Paulie Gee’s

Paulie Gee’s

Pizza Place and Vegetarian / Vegan Restaurant$$$$
Greenpoint, Brooklyn
Save
Share
9.5/10
1,373
ratings
357 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • pizza
  • lively
  • cherry jones
  • good for dates
  • cozy
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Recent
  • Popular
  • Kathryn I.
    Kathryn I2 weeks ago
    Get a side of hot honey for dipping your crust. Super accommodating for vegetarians .
  • Ruth F.
    Ruth Figueroa2 weeks ago
    Always amazing pizza but the menu is always changing slightly. Last time they had gluten pizza. Sucks not being able to have gluten. They also use to be able to add things to the pizza.
  • Tabitha J.
    Tabitha Johnson2 weeks ago
    The Hellboy is one of my favorite pizzas anywhere.
  • Igal G.
    Igal Ghitelman3 weeks ago
    Try their PorkypineapplePizza... Delicious 👌
  • Jarel H.
    Jarel HillJune 17
    Brisket pizza was awesome but the hellboy might be my favorite pizza of all time
  • Chad H.
    The Hellboy is spicy and sweet thanks to Mike's Hot Honey. you can also find collabs with Brooklyn favorites like Frankel's Deli and Hometown BBQ
  • Charlotte C.
    Im sure this place has great pizzas but it was an immediate turnoff that hostess was acting rude and snobby, like she was doing us a huge favor by "maybe" sitting us down. Drop the attitude Paulie
  • Tyson G.
    Tyson GachJune 4
    Been here 5+ times
    You really can’t go wrong with any pizza on the menu, but the cherry jones and hellboy are particularly crowd pleasing 👌🏼
  • Ashley W.
    omg vegan pizza options are awesome
  • Kabir d.
    Skip it - just as good or better options in the hood without the wait. "No one goes there anymore, its too crowded."
  • Bryant B.
    Excellent, authentic Neapolitan style pizza to go with excellent service. Consider coming in early for dinner to beat the crowd.
  • Jake D.
    Jake DayApril 15
    Really good pizza and chill atmosphere
  • Lee H.
    Lee HoffmanMarch 18
    The hellboy is one of the best pizzas I've ever had. The backdoor brisket is good. The Regina is ok.
  • Rachael M.
    The pizza is as good as everyone says. Come on a weeknight for less of a wait. Every pizza I've tried has been awesome!
  • Tim F.
    Tim FrietasMarch 11
    Eat it all. If not the best pizza in NY it is one of the best.
  • Nasir M.
    Nasir MemonMarch 11
    Cherry joe
  • Aaron L.
    If owner Paulie Gee stops by your table, get through the compliments quickly so you can spend this sacred minute inquiring about pizza with the oracle of world pizza knowledge that he is.
  • Daniel P.
    Daniel PalmierFebruary 28
    Wide variety of selections here! Great place to come for a quick bite to eat!
  • C-Line E.
    C-Line EatsJanuary 19
    Hellboy is my homeboy. Favorite pizza in NYC. (Greenpointer is 👌🏼 too).
  • David M.
    David MilbergJanuary 9
    Hellboy pizza is unlike any other pizza I have ever had. Absolutely fantastic. Highly recommend getting it.
  • Dave H.
    Dave HoltzJanuary 4
    The hellified porkpie white 😍
  • Emily W.
    Emily WilsonDecember 10, 2016
    Do not be appalled by a 2+ hour line if you come during prime time. Take a deep breath, go to one of the many great bars nearby for a drink and a snack, and wait... 'cuz it's worth it.
  • Staff Picks
    Staff PicksDecember 6, 2016
    Paulie Gee’s was one of the more wished for places throughout 2015’s I Want Somewhere holiday campaign. Where’s your somewhere? Enter to win a bucket list experience. Read more
  • Amber C.
    Amber CrisciNovember 27, 2016
    Ricotta be kidding me 👌🏻👌🏻
  • Ivan B.
    Ivan BlagajićNovember 20, 2016
    Perfect pizza place.
  • Jay M.
    Jay MuntuNovember 2, 2016
    This place gets full, be prepared to wait. Start the debauchery at Tender Trap next door.
  • Giovana P.
    Giovana ParasmoOctober 8, 2016
    The pesto pizza is amazing ❤️
  • Dan S.
    Dan SteilenSeptember 29, 2016
    Hellboy = amazing. Daniela Spinachi also solid.
  • Matt B.
    Matt BarberSeptember 19, 2016
    Dessert pizza is a must try. Marmalade and cream, what's not to love there
  • Matt B.
    Matt BarberSeptember 19, 2016
    Excellent stone fired pizza. Brisket BBQ is sweet and unusual but tasty.
  • Claudia F.
    Claudia FilthSeptember 6, 2016
    Pizza is amazing, but come early because there's always a wait.
  • Rock Raines
    Rock RainesAugust 13, 2016
    Pizza is remarkable though I don't necessarily understand the hype behind mike's hot honey
  • Guest of a Guest
    Guest of a GuestAugust 11, 2016
    Meat pizzas, veg pizzas, dessert pizzas, savory pizzas, weird pizzas, traditional pizzas - there is no bad slice at Pauly Gee's. Pauly Gee's has mastered them all with expert craftsmanship. Read more
  • Chris V.
    Chris VAugust 8, 2016
    Great pizza, ambiance, and service. I'm not sure it's worth the 90 minute wait on a Saturday night, though there's a few bars in the area that will help you pass the time.
  • Nicklas H.
    Nicklas HolmAugust 5, 2016
    Probably the best pizza in NYC. Get the Hellboy. Or the Ricky ricotta. Or anything really.
  • Tim O.
    Tim OAugust 3, 2016
    Try putting chili flavored honey on your pizza.
  • Isuru J.
    Isuru JayaratnaJuly 27, 2016
    Pizza forever
  • Jake C.
    Jake CraigeJuly 23, 2016
    All the pizza of course! It was great to have the owner come to our table and chat for a bit.
  • Lee S.
    Lee SimpsonJuly 12, 2016
    Good, but generally a little over rated. Not the best pizza I've ever had.
  • Kate B.
    Kate BallJune 30, 2016
    Heard amazing things about this place. Was super disappointed by extremely blackened, burned pizza.
  • Caitlin L.
    Caitlin LJune 23, 2016
    Put spicy honey on everything!
  • Kate Y.
    Kate YanMay 17, 2016
    Hellboy pizza is the way to go. Spicy honey is amazing!
  • Zack K.
    Zack KantorMay 15, 2016
    I can't eat pizza but I brake rules for this place
  • Brandon H.
    Brandon HofmannMay 13, 2016
    Veggie Sausage is great, all the pizzas are awesome and the Milk and Honey beer is amazing.
  • VelvetCrate
    VelvetCrateMay 12, 2016
    Hellboy, Brisket de Brian, 🍒 Jones = 🍕 goals
  • Jasmine D.
    Jasmine DMay 5, 2016
    Good but not the best in NY as purported. The mushroom and red onion pie and the kale pesto pie were delicious. Salads are fresh but odd ingredients and nothing special. Owner Paulie is a riot.
  • Darshy N.
    Darshy NApril 29, 2016
    Praise be to thee hell boy and cherry Jones! 🙌
  • DishEnvy
    DishEnvyApril 28, 2016
    Hell Boy is the goto but the Anise & Anephew is also a must try.
  • Dan P.
    Dan PericoneApril 24, 2016
    Been here 5+ times
    The Hellboy pie is the best!
  • Ashley A.
    Ashley AlvarezApril 23, 2016
    The pizza with drizzled hot honey keeps me up at night in a good way.
  • Kevin A.
    Kevin AbramsApril 20, 2016
    One of the best pie's in Brooklyn.
  • Paulo H.
    Paulo HApril 11, 2016
    Get the pizzas with the hot honey on it. Extremely good.
  • Time Out New York
    Time Out New YorkApril 7, 2016
    Paul Giannone will soon be opening a new, classic pizza slice joint in Greenpoint. Until then, check out his acclaimed original spot. Long lines are expected, but so are delicious, creative pies. Read more
  • Tiffany
    TiffanyMarch 14, 2016
    Cozy restaurant that's perfect for a date night or dinner w family! Must try the hellboy.
  • Juan B.
    Juan BuisMarch 7, 2016
    Paulie does the rounds a lot - if you get lucky he'll bring a free starter.
  • Margaret M.
    Margaret MyersMarch 4, 2016
    Great vegan and non vegan options! Perfect for a vegan/omnivore combo
  • Saarim Z.
    Saarim ZamanMarch 3, 2016
    The garlic knots are fire
  • Lisa T.
    Lisa ThomasFebruary 26, 2016
    Go for the Hellboy, a perfect concoction of sweet and spicy. It's their most popular pie for a reason!
  • Deborah B.
    Deborah BeardenFebruary 26, 2016
    Great pizza, best I've had in NYC
  • Martin O.
    Martin OngFebruary 23, 2016
    They make amazingly good savory pizzas with sweet toppings like Hot Honey on the Hellboy and maple syrup on the Monte Cristo
  • Globetrottergirls D.
    Globetrottergirls DaniFebruary 10, 2016
    Seriously delicious
  • Raphael
    RaphaelFebruary 3, 2016
    get pizza!
  • Ivana K.
    Ivana KurtovićJanuary 14, 2016
    Pizza is great
  • Dani O.
    Dani O'NeilJanuary 13, 2016
    Still dreaming about the Hellified Porkpie White; it's dark as hell in there, so don't be shy about cell phone lights to read the menu.
  • Corley S.
    Corley StoneJanuary 12, 2016
    UNREAL pizza! The Hellboy is delish and is topped with Mikes Hot Honey ☺️. Get here early though, because it's always packed!
  • Leah H.
    Leah HammerschlagJanuary 11, 2016
    Love everything. The dried cherry pie is really unique and delicious (even without the speck)!
  • Abby
    AbbyJanuary 6, 2016
    I got there at 5pm on Sunday and it was easy peasy to get a table. then take a walk around the neighborhood.
  • Daniel C.
    Daniel ChangDecember 31, 2015
    Surprisingly liked some of the vegetarian options as much as the meat ones
  • valerie
    valerieDecember 30, 2015
    The most amazing vegan pizza, with all homemade vegan cheeses. I'm not vegan (just lactose intolerant) & they will put meat on your vegan pizza if you ask (though the jackfruit meatballs are so good).
  • Mark M.
    Mark MunroDecember 27, 2015
    Hellified porkpie white and Hellboy are magnificent. Paulie stopped by our table; this place is as real as it gets.
  • Leland
    LelandDecember 26, 2015
    It's rare that any pizza place offer vegan pizza. So when one does, I'm all over it. This place has 7 different vegan pizza's. The Jackie Green pizza (vegan) is worth coming back for.
  • Matt D.
    Matt DonatelliDecember 19, 2015
    Low light ambiance, but too loud to be romantic. Good wood oven pizza, but the tomato sauce is a bit ok the wet side.
  • Juliana A.
    Juliana ArdilaDecember 7, 2015
    The ones with ricotta are really good. I love that they don't put pressure on you to leave (as at Roberta's). Service is fantastic! Be there early, there would be a line at 5:00
  • Ezra P.
    Ezra PollardNovember 23, 2015
    Get a Hellified Porkpie White. V have the good taste.
  • Aesop F.
    Aesop FableMonsterNovember 3, 2015
    Had the Helicopter Hellified Porkpie White and the Hometown Brisket. Both pizzas were delicious, but the hot honey drizzle on the Porkpie White is what has me wanting to go back to pursue Paulie Gees!
  • Nichlas W.
    Nichlas Wærnes AndersenNovember 2, 2015
    I had the hellboy pizza, and it was fantastic! Great service - Paulie is a super friendly guy!
  • Ranu R.
    Ranu RajkarnikarOctober 26, 2015
    Be prepared to wait but the pizza is worth it. Love their spicy honey combos. Dark and romantic vibe, and a solid beer list. 🍕 wins every time.
  • Abigail A.
    Abigail ArgersingerOctober 23, 2015
    Be prepared for long waits but really yummy, unique pizza.
  • Chet M.
    Chet ManciniOctober 17, 2015
    Flawless pizzas. Get the Hellboy if you like a flavor kick.
  • Natalie F.
    Natalie FreilichOctober 13, 2015
    Pizza that rivals roberta's. I will fare to say it's even better & there are 2x as many topping combinations. Paulie Gee will stop by your table personally and check if you're happy.
  • Tyler L.
    Tyler LundOctober 12, 2015
    Paulie Gee's is a solid option for good pizza in Brooklyn, but I think there are better options. It didn't compare to Roberta's in Bushwick or Marta in Manhattan, but was still pretty good pizza
  • Antek P.
    Antek PrzybyOctober 8, 2015
    Well its simple.Best pizza I've ever eaten in my life!!
  • Benjamin W.
    Benjamin WiederkehrOctober 6, 2015
    Mike's Hot Honey is amazing.
  • Daniel C.
    Daniel ChoeOctober 5, 2015
    Been here 10+ times
    Hellboy and the Greenpointer.
  • Hector
    HectorSeptember 28, 2015
    Pulled pork of hellboy pizza, this cozy spot will make you rethink top 3 pizza places in Brooklyn. Sit at the bar if you can!
  • Nicole C.
    Nicole CloutierSeptember 20, 2015
    Fennel sausage on the Ricky Ricotta pizza spiced up an otherwise meh pie. Hostess was a champ even while barraged by hangry hipsters.
  • Nate T.
    Nate TSeptember 12, 2015
    The owner comes out to talk with people with his authentic Bk attitude. He clearly hates hipsters, yuppies, and everyone there now but in a very endearing way.
  • Fodor's Travel
    Fodor's TravelSeptember 9, 2015
    When it comes to pizza there's stiff competition, but Paulie Gee's serves outstanding gourmet pies with creative toppings. The idea to put Mike's Hot Honey on pizza is one of many strokes of genius. Read more
  • IrmaZandl T.
    IrmaZandl The OpinionatorSeptember 6, 2015
    LOVE it. Would totally come back despite lines. We ate at the bar. Greenpointer is delicious. Also met paulie.
  • Jason F.
    Jason FrySeptember 1, 2015
    Been here 10+ times
    The bathrooms are peak Brooklyn. I mean that in a good way.
  • Anna D.
    Anna DAugust 23, 2015
    Hellboy sure is great. I think Lucali in Caroll Gardens is still best.
  • Danny T.
    Danny TrejoAugust 20, 2015
    Great thin pizza. The simpler the better.
  • Samantha F.
    Samantha FreemanAugust 15, 2015
    Hellified pork pie white dawgs!!
  • Theresa R.
    Theresa RoldanAugust 10, 2015
    If you're here, might as well go all out. Do better than the Greenpointer
  • Sapana K.
    Sapana KulkarniAugust 5, 2015
    Delicious! There's typically an hour wait, so check out great beer spot not too far away to wait.
  • Bobby N.
    Bobby NooromidAugust 4, 2015
    If you end up sitting in the front, be sure to check out the oven area in the back where all the magic happens.
  • Michael M.
    Michael MarranziniAugust 4, 2015
    Vegan Pizza Menu is on point.
  • Gi E.
    Gi EdgingtonAugust 2, 2015
    Been here 5+ times
    Pizza is just out of this world. Literally.
  • Drew H.
    Drew HowardJuly 31, 2015
    Some of the best pizza...ever. Order the Hellboy. Arrive early as there are no reservations and it gets packed! Be sure to say hi to Paulie while you're there.
  • Nate F.
    Nate F.July 23, 2015
    Been here 10+ times
    NYC's best pizza. If you need some fuel to keep you going all night long, come here. Don't leave without trying the Cherry Jones and Hellboy - the perfect order.
673 Photos

Related Searches

  • paulie gee’s brooklyn
  • paulie gee’s brooklyn photos
  • paulie gee’s brooklyn location
  • paulie gee’s brooklyn address
  • paulie gee’s brooklyn
  • paulie gee brooklyn
  • paulie gee's brooklyn
  • paulie gees brooklyn
  • paulie gee’s brooklyn
  • paulie gee’s pizzeria brooklyn
  • paulie g’s pizzeria brooklyn
  • paulie gee’s greenpoint brooklyn

Foursquare © 2017  Lovingly made in NYC & SF