Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe

Bagel Shop$$$$
Prospect Heights, Brooklyn
Save
Share
7.8/10
277
ratings
  • Jon P.
    "egg & cheese on an everything bagel"(4 Tips)
    MidgeMadge D.
    "Try the signature breakfast sesame bagel with feta and Zaatar."(4 Tips)
    Joe T.
    "Their signature breakfast sandwiches ROCK!"(2 Tips)
    Dri B.
    "Had a zaatar bagel with cream cheese, was really good!!!"(2 Tips)
100 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • bagels
  • sandwiches
  • breakfast food
  • artichoke cream
  • coffee
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Recent
  • Popular
  • Rem K.
    Rem KoningOctober 17
    NYC Old school bagels, chips and sandwiches.
  • Bjorn J.
    Bjorn JohnsonOctober 14
    Damn fine bagels.
  • Wayne B.
    Wayne BennettMarch 27
    Been here 5+ times
    Great sense of humor . Sandwiches good too
  • Dri B.
    Dri BacciMarch 25
    Had a zaatar bagel with cream cheese, was really good!!!
  • Wayne B.
    Wayne BennettMarch 21
    Been here 5+ times
    Yes the bagels are delish. But the food is very good too. .Broccoli Rabe, delicious turkey burgers, egg and cheese, meatballs , Mexican tuna are some of yummy options to put on those bagels.
  • Nikki
    NikkiJanuary 8
    no fuss. plus cookies!
  • Andrew F.
    Andrew FurmanJanuary 5
    Decent everything bagel, but the bacon was soggy
  • Remy L.
    Remy Le BoeufNovember 2, 2016
    They don't have prices on anything so you never know what they are charging you. They also have the uncanny ability to consistently mess up my order. Not a big fan of this place.
  • Eliza
    ElizaOctober 21, 2016
    Been here 5+ times
    Bagels are amazing. Service is really slow.
  • Wayne B.
    Wayne BennettOctober 3, 2016
    Been here 5+ times
    Coffee, bagel, salads are all great here . All served with a smile
  • Billy J.
    Billy JacobsonJune 5, 2016
    Great large bagels. Classic NYC bagel style
  • alex r.
    alex rockMay 25, 2016
    Bagel all the way!
  • Joe D.
    Joe DFebruary 26, 2016
    Been here 10+ times
    Spinach & Artichoke cream cheese is definitely the sleeper move here.
  • Ben S.
    Ben ShiraiJanuary 20, 2016
    Been here 10+ times
    The best bagels!
  • Christopher A.
    Christopher AndersonNovember 8, 2015
    Been here 5+ times
    WW Everything with lox. Yum!
  • Cameron M.
    Cameron MadduxOctober 3, 2015
    I had the zaatar bagel, but I think the zaatar cream cheese on something is the smarter play.
  • Wayne B.
    Wayne BennettSeptember 28, 2015
    Been here 5+ times
    The Bagels here are pretty darn good. Anyway you like them. Sip a nice dark roast D'Amico coffee and experience a form of calm and satisfaction in NY.
  • justmush
    justmushSeptember 11, 2015
    They have tofu cream cheese
  • Ryan Scott T.
    Ryan Scott TandyJune 27, 2015
    Great bagels, get a fresh everything with smoked salmon, cream cheese and tomato. Thank me later.
  • Joe M.
    Joe MasilottiApril 26, 2015
    Been here 25+ times
    Ask for a Middle Eastern Spiced Bagel, if they have any left.
  • Joe M.
    Joe MasilottiMarch 18, 2015
    Been here 25+ times
    Best bagels in the area, but be prepared for a wait.
  • Kimmie O.
    Kimmie OhhFebruary 27, 2015
    They have a great of cream cheeses to schmear onto your delicious, soft & chewy bagels
  • Erin
    ErinFebruary 2, 2015
    Been here 25+ times
    Signature breakfast #2.
  • Sarah S.
    Sarah Schipul SwiftJanuary 15, 2015
    Been here 50+ times
    Try to be zen about the line, it's worth the wait. Excellent bagels, cream cheese, sandwiches, and omelettes. Cash only.
  • John S.
    John SourbeerNovember 2, 2014
    Good selection of cream cheeses
  • John S.
    John SourbeerNovember 2, 2014
    Great bagels. Cash only
  • Virginia M.
    Virginia MurdochOctober 4, 2014
    I'm not sure that any less efficient check-out exists on earth.
  • Alicia
    AliciaOctober 2, 2014
    for the fall season, get a cinnamon bagel with pumpkin cream cheese. it's to die. after you might want a container of it to bring home.
  • Elie B.
    Elie BleierSeptember 28, 2014
    Cheap sandwich options for the neighborhood. Check out the"healthy"menu in the back, even if it is only half healthy in my humble opinion...
  • Melissa L.
    Melissa LonsdaleSeptember 13, 2014
    Amazing and GIANT bagels! Loved the egg bagel
  • Camille
    CamilleSeptember 13, 2014
    Bagels are usually good, but I've often gotten an untoasted bagel and today my salt bagel came covered in jelly... Blegh. Service is also not good.
  • Benjamin H.
    Benjamin HealySeptember 2, 2014
    Bagels the way they're meant to be when fresh, soft & chewy inside with a slightly crunchy crust, without having to toast them.
  • Terry P.
    Terry PovedaAugust 7, 2014
    Been here 50+ times
    Veggie cream cheese and tomato on an everything!
  • Mike B.
    Mike BaronJuly 23, 2014
    Been here 5+ times
    Dont expect them to give you what you ask for. They actually microwaved a bagel that I asked to have toasted once. I am angry at myself for giving these guys so many chances.
  • Danny D.
    Danny DJuly 11, 2014
    Been here 25+ times
    Cant go wrong with the zatar bagel and Janine in the best
  • Varun S.
    Varun ShettyJune 8, 2014
    Been here 10+ times
    If there's ever a global cream cheese shortage, blame these guys. They're aggressive.
  • Yoojin L.
    Yoojin L.January 19, 2014
    They have bags of coffee hidden along the back wall, which they will grind to your desired setting. Cash only.
  • Stacy S.
    Stacy S.January 2, 2014
    Been here 5+ times
    Just tried the coconut cream cheese! Good stuff!
  • Jon P.
    Jon PetersDecember 11, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Hangover remedy: 1) bleary-eyed zombie stumble from apt. around noon 2) maintain consciousness while cursing too-long line (3) devour sausage, egg & cheese on an everything bagel 4) joyously skip home
  • Samantha M.
    Samantha MushnickNovember 23, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Always good. So many cream cheese selections.
  • rabi
    rabiNovember 16, 2013
    Been here 25+ times
    Good bagels and good cream cheese options. They get my order wrong too often. Doesn't hurt to check before you leave.
  • Deborah A.
    Deborah Au-YeungOctober 27, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Salmon and fill cream cheese with a toasted onion bagel = nirvana
  • Ramya
    RamyaOctober 10, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    So many choices... amazing bagels, slow service, cash only
  • Lydia D.
    Lydia DingSeptember 7, 2013
    Must try the zataar cream cheese! And you need to specify that you want your bagel toasted.... Or else they don't. Sad face.
  • Peter J.
    Peter JosephAugust 31, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    There's no cream cheese on it, but get the #1 Signature Breakfast sandwich.
  • Virginia M.
    Virginia MurdochAugust 21, 2013
    Jesus H. Christ that was a lot of cream cheese! The multigrain bagel is a winner.
  • Mike S.
    Mike SaundersAugust 16, 2013
    Best bagel I ever ate.
  • Tina B.
    Tina Bou safiJune 23, 2013
    Order the Signature breakfast #1 fea + Zaatar (thyme) + olive oil
  • Momo F.
    Momo FurudateJune 23, 2013
    Been here 50+ times
    If they get your order wrong, and it can't be fixed directly on what you received (i.e. they'd have to remake it), they will throw the initial attempt away. So if you can live with the issue, eat it.
  • Mary B.
    Mary BocchinoMay 30, 2013
    Been here 100+ times
    Best bagels in the area- hands down!! Always worth the wait.
  • Ashley P.
    Ashley PerezMay 26, 2013
    Plain bagel, toasted with light scallion. That's where it's at.
  • Makena C.
    Makena CunninghamMay 18, 2013
    amazing bagels, and the spinach artichoke cream cheese to to DIE for.
  • Dan S.
    Dan SApril 21, 2013
    No sign in the whole place but its Cash only. They're also kinda rude behind the counter.
  • Dewan T.
    Dewan TarekFebruary 22, 2013
    Generous with the schmeaR here
  • Yvette P
    Yvette PFebruary 2, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Hopefully some day they will get that "a tiny amount of cream cheese please" doesn't mean slightly smaller huge globs.
  • Francesca K.
    Francesca KrihelyJanuary 26, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Specialty breakfast sandwich #2
  • Jamie
    JamieJanuary 15, 2013
    Been here 10+ times
    Cash only ATM $1.99
  • Andrew H.
    Andrew HellerJanuary 13, 2013
    Staff prefer shenanigans over service. Go to Bergen Bagels instead unless you feel like waiting 4 times longer than you have to.
  • Avi F.
    Avi FlamholzDecember 17, 2012
    ZAATAR BAGELS. Also, Azi, the owner, is a fantastically nice guy with a super interesting personal history. Talk to him.
  • William G.
    William GrugerNovember 4, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    Hope you're not in a rush, because its going to be at least 15 minutes till you're out the door and on your way
  • Chelsea P.
    Chelsea ParksOctober 7, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    It's cash only and when you get cash out you should get a pumpernickel bagel with either herb and garlic or bacon and maple syrup. And then cry fast tears of ecstasy.
  • Julie F.
    Julie FSeptember 3, 2012
    Get awesome coffee to go at Milk Bar across the street first and enjoy with your bagel
  • Mat B.
    Mat BrownAugust 30, 2012
    Best bagels and worst coffee in Prospect Heights.
  • Linnie D.
    Linnie DJuly 4, 2012
    Tofu lox spread
  • Adam S.
    Adam S.May 16, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    Great bagels, sandwiches and spreads mitigated by the ludicrously surly register staff. Not sure who pooped in their coffee, but the customer service leaves quite a bit to be desired.
  • Kimb J.
    Kimb James~JammalMay 15, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    Their tofu veggie cream cheese is a dream.
  • Nicholas N.
    Nicholas NewcombMay 7, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    So much potential here. It's too bad that with all this good food, I'm left with a bad taste in my mouth from the awful customer service.
  • Jevaun H.
    Jevaun HowellApril 21, 2012
    Strollers and cyclists and babies, oh my! This place is kind of a scene...
  • Joe T.
    Joe TaorminaApril 14, 2012
    Their signature breakfast sandwiches ROCK! Toasted sesame, evoo, feta, hard boiled egg, thyme!!!
  • Jarlin N.
    Jarlin NunezMarch 31, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    One of the Best bagel stores in brooklyn
  • Ross B.
    Ross BernardMarch 24, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    930am. 25 minute wait for a bagel with cream
  • Megan H.
    Megan H.March 14, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    These guys make the best egg & cheese on a bagel. My go to: whole wheat everything, egg, cheese, spinach, tomato.
  • Michael M.
    Michael MilbergerMarch 3, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    Decent bagels, service feels like a prison cafeteria
  • Rachael P.
    Rachael PazdanFebruary 28, 2012
    Try the Park slope On a wheat wrap with mozz
  • Cassel K.
    Cassel KrollFebruary 4, 2012
    Been here 100+ times
    Best bagels in Brooklyn.
  • Eva
    EvaJanuary 30, 2012
    The special bagel with za'tar and herbs is spesh.
  • Zz M.
    Zz MystaJanuary 9, 2012
    Been here 50+ times
    Delicious comes 2 those who wait
  • Ross B.
    Ross BernardDecember 18, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    The worst service. Someone please open up a better run bagel store.
  • Michael M.
    Michael MilbergerDecember 10, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    Good bagels (and lox!) but skip the coffee. Go to Milk or Joyce across the way for your cup of joe.
  • Izzy S.
    Izzy SammorDecember 9, 2011
    Deliciously awesome !!! Good things come to wait I don't mind the lines just shows you that they are amazing!
  • Polish Bar Brooklyn P.
    LARGE HOT COFFEE & SPINACH ARTICHOKE CREAM CHEESE BAGEL....LUVS IT!
  • Ross B.
    Ross BernardDecember 3, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    Please please fix the line situation here. Always a wait. Good bagels but terrible service.
  • Jen B.
    Jen BNovember 12, 2011
    Not only is the food not worth the wait, but they have terrible line management. If you can walk the extra couple blocks to Bergen bagels, do it. Ok in a pinch though.
  • John D.
    John DeSilvestriNovember 2, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    Amazing food slow service
  • Ross B.
    Ross BernardOctober 23, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    They can't figure out how to move the line faster. Frustrating. Bagels are good.
  • Polish Bar Brooklyn P.
    THE COFFEE & THE MADE TO ORDER SALADS ARE MY FAVORITE!
  • 💕Linds💕
    💕Linds💕August 29, 2011
    As a veggie sandwich connoisseur, the Park Slope is a really amazing sandwich. Try it on an everything bagel with asiago!
  • MidgeMadge D.
    MidgeMadge DJuly 30, 2011
    Try the signature breakfast sesame bagel with feta and Zaatar. Yummy.
  • Bryan B.
    Bryan BonczekJuly 17, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    Sesame bagel with zataar cream cheese!
  • thecoffeebeaners
    thecoffeebeanersJuly 12, 2011
    Bagels are incredibly soft, chewy, and warm!
  • thecoffeebeaners
    thecoffeebeanersJuly 12, 2011
    Laptops accepted and A/C!
  • thecoffeebeaners
    thecoffeebeanersJuly 12, 2011
    Order your Italian coffee for morning meetings here!
  • thecoffeebeaners
    thecoffeebeanersJuly 12, 2011
    Greatest bagels!
  • MidgeMadge D.
    MidgeMadge DJune 12, 2011
    Try the signature sesame bagel with Zataar and Feta. Delish
  • Janie S.
    Janie SJune 2, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    The people who work here couldn't be nicer.
  • Genetta A.
    Genetta AdamsJune 1, 2011
    Been here 25+ times
    There really isn't a bad bagel in the house. All are big, chewy puffs of goodness. Get a sandwich, please.
  • Ross B.
    Ross BernardMay 30, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    Finally a bagel place on vanderbilt beware of Long lines. Get here early. They need to figure out how to move the long lines along faster.
  • Danyel S.
    Danyel SmithMay 29, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    the line gets really long. the bagels are really good. the wraps are good, too, and kind of less of a big breakfast than the bagels.
  • Mary C.
    Mary CrosseMay 29, 2011
    The thyme cream cheese is amazing. Get the signature breakfast: feta, thyme, olive oil on a sesame bagel. Ask to add a runny egg for something spectacular. Cash only; no ATM inside.
  • Kristan D.
    Kristan DMay 15, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    The Freeze Tag is delicious!
150 Photos

Related Searches

  • olde brooklyn bagel shoppe brooklyn
  • olde brooklyn bagel shoppe brooklyn photos
  • olde brooklyn bagel shoppe brooklyn location
  • olde brooklyn bagel shoppe brooklyn address
  • olde brooklyn bagel shoppe brooklyn
  • olde brooklyn bagel shoppe brooklyn
  • olde brooklyn bagel shoppe prospect heights brooklyn

Foursquare © 2017  Lovingly made in NYC & SF