Peanut Butter & Co.

Peanut Butter & Co.

Sandwich Place, Ice Cream Shop, and Dessert Shop · Greenwich Village
240 Sullivan St (btwn Bleecker & W 3rd), New York, NY 10012, United States
Closed until 11:00 AM tomorrow (Show more)
  • Mon–Thu, Sun
    • 11:00 AM–9:00 PM
  • Fri–Sat
    • 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
$ $ $ $
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Dessert
Credit Cards:
Yes (incl. American Express & MasterCard)
Outdoor Seating:

The Sandwich Shop opened in 1998. Whether you're a student looking for a PB&J in between classes, a Greenwich Village resident dropping by for a slice of Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie, or a visitor from out of town who wants to try our Death By Peanut Butter Sundae, we look f... (See all)


Based on 325 votes

People like this place

  • What you need to know
    Serious Eats
    "We're fans of the mighty maple - with maple peanut butter and bacon."(5 Tips)
    "Do you love peanut butter sandwiches?"(5 Tips)
    Peter S.
    "And if you need a classic--get the fluffernutter."(5 Tips)
    "❤️ the Elvis with bacon and the Cinnamon and Raisin is delightful."(5 Tips)
Log in to leave tips at this venue!
  • Recent
  • Popular

128 tips and reviews.

  • Filter by taste:
  • all tips and reviews
  • sandwiches
  • mighty maple
  • fluffernutter
  • milkshakes
  • bacon
  • peanut butter
  • desserts
  • spicy food
  • ice cream sundaes
  • family-friendly
  • cute
  • good for a quick meal
  • great value
  • smoothies
  • casual
  • good service
  • brownies
  • authentic
  • cherry cheesecake
  • comfort food
  • Travelzoo

    #Travelzoo Deal: For $10, get double the amount to spend on any peanut butter snacks or shakes you desire at this Village staple. Purchase by: 12/26/15 Read more

    Travelzoo · 3 weeks ago
  • Kimmie O.

    They serve savory dishes too! Their 'the heat is on' has spicy peanut butter, grilled chicken & some pineapple jam - a play on Thai chicken satay. They only serve non-peanut butter sandwiches :P

    Kimmie Ohh · 3 weeks ago
  • Kimmie O.

    If you love peanut butter, come here :P. Get the cookie dough surprise! It has peanut butter, vanilla cream cheese & chocolate chips!

    Kimmie Ohh · 3 weeks ago
  • Nicolette R.

    Big sandwiches! Try the Elvis with a glass of milk!

    Nicolette Romero · September 15
  • J P.

    S'mores sandwich was very good

    J P · August 12
  • Sam H.

    I only ever eat the Jerry Seinfeld because it's so darn goooood - I always intend to change my order but get reeled in at the last minute

    Sam H · August 7
  • Sevgi S.

    The Elvis 👌 it can't go wrong! Recommended with Crunchy PB. During nice weather enjoy this delicious taste at Washington Sq. Park 👍

    Sevgi Sairoglu · June 27
  • Kat C.

    Sort of plain, but definitely worth trying. The white chocolate Wonderful wasn't all that bad of a sandwich! :-)

    Kat Cameron · June 6
  • drew t.

    The Peanut Butter BLT sounds weird but it's phenomenal. You'll never look at bacon + PB the same way again.

    drew tarvin · May 25
  • Kate Y.

    All sandwiches come with chips and carrots, just like elementary school days.

    Kate Yan · May 19
  • ℰℓenaᶳᵘ²

    You can't go wrong with any item on the menu. Great variety of peanut combinations and drink selections of milkshakes and smoothies. ❤️ the Elvis with bacon and the Cinnamon and Raisin is delightful.

  • Meghan S.

    Eat the Elvis and get a jar or two to go. You can eat their peanut butter by the spoonful.

    Meghan Simon · March 12
  • Rebecca W.

    This is heaven. Eat everything.

    Rebecca W · February 23
  • kate k

    Gluten free bread

    kate k · December 26, 2014
  • Chris H.

    I'm not a doctor, but I think I may have diabetes now. Place is full of cracky goodness. Warmed the cockles of my heart :)

    Chris Hedeen · November 30, 2014
  • Jennifer U.

    Great people, messed up sandwich but made it right and then some! Highly recommend...

    Jennifer Ullrich-Hedeen · November 30, 2014
  • Shannon C.

    Get the Pregnant Lady - so good

    Shannon Coulson · November 19, 2014
  • Sarah

    Yummy! Get the Maple with bacon!!

    Sarah · November 14, 2014
  • Mariana B.

    SO yummy! Sad that the gluten free bread was so small. I felt jipped but it was too tasty to be too mad. Really would suggest a bigger loaf brand like Udi's or something guys.

    Mariana Bernasconi · October 28, 2014
  • ZZubin

    Surprisingly filling, and comes with (terrible) potato chips and carrot sticks. Still can't quite condone paying the $7+ for a PBJ

    ZZubin · September 7, 2014
  • Paige C.

    I still haven't tried the 9-bite PB&J, but I have seen it and I want it!

    Paige C · September 3, 2014
  • Andreas B.

    This sounded more interesting than it was...

    Andreas Bränström · August 27, 2014
  • TV Food Maps

    Check out Peanut Butter Read more

    TV Food Maps · August 26, 2014
  • Anne A.

    Fluffernutter with maple flavor. Get it.

    Anne Aretz · August 18, 2014
  • Allison L.

    Peanut butter shake!

    Allison Loftus · August 8, 2014
  • What's Good Here

    Get the Elvis - a grilled peanut butter sandwich, stuffed w/ bananas, honey, & bacon. One of NY Magazine’s 101 Best Sandwiches. Choose the maple peanut butter to go with it.

    What's Good Here · August 7, 2014
  • Harumi U.

    When they realized our original order was going to take a while, they gave us another item from the menu AND the original order at the end. This is service! (And both were great by the way)

    Harumi U · June 22, 2014
  • Kelsey L.

    The people who work here take themselves a little too seriously, but the food is great. Grab a sandwich, milkshake, and a friend and picnic in nearby Washington square park!

    Kelsey Lee · April 20, 2014
  • Carolina R R.

    The Elvis with the mighty maple and bacon is really good

    Carolina R Rieth · April 8, 2014
  • VanA.

    Childhood favorite dressed up for adults. PB&J club... the bees knees...

    VanA. · March 25, 2014
  • Faith R.

    Yay! This place is so cute.

    Faith Redding · November 3, 2013
  • Grace N.

    Great atmosphere and delicious sandwiches. The dark chocolate peanut butter is unreal.

    Grace Nelson · October 19, 2013
  • Steve A.

    This was beyond delicious. And they were so so nice. I loved the tuna melt!

    Steve Adams · June 24, 2013
  • Tyler M.

    Mighty Maple: a sandwich with bacon and maple peanut butter. Are those not two of the greatest things in life?

    Tyler Murphy · June 24, 2013
  • Ben K.

    The chocolate peanut butter pie is delicious, highly recommend it

    Ben Krasnow · June 22, 2013
  • Serena P.

    Check out the amazing How About We deal!

    Serena Piol · June 3, 2013
  • Lee W.

    Nice sandwiches but not impressed with the service - we were treated to a surly response when other patrons were not. Won't be returning.

    Lee Woods · May 28, 2013
  • Taylor P.

    The cinnamon raisin gourmet sandwich is the bomb.

    Taylor Perry · May 23, 2013
  • Aj

    If you like peanut butter, this is the place. The peanut butter sundaes use real fudge.

    Aj · May 9, 2013
  • Jeremy B.

    PB&J Milkshake

    Jeremy Berens · May 8, 2013
  • Jeana C.

    The Elvis is delish! Peanut Butter + Banana + Honey on grilled bread. Suggest it with chunky PB.

    Jeana Costa · April 20, 2013
  • Minji S.

    They know how a Peanut butter jelly sandwich should be. Creative pb&j sandwiches!! You can choose your type of texture or flavor for pb & flavores of jelly! Yeah :)

    Minji Son · March 27, 2013
  • Serious Eats

    Don't be afraid of their strange-sounding combinations. We're fans of the mighty maple - with maple peanut butter and bacon.

    Serious Eats · March 6, 2013
  • Vidula

    Delicious, but overpriced.

    Vidula · February 27, 2013
  • Rebekah K.

    Do NOT get the Elvis shake!!!

    Rebekah Keena · February 24, 2013
  • Thalia K.

    Try the Peanut Butter Sampler - 8 different kinds of peanut butter! My favorites: "The Heat is On" "Mighty Maple" "Cinnamon Raisin Swirl"

    Thalia K · February 10, 2013
  • Caitlin C.

    This place is fun inside and certainly a novelty. The sandwiches are a bit pricey, but the Peanut Butter Brownie was a delicious treat.

    Caitlin Clements · February 10, 2013
  • Alex M.

    The White Chocolate Wonderful Sandwich is so good, it's a little unfair to the other sandwiches.

    Alex Mann · January 29, 2013
  • Tome C.

    The Elvis with bacon is what you need to order, add a peanut butter shake and you're all set!

    Tome C · January 5, 2013
  • Andrew S.

    Try the spicy peanut butter... and make sure you drink milk with it.

    Andrew Silikovitz · December 16, 2012

Related Searches

  • peanut butter & co. new york
  • peanut butter & co. new york photos
  • peanut butter & co. new york location
  • peanut butter & co. new york address
  • peanut butter & co. new york
  • peanut butter & co new york
  • peanut butter & co. new york
  • peanut butter & company new york
  • peanut butter &co. new york
  • peanut butter and co new york
  • peanut butter and co. new york
  • peanut butter andco. new york
  • peanut butter co. new york
  • peanut butter & co. greenwich village new york

Foursquare © 2015  Lovingly made in NYC & SF

Appears on 463 lists

See all »

Is this your business? Claim it now.

Make sure your information is up to date. Plus use our free tools to find new customers.