Paulie Gee’s

Paulie Gee’s

Pizza Place and Vegetarian / Vegan Restaurant$$$$
Greenpoint, Brooklyn
Save
Share
9.5/10
1,501
ratings
  • Has a stamp of approval from Eater and Time Out New York
    • Eater
    • Time Out New York
  • Caroline S.
    "Cherry jones and the Hellboy"(23 Tips)
    Darrin P.
    "Agree with others, the Hellboy pizza is the best."(13 Tips)
    Cardwell Beach
    "Hellboy with spicy honey and the Greenpointer"(11 Tips)
    Jorge S.
    "... enjoying the food. Hell boy and cherry jones were both amazing...oh and..."(9 Tips)
372 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • pizza
  • lively
  • cherry jones
  • good for dates
  • vegan food
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Recent
  • Popular
  • Daniel B.
    Hellboy makes me wanna do bad things
  • Jon M.
    Jon MooreMay 28
    Awesome. Just awesome!
  • Dana B.
    Dana BKMay 28
    Generally, the place is unobtrusive and staggering. I will never recommend it to anyone.
  • Dana B.
    Dana BKMay 28
    The place is dirty and dirty and it is loud that you can not talk culturally. The tables are sticky because they are not washed.
  • Dana B.
    Dana BKMay 28
    My experience with this place was the first and the last time. The pizza is not tasty. The pizza sauce is not seasoned. The dough is burnt and can not be eaten.
  • Jackie W.
    So many varieties of pizza
  • Will M.
    Rx 1 Hot honey and pepperoni pizza 3x daily for good health
  • Will M.
    Rx: 1 Hot honey and pepperoni pizza 3x daily for good health
  • Tyler
    TylerMay 6
    Huge wait for killer ambiance and exquisite pizza.
  • Chelsea B.
    #FabuLIST #DubiDO if you arrive after 6 there will be a wait but head to Ramona’s for a cocktail to kill time. For pizza you must get the Hellboy. If you like blue cheese get the Cherry Garcia.
  • Sean B.
    Hellboy. Greenpointer. Can’t go wrong with anything. Delicious pizza.
    Upvoted Apr 27
  • Daniel A.
    Daniel AxmanMarch 30
    Hot honey on pep pizza 😍
  • Lucie P.
    Be ready to wait, try coming really early to beat the rush. Obviously Hellboy is amazing but honestly you can’t go wrong with any of them.
  • Elvis R.
    Get here by 4:50pm before they open up. My favorite among the vegetarian was the vegan sausage. They can get a side of the hot (spicy) honey for a $1 thats worth it.
    Downvoted May 28
  • Javier M.
    The best pizza and the best porter beer.
  • Ivana N.
    Ivana NikolicFebruary 21
    Been here 10+ times
    All the vegan pizzas!
  • justmush
    justmushFebruary 20
    Amazing vegan pizza options.
  • Ashley S.
    Ashley SpechtJanuary 30
    Decent pizza-- not the best I've had in my life. The pizzas are pretty small for costing almost $20 each and leaving still slightly hungry. I'll stick to the classic NY $1 slice and be full. 👍🏻
  • Graham G.
    Graham GnallJanuary 26
    Hellboy. Brooklyn Pizza temple.
  • Zachary
    ZacharyDecember 29, 2017
    worth the hype and the wait. you can substitute non-dairy cheese on any pizza.
  • Charles M.
    Charles MbaruguruNovember 29, 2017
    Quite possibly one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had... in my life. Must try Aniece and Anephew and frankly anything with their signature hot honey on it
  • Sam L.
    Sam LoganNovember 23, 2017
    This is the best pizza I have ever had in my life. Period.
  • Sam L.
    Sam LoganNovember 3, 2017
    This is the best pizza I have ever had. Period. They don't take reservations and you can't order takeout. You have to go here to eat the pizza. Any wait is worth it. Find a way to eat this pizza!
  • Emily W.
    Emily WilsonOctober 7, 2017
    Waits can be a bit much, so come well before you’re hungry (if prime time), and kick it at one of the very good bars (Ramona, Black Rabbit...) nearby.
  • Edmund B.
    Edmund BoeyOctober 6, 2017
    2 top pizzas! Hellboy & Monte Cristo! Get them!
  • Elvin G. M.
    Elvin G. MarmolSeptember 8, 2017
    Try the Hellboy or go with a small group and pick several options to share. There are so many good ones!
  • Kathryn I.
    Kathryn IJuly 8, 2017
    Get a side of hot honey for dipping your crust. Super accommodating for vegetarians .
  • Ruth F.
    Ruth FigueroaJuly 8, 2017
    Always amazing pizza but the menu is always changing slightly. Last time they had gluten pizza. Sucks not being able to have gluten. They also use to be able to add things to the pizza.
  • Tabitha J.
    Tabitha JohnsonJuly 7, 2017
    The Hellboy is one of my favorite pizzas anywhere.
  • Igal G.
    Igal GhitelmanJune 25, 2017
    Try their PorkypineapplePizza... Delicious 👌
  • Jarel H.
    Jarel HillJune 17, 2017
    Brisket pizza was awesome but the hellboy might be my favorite pizza of all time
  • Chad H.
    Chad HornerJune 5, 2017
    The Hellboy is spicy and sweet thanks to Mike's Hot Honey. you can also find collabs with Brooklyn favorites like Frankel's Deli and Hometown BBQ
  • Charlotte C.
    Charlotte ChanJune 4, 2017
    Im sure this place has great pizzas but it was an immediate turnoff that hostess was acting rude and snobby, like she was doing us a huge favor by "maybe" sitting us down. Drop the attitude Paulie
  • Tyson G.
    Tyson GachJune 4, 2017
    Been here 5+ times
    You really can’t go wrong with any pizza on the menu, but the cherry jones and hellboy are particularly crowd pleasing 👌🏼
  • Ashley W.
    Ashley WilliamsMay 29, 2017
    omg vegan pizza options are awesome
  • Kabir d.
    Kabir de LeeuwMay 26, 2017
    Skip it - just as good or better options in the hood without the wait. "No one goes there anymore, its too crowded."
  • Bryant B.
    Bryant BalatbatApril 24, 2017
    Excellent, authentic Neapolitan style pizza to go with excellent service. Consider coming in early for dinner to beat the crowd.
  • Jake D.
    Jake DayApril 15, 2017
    Really good pizza and chill atmosphere
  • Lee H.
    Lee HoffmanMarch 18, 2017
    The hellboy is one of the best pizzas I've ever had. The backdoor brisket is good. The Regina is ok.
  • Rachael M.
    Rachael McCarthyMarch 18, 2017
    The pizza is as good as everyone says. Come on a weeknight for less of a wait. Every pizza I've tried has been awesome!
  • Tim F.
    Tim FrietasMarch 11, 2017
    Eat it all. If not the best pizza in NY it is one of the best.
  • Nasir M.
    Nasir MemonMarch 11, 2017
    Cherry joe
  • Aaron L.
    Aaron LandryMarch 3, 2017
    Been here 5+ times
    If owner Paulie Gee stops by your table, get through the compliments quickly so you can spend this sacred minute inquiring about pizza with the oracle of world pizza knowledge that he is.
  • C-Line E.
    C-Line EatsJanuary 19, 2017
    Hellboy is my homeboy. Favorite pizza in NYC. (Greenpointer is 👌🏼 too).
  • David M.
    David MilbergJanuary 9, 2017
    Hellboy pizza is unlike any other pizza I have ever had. Absolutely fantastic. Highly recommend getting it.
  • Dave H.
    Dave HoltzJanuary 4, 2017
    The hellified porkpie white 😍
  • Staff Picks
    Staff PicksDecember 6, 2016
    Paulie Gee’s was one of the more wished for places throughout 2015’s I Want Somewhere holiday campaign. Where’s your somewhere? Enter to win a bucket list experience. Read more
  • Amber C.
    Amber CrisciNovember 27, 2016
    Ricotta be kidding me 👌🏻👌🏻
  • Ivan B.
    Ivan BlagajićNovember 20, 2016
    Perfect pizza place.
  • Jay M.
    Jay MuntuNovember 2, 2016
    This place gets full, be prepared to wait. Start the debauchery at Tender Trap next door.
716 Photos

Related Searches

  • paulie gee’s brooklyn
  • paulie gee’s brooklyn photos
  • paulie gee’s brooklyn location
  • paulie gee’s brooklyn address
  • paulie gee’s brooklyn
  • paulie gee brooklyn
  • paulie gee's brooklyn
  • paulie gees brooklyn
  • paulie gee’s brooklyn
  • paulie gee’s pizzeria brooklyn
  • paulie g’s pizzeria brooklyn
  • paulie gee’s greenpoint brooklyn

Foursquare © 2018  Lovingly made in NYC & SF