The only accurate menu: pauliegee.com/greenpoint/menu
Pizza is great
Still dreaming about the Hellified Porkpie White; it's dark as hell in there, so don't be shy about cell phone lights to read the menu.
UNREAL pizza! The Hellboy is delish and is topped with Mikes Hot Honey ☺️. Get here early though, because it's always packed!
Love everything. The dried cherry pie is really unique and delicious (even without the speck)!
I got there at 5pm on Sunday and it was easy peasy to get a table. then take a walk around the neighborhood.
Surprisingly liked some of the vegetarian options as much as the meat ones
The most amazing vegan pizza, with all homemade vegan cheeses. I'm not vegan (just lactose intolerant) & they will put meat on your vegan pizza if you ask (though the jackfruit meatballs are so good).
Hellified porkpie white and Hellboy are magnificent. Paulie stopped by our table; this place is as real as it gets.
It's rare that any pizza place offer vegan pizza. So when one does, I'm all over it. This place has 7 different vegan pizza's. The Jackie Green pizza (vegan) is worth coming back for.
Low light ambiance, but too loud to be romantic. Good wood oven pizza, but the tomato sauce is a bit ok the wet side.
The ones with ricotta are really good. I love that they don't put pressure on you to leave (as at Roberta's). Service is fantastic! Be there early, there would be a line at 5:00
Get a Hellified Porkpie White. V have the good taste.
Had the Helicopter Hellified Porkpie White and the Hometown Brisket. Both pizzas were delicious, but the hot honey drizzle on the Porkpie White is what has me wanting to go back to pursue Paulie Gees!
I had the hellboy pizza, and it was fantastic! Great service - Paulie is a super friendly guy!
Be prepared to wait but the pizza is worth it. Love their spicy honey combos. Dark and romantic vibe, and a solid beer list. 🍕 wins every time.
Be prepared for long waits but really yummy, unique pizza.
Flawless pizzas. Get the Hellboy if you like a flavor kick.
Pizza that rivals roberta's. I will fare to say it's even better & there are 2x as many topping combinations. Paulie Gee will stop by your table personally and check if you're happy.
Paulie Gee's is a solid option for good pizza in Brooklyn, but I think there are better options. It didn't compare to Roberta's in Bushwick or Marta in Manhattan, but was still pretty good pizza
Well its simple.Best pizza I've ever eaten in my life!!
Mike's Hot Honey is amazing.
Hellboy and the Greenpointer.
Pulled pork of hellboy pizza, this cozy spot will make you rethink top 3 pizza places in Brooklyn. Sit at the bar if you can!
Fennel sausage on the Ricky Ricotta pizza spiced up an otherwise meh pie. Hostess was a champ even while barraged by hangry hipsters.
The owner comes out to talk with people with his authentic Bk attitude. He clearly hates hipsters, yuppies, and everyone there now but in a very endearing way.
Hellboy and Brisket👍👍
LOVE it. Would totally come back despite lines. We ate at the bar. Greenpointer is delicious. Also met paulie.
The bathrooms are peak Brooklyn. I mean that in a good way.
Hellboy sure is great. I think Lucali in Caroll Gardens is still best.
Great thin pizza. The simpler the better.
Hellified pork pie white dawgs!!
If you're here, might as well go all out. Do better than the Greenpointer
Delicious! There's typically an hour wait, so check out great beer spot not too far away to wait.
If you end up sitting in the front, be sure to check out the oven area in the back where all the magic happens.
Vegan Pizza Menu is on point.
Pizza is just out of this world. Literally.
Some of the best pizza...ever. Order the Hellboy. Arrive early as there are no reservations and it gets packed! Be sure to say hi to Paulie while you're there.
NYC's best pizza. If you need some fuel to keep you going all night long, come here. Don't leave without trying the Cherry Jones and Hellboy - the perfect order.
hellboy hellboy hellboy 😈
Tally up another tip for the Hellboy. I wasn't sure about honey on a pizza, but it's one of the best slices I've ever had. Mike's Hot Honey perfectly complements the soppressata.
Take note: if it has pickled onions on it, you should probably order it.
Given the crowds, it's unlikely you can choose seats but note that it gets rather warm in the back and cell service is weak so you may actually have to converse with your companion. Great pizza btw
If you don't sub out regular ricotta for the cashew ricotta you a damn fool.
Try the Hellified Porkpie with tomato sauce if that floats your boat.
The Hellboy, with Mike's Hot Honey is always amazing. ...say Hi to Paulie for me 🙋
Hate the G train? Take the east river ferry! Super close to the docks. Once you get here, as everyone says the Hellboy pizza cannot be skipped - the honey makes the sauce taste like candy.
Hellboy. Get that hot honey
Hellboy pizza is the best pizza I've ever had.