Peanut Butter & Co.

(Now Closed)
Sandwich Place, Ice Cream Shop, and Dessert Shop$$$$
Greenwich Village, New York
Save
Share
128 Tips and reviews
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent
  • What's Good Here
    What's Good HereAugust 7, 2014
    Get the Elvis - a grilled peanut butter sandwich, stuffed w/ bananas, honey, & bacon. One of NY Magazine’s 101 Best Sandwiches. Choose the maple peanut butter to go with it.
  • Kimmie O.
    Kimmie OhhNovember 2, 2015
    They serve savory dishes too! Their 'the heat is on' has spicy peanut butter, grilled chicken & some pineapple jam - a play on Thai chicken satay. They only serve non-peanut butter sandwiches :P
  • Untapped Cities
    Untapped CitiesJanuary 7, 2016
    If you’re the type to spread peanut butter on everything or sometimes find yourself eating it straight from the jar, Peanut Butter and Co is your paradise. Read more
  • Florence H.
    Florence HNovember 6, 2012
    Great place to relive childhood memories, or if you're like me, experience a bit of the classical American lunch tradition I never had as a kid. Complete with brown paper bag, chips and carrot sticks.
  • Ariel E.
    Ariel ElizabethFebruary 10, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    I love the cherry cheesecake sandwich- cherry preserves, cream cheese, crunchy PB on toasted white bread. It was the 'sandwich of the week' at one time, but I ask for it each time I visit! Delish!!!
  • Harumi U.
    Harumi UJune 22, 2014
    When they realized our original order was going to take a while, they gave us another item from the menu AND the original order at the end. This is service! (And both were great by the way)
  • Peanut Butter & Co.
    Peanut Butter & Co.August 14, 2012
    End hunger and get 10% off every time you're in the Shop! Join the Mutual by donating $10 to Food Bank For NYC. Membership to Mutual gives u access to other great perks from different stores in NYC! Read more
  • Kelsey L.
    Kelsey LeeApril 20, 2014
    The people who work here take themselves a little too seriously, but the food is great. Grab a sandwich, milkshake, and a friend and picnic in nearby Washington square park!
  • New York Habitat
    New York HabitatOctober 27, 2011
    If you love peanut butter sandwiches, this is the place for you. Tons of crazy yet delicious combinations. Try the "Elvis" - grilled with peanut butter, banana, honey, and bacon!
  • Vanessa P.
    Vanessa PowellAugust 4, 2012
    Seriously obsessed with this place. I created my own toasted wheat sandwich with cinnamon peanut butter, bananas and fluff... So delish!
  • Serious Eats
    Serious EatsMarch 6, 2013
    Don't be afraid of their strange-sounding combinations. We're fans of the mighty maple - with maple peanut butter and bacon.
  • Sevgi S.
    Sevgi SairogluJune 27, 2015
    The Elvis 👌 it can't go wrong! Recommended with Crunchy PB. During nice weather enjoy this delicious taste at Washington Sq. Park 👍
  • Kimmie O.
    Kimmie OhhNovember 2, 2015
    If you love peanut butter, come here :P. Get the cookie dough surprise! It has peanut butter, vanilla cream cheese & chocolate chips!
  • GourmetLive
    GourmetLiveMarch 24, 2011
    The ultimate ode to the P on the PB&J, which, of course, you can get here in several ways, including doubled up in a PB&J Club. Definitely a must-eat in bakery world USA.
  • Minji S.
    Minji SonMarch 27, 2013
    They know how a Peanut butter jelly sandwich should be. Creative pb&j sandwiches!! You can choose your type of texture or flavor for pb & flavores of jelly! Yeah :)
  • Mariana B.
    Mariana BernasconiOctober 28, 2014
    SO yummy! Sad that the gluten free bread was so small. I felt jipped but it was too tasty to be too mad. Really would suggest a bigger loaf brand like Udi's or something guys.
  • Omer Z.
    Omer ZachJune 21, 2012
    If you're a huge PB fan and it's nearby, it might be worth at try, but the sandwiches aren't particularly creative and don't use any better ingredients than you'd get at most grocery stores.
  • Caitlin C.
    Caitlin ClementsFebruary 10, 2013
    This place is fun inside and certainly a novelty. The sandwiches are a bit pricey, but the Peanut Butter Brownie was a delicious treat.
  • Gray Line New York
    Gray Line New YorkDecember 5, 2011
    Hop-off at Stop #7 & try The Elvis! Buy a sandwich & show your Gray Line New York ticket at checkout to receive a FREE jar of peanut butter. Offer valid in shop only between December 5-16, 2011.
  • Robert R.
    Robert RoweOctober 10, 2010
    ...get some extra bacon on the already scrumptious sandwich The Elvis (grilled with peanut butter, which is stuffed with bananas and honey). Crazy Good! It's now or never... Read more
  • Jessica N.
    Jessica NortonOctober 8, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    Lactose-free lovers, the peanut butter smoothie is made with peanut butter, honey, ice chips, and SOY milk. Mucho delicioso.
  • Kat C.
    Kat CameronJune 6, 2015
    Sort of plain, but definitely worth trying. The white chocolate Wonderful wasn't all that bad of a sandwich! :-)
  • Thalia K.
    Thalia KFebruary 10, 2013
    Try the Peanut Butter Sampler - 8 different kinds of peanut butter! My favorites: "The Heat is On" "Mighty Maple" "Cinnamon Raisin Swirl"
  • Jeana C.
    Jeana CostaApril 20, 2013
    The Elvis is delish! Peanut Butter + Banana + Honey on grilled bread. Suggest it with chunky PB.
  • nymag
    nymagJuly 20, 2010
    Try the Elvis, one of our 101 Best Sandwiches in New York. Peanut butter, bacon, banana, and honey on white toast - fit for the King. Read more
  • Kate Y.
    Kate YanMay 19, 2015
    All sandwiches come with chips and carrots, just like elementary school days.
  • Kristina R.
    Kristina RodulfoJuly 27, 2012
    Cute, talk-for-hours-friendly, and right by campus. Love the cinnamon peanut butter cream cheese apple sandwich!
  • Carolina R R.
    Carolina R RiethApril 8, 2014
    The Elvis with the mighty maple and bacon is really good
  • Christine
    ChristineJune 23, 2012
    Cookie dough surprise was very tasty. Went well with a grape soda.
  • Allison C.
    Allison CNovember 5, 2011
    This place is super cute and yummy! Just make sure you get a glass of milk to wash it down:)
  • Fanboy Gaymer
    Fanboy GaymerAugust 5, 2011
    Do I even need to discuss the power of an "Elvis"? Peanut Butter done right. With bacon. Make sure to check out the sweet soda selection. Lots of fruity options.
  • Eunic O.
    Eunic OrtizFebruary 6, 2011
    Right around the corner from Bobst Library (NYU student haven) you might be able to score delivery to your study group depending on the season.
  • Chris H.
    Chris HedeenNovember 30, 2014
    I'm not a doctor, but I think I may have diabetes now. Place is full of cracky goodness. Warmed the cockles of my heart :)
  • David B.
    David BerkowitzOctober 10, 2011
    Try the Elvis Peanut Butter Sandwich - Bananas, honey, peanut butter, and bacon - perfect combo
  • Andrea F.
    Andrea FaggianiOctober 12, 2016
    The Fluffernutter sandwich (peanut butter and marshmallow fluff) was amazing. So yummy!
  • Spam
    SpamFebruary 2, 2010
    This place is heaven for peanut butter lovers! You might want to skip the peanut butter BLT...there's not enough bacon to keep it from getting drowned out by the peanut butter.
  • Grace N.
    Grace NelsonOctober 19, 2013
    Great atmosphere and delicious sandwiches. The dark chocolate peanut butter is unreal.
  • Sam H.
    Sam HAugust 7, 2015
    I only ever eat the Jerry Seinfeld because it's so darn goooood - I always intend to change my order but get reeled in at the last minute
  • drew t.
    drew tarvinMay 25, 2015
    The Peanut Butter BLT sounds weird but it's phenomenal. You'll never look at bacon + PB the same way again.
  • Amanda L.
    Amanda LeeDecember 19, 2015
    Peanut butter sampler, banarama sundae, basically everything is incredible.
  • Aj
    AjMay 9, 2013
    If you like peanut butter, this is the place. The peanut butter sundaes use real fudge.
  • Andrea F.
    Andrea FaggianiOctober 12, 2016
    The Fluffernutter sandwich (peanut butter and marshmallow) was amazing! So yummy!
  • Tome C.
    Tome CJanuary 5, 2013
    The Elvis with bacon is what you need to order, add a peanut butter shake and you're all set!
  • ms
    msMarch 12, 2015
    Eat the Elvis and get a jar or two to go. You can eat their peanut butter by the spoonful.
  • Andrew S.
    Andrew SilikovitzDecember 16, 2012
    Try the spicy peanut butter... and make sure you drink milk with it.
  • Frank R.
    Frank RimalovskiMay 26, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    Maple peanut butter & bacon on wheat toast. Doesn't get much better than that! (4 of 4 petals via Fondu) Read more
  • Ben K.
    Ben KrasnowJune 22, 2013
    The chocolate peanut butter pie is delicious, highly recommend it
  • Liz G.
    Liz GAugust 27, 2011
    The Jerry Seinfeld Comedy Special is the way to go! Your mouth will be overwhelmed!
  • Kierra L.
    Kierra LeoneOctober 23, 2010
    Before you try the Elvis, grub on the peanut butter BLT. had it and was mesmerized! Next for me is the ELVIS.
  • Steve A.
    Steve AdamsJune 24, 2013
    This was beyond delicious. And they were so so nice. I loved the tuna melt!
  • Jennifer U.
    Jennifer Ullrich-HedeenNovember 30, 2014
    Great people, messed up sandwich but made it right and then some! Highly recommend...
  • Alex M.
    Alex MannJanuary 29, 2013
    The White Chocolate Wonderful Sandwich is so good, it's a little unfair to the other sandwiches.
  • Kevin S.
    Kevin SkobacOctober 19, 2011
    Try the peanut-butter & fluff, or the Elvis (PB with banana and honey)
  • Nicolette R.
    Nicolette RomeroSeptember 15, 2015
    Big sandwiches! Try the Elvis with a glass of milk!
  • Mommy Shorts
    Mommy ShortsJanuary 2, 2011
    Fluffernutters, classic lunchbox specials, and ants on a log. Plus the more adventurous Elvis for the adults.
  • Kyle M.
    Kyle MOctober 12, 2012
    Omg the death by peanut butter sundae is soooo phenomenal. It's orgasmic. You'll have to split it.
  • Peter S.
    Peter StoffanJanuary 27, 2011
    The cinnamon swirl is crazy delish. And if you need a classic--get the fluffernutter. It eats you out.
  • ZZubin
    ZZubinSeptember 7, 2014
    Surprisingly filling, and comes with (terrible) potato chips and carrot sticks. Still can't quite condone paying the $7+ for a PBJ
  • Amanda D.
    Amanda DeSapriOctober 17, 2012
    I have cravings forThe Fluffernutter shake all the way from CLEVELAND we had to come back to get it again!
  • LogoTV
    LogoTVJune 1, 2010
    "All Peanut Butter themed sandwiches of awesomeness. I like the "Elvis" sandwich more than I like most of my friends." - Jeffery Self, Jeffery & Cole Casserole
  • Tyler M.
    Tyler MurphyJune 24, 2013
    Mighty Maple: a sandwich with bacon and maple peanut butter. Are those not two of the greatest things in life?
  • Barrie C.
    Barrie CohnJanuary 23, 2012
    Always my favorite place for dessert. Peanut butter pie = heaven on a plate.
  • Eldon C.
    Eldon CarandanJuly 22, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    Try "The Elvis" or the "Peanut Butter Club"...so good, it's ridonculous!!!
  • Mashable
    MashableJune 6, 2010
    Do you love peanut butter sandwiches? If so, go here and order the "Peanut Butter Cup". Life will not be the same after that! - Brett Petersel
  • David D.
    David DownsJuly 15, 2010
    Pick up a jar of the cinnamon raisin peanut butter, and dark chocolate peanut butter! Just eat it with a spoon!
  • Andrew N.
    Andrew NicholsonOctober 19, 2010
    A bit pricy for a sandwich. But the specialty shakes are amazing. Totally worth the money.
  • Taylor P.
    Taylor PerryMay 23, 2013
    The cinnamon raisin gourmet sandwich is the bomb.
  • Dora
    DoraJuly 21, 2010
    Buy a jar of all-natural peanut butter – there are 10 flavors! – and make the shop’s famous sandwiches at home. Powered by ParentsConnect.com
  • Rahadyan S.
    Rahadyan SastrowardoyoSeptember 30, 2011
    One of my guilty pleasures. <3 the Elvis: peanut butter, bacon, banana and honey!
  • Shannon H.
    Shannon HunterAugust 16, 2011
    Try the Lunchbox special with bacon = yum.
  • Melissa P.
    Melissa PendletonJune 13, 2012
    The best comfort food in Manhattan. Crusts off and a crazy straw, please!
  • Jeany
    JeanyJanuary 21, 2012
    Definetely try the egg cream there in chocolate! It's amazing!
  • L
    LApril 17, 2012
    The Elvis was great...dont even think about dieting (3 of 4 petals via Fondu) Read more
  • Anne A.
    Anne AretzAugust 18, 2014
    Fluffernutter with maple flavor. Get it.
  • Scrollmotion
    ScrollmotionDecember 18, 2010
    love to order from here - peanut butter on anything is great
  • justinstoned
    justinstonedMarch 31, 2010
    desipte all the hype a tasty place! try the elvis.. everything tastes better with bacon. everything.
  • Jake S.
    Jake SimmsApril 20, 2012
    Get the Elvis with bacon so you don't live your life wondering "what if"
  • Jillana B.
    Jillana BMay 28, 2012
    Get the Elvis & pay the extra buck for the bacon.
  • Brian M.
    Brian MichaelOctober 12, 2012
    Look at how they serve tea!
  • Paige C.
    Paige CSeptember 3, 2014
    I still haven't tried the 9-bite PB&J, but I have seen it and I want it!
  • david ' dj shakez ' t.
    Elvis is way too heavy (the sandwich)... Best part is the bacon that costs extra. Skip it!
  • Jamie
    JamieAugust 11, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    Pb&j milkshake is my favorite milkshake ever
  • Nicole M.
    Nicole MartinFebruary 6, 2012
    Try the Elvis - Crunchy peanut butter, bananas and bacon!
  • Rebecca W.
    Rebecca WFebruary 23, 2015
    Been here 5+ times
    This is heaven. Eat everything.
  • Nicole H.
    Nicole HeringNovember 14, 2011
    But yourself a jar of smooth operator and bring the goodness home with you!
  • Sarah
    SarahNovember 14, 2014
    Yummy! Get the Maple with bacon!!
  • Jessica M.
    Jessica MasslerJanuary 2, 2016
    Get crunchy peanut butter any anything with bacon.
  • Dave C.
    Dave CronenOctober 1, 2011
    Simply the greatest shop in the world!
  • Meredith P.
    Meredith PeruzziDecember 12, 2010
    $10 credit card minimum - the samples are $1 if you need a boost.
  • Michelle W.
    Michelle WadeJanuary 4, 2012
    Get the chocolate peanut butter pie! It's bomb!
  • Andrew R.
    Andrew RosseNovember 5, 2011
    Eat the PB Bliss sundae, so gooooood :)
  • Michelle C.
    Michelle CooperJanuary 23, 2011
    Gotta have the Elvis! It'll be your fav too.
  • Serena P.
    Serena PiolJune 3, 2013
    Check out the amazing How About We deal!
  • Lisa M.
    Lisa McPheeJanuary 26, 2010
    We saw it on the food network and had to go. Creamy & Smooth it was so worth the trip!
  • kashew
    kashewNovember 16, 2010
    Elvis with bacon and crunchy peanut butter is the stuff
  • Jeffrey B.
    Jeffrey BehmDecember 1, 2010
    The spicy PB sandwich is delicious!
  • Charlotte B.
    Charlotte BounousSeptember 28, 2009
    For the dessert-obsessed, their peanut butter pie is so tasty -- and made from scratch.
  • Shannon C.
    Shannon CoulsonNovember 19, 2014
    Get the Pregnant Lady - so good
  • J P.
    J PAugust 12, 2015
    S'mores sandwich was very good
  • Marcus C.
    Marcus CalderonJune 14, 2012
    Elvis! Bacon. Yes, please.
352 Photos

Related Searches

  • peanut butter & co. new york
  • peanut butter & co. new york photos
  • peanut butter & co. new york location
  • peanut butter & co. new york address
  • peanut butter & co. new york
  • peanut butter & co new york
  • peanut butter & co. new york
  • peanut butter & company new york
  • peanut butter &co. new york
  • peanut butter and co new york
  • peanut butter and co. new york
  • peanut butter andco. new york
  • peanut butter co. new york
  • peanut butter & co. greenwich village new york

Foursquare © 2017  Lovingly made in NYC & SF