The only accurate menu: pauliegee.com/greenpoint/menu
Might possibly be my favorite pizza place in brooklyn
Could be the BEST pizza in NYC! Check out the Mo Cheeks!!
If you left any room for dessert the hot honey Sunday is really good.
The best pizza in the city!! The hometown bbq brisket pizza was delicious.
The hellified porkpie white = ❤️❤️. The monte cristo is drowning in maple syrup; too sweet for my blood.
Best pizza and nicest owner in town. Get the Hellboy with spicy honey and the Greenpointer, along with one of their locally brewed beers. They open at 5- line starts forming around 4:45. Arrive early
Great food, cool decor and good music. The Hellboy and Greenpointer were excellent
You gotta go early.
Awesome Pizza made fresh with the toppings of your choice. Lot of vegan options too!
The Hellboy beats the BeeSting at Roberta's; surprisingly delightful.
So good! Also the decor is fantastic. Love the barn door entry.
One of my favorite authentic pizza spots. Paulie gee himself was there to greet guests last time I went. The prosciutto pizza is killer, and they have bomb veg alternatives too
Excellent Spot with the right oven and good service. Pizza is at least 🌟🌟🌟🌟
LOVE this place! A bit pricey (not too steep) but well worth it. Awesome ambiance for dates and meet-ups with friends and food and wine are super yummy.
Killer pizza and a wonderful owner who usually comes out and says hello to every table.
Pizza is absolutely amazing; this is a decision you won't regret!
Get more pies than people. Try as much as possible and celebrate with leftovers.
Beware. This pizza is so good, it'll steal your girlfriend. It's in my top ten.
Simplesmente a melhor pizza de NYC. Forno importado diretamente de Napoli, massa fermentada naturalmente e por longo tempo. Demais!!!
The hellboy is just as amazing as everyone says, but no matter what you pick it will be delicious
The Pizza Snobo suggested this place which was a great recommendation. The pizza was perfectly cooked I will be back.
Get here very very early if you can. The lines can be pretty intense!
I love Hell boy, the best. However, their restroom not looked clean, their music very loud and servers/hostess were pretty rude. Now what I heard, some of their pizza stuffs are heroine junky:(
If you're a first-timer, the Hellboy is your move. It isn't as spicy as it sounds.
I lived in Italy and ate pizza all over the world. This is definitely one of the best. A must try!! Luca Brasi pizza for me is amazing.
Hellboy pizza is delish!
If you don't order the brisket pizza you are dumb and I feel bad for you.
Get Spectacle 261 & Hellboy!
Eat all the pie.
Great and somewhat weird pizza. Don't call it Californian... But that's what it is.
Cherry Jones if it's your first time.
All the pizzas I had were amazing! I'd say the best were the cherry jones (very unique), hellified porkpie white and hellboy. The porkypineapple and hometown brisker are also great.
Monte Cristo is awesome
You have to order at lest one Hellboy. After that you can try one of the many other delicious sounding pizzas.
They have an entire vegan pizza menu! Pizzas are absolutely wonderful and affordable for a night out. Come early bc it gets packed quickly.
Order some hot honey on the side to dip your crust. Only muggles leave their crusts on their plate.
Hellboy & Greenpointer
Sit down and order the Hellboy. You won't regret it! Also, say hi to Paulie for me. My guy!
One of the best pizza places in NYC... Love the Greenpointer w/ prosciutto. Worth the schlep!
If you plan your next private dinner occasion here, you get to email with Mrs. Gee who is a gem!
Super incredibly absurdly long wait. The food is fantastic, Paulie is great, and the service sucks.
A ton of pizzas to choose from!
Monte cristo pizza... Amazing
Hell boy. Monte cristo. Paulie.
Hell boy forever
Very nice place!! Pizza definitely the best in the area! Owner super friendly;)) good atmosphere, good selection of drinks it's all you need for good night out
The Hellboy is incredible. Get there early and be prepared to wait. Such good pizza is worth it.
The Hellboy is super. Don't let the mention of Mike's hot hard honey put you off.
Cherry Jones, Cherry Jones, Cherry Jones! Such a tasty mix of savory and sweet.
The Daniela Spinacci pizza with a side of red sauce was a mouthgasm.