in Nashville
  • Dennis H.
    Dennis HickeyFebruary 21, 2013
    Been here 100+ times
    A Slice of Home !
  • Katie D.
    Katie DavidsonFebruary 9, 2013
    Apparently a very family friendly establishment...
  • Val L.
    Val LSeptember 3, 2012
    Amazing food! Best Pizza in Nashville.
  • Anthony M. C.
    Anthony M. CanadaAugust 22, 2012
    please try the spinach & garlic chicken pie! Amazing
  • David S.
    David SchwartzMay 11, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    Ask them for dough to occupy your kids while the pizza is made to order.
  • Angelina ..
    Angelina .April 13, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    With me being a New Yorker for 35 years this is the only place in Nashville that comes close! I love this place!
  • Luna N.
    Luna NashvilleMarch 31, 2012
    If you want Pizza that taste like what you would get up North, you must go here. It's the best in town:)
  • Jennifer D.
    Jennifer DavisFebruary 26, 2012
    Best pizza ever!!!!!
  • Dennis H.
    Dennis HickeyFebruary 2, 2012
    Been here 100+ times
    HANDS DOWN BEST PIZZA IN TOWN! :-)
  • Tim R.
    Tim ReynoldsJanuary 25, 2012
    Been here 50+ times
    Best pizza in Nashville - and they sell by the slice! New York Style
  • Matthew S.
    Matthew SlyJanuary 22, 2012
    Get the homemade meatballs on your pie. You'll thank me for it.
  • Linda D.
    Linda DukeJanuary 7, 2012
    Best in Nashville
  • Max B.
    Max ButlerNovember 14, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    Easily the best pizza in Nashville. My favorite is sausage and jalapenos.
  • Dennis H.
    Dennis HickeySeptember 23, 2011
    Been here 100+ times
    Try if you like ...you won't find better Pizza or people. :-)
  • Nathan W.
    Nathan WeinbergSeptember 10, 2011
    Honest to God, best pizza in Nashville. Seriously good stuff.
  • Gary B.
    Gary BarkerSeptember 7, 2011
    I'm not sure I'd call it authentic NY pizza, but it's really trying to be. I didn't like it enough to order a whole pie again but I'd definitely stop in for pizza by the slice for lunch!
  • Dennis H.
    Dennis HickeyAugust 31, 2011
    Been here 100+ times
    Its all good try the desserts!
  • Lili J.
    Lili JJuly 28, 2011
    Our pizza came out uncooked. It was still really doughy.
  • Ryan M.
    Ryan MJuly 19, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    Great pizza! And the 14" is plenty big enough for 4.
  • Amber F.
    Amber FaulkJune 15, 2011
    The margarita pizza is amazing!! You MUST try it!
  • Spencer N.
    Spencer NickelJune 1, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    best service ever, most employees know me by name and take time to talk to me, ya feel like part of the family.
  • Kerry W.
    Kerry WooMay 30, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    Service is much improved; pizza remains consistently good. Read more
  • Flame H.
    Flame HicksApril 6, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    Try the Greek it's THE BEST!!!
  • Jason S.
    Jason SmallingMay 18, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Best pizza in Nashville!
41 Photos