The pizza was delicious
As of December 2012, now open for lunch Monday-Friday 11:30am-2pm!!
This place is absolutely amazing. If you're in the area, check it out. Even just a plain tomato pie is like eating heaven!
Best tomato pie around!
Established in 1912 and continuously family owned & operated, but moved to from Butler St. in 1945, and remodeled later. It competes with Lombardi's for the title "oldest pizzeria," though both moved.
The country's oldest, consecutively run pizza place. The tomato pies are absolutely yummy. Try a pasta dish too - everything is homemade and off the hook good!
Order Red Cream Soda
I agree with Monica that this tomato pie is awesome, but I say order extra sauce!
This pizza, excuse me, tomato pie is UNREAL. Do yourself a favor and order extra cheese.