The Sandwich Shop opened in 1998. Whether you're a student looking for a PB&J in between classes, a Greenwich Village resident dropping by for a slice of Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie, or a visitor from out of town who wants to try our Death By Peanut Butter Sundae, we look forward to seeing you!
Get crunchy peanut butter any anything with bacon.
Peanut butter sampler, banarama sundae, basically everything is incredible.
They serve savory dishes too! Their 'the heat is on' has spicy peanut butter, grilled chicken & some pineapple jam - a play on Thai chicken satay. They only serve non-peanut butter sandwiches :P
If you love peanut butter, come here :P. Get the cookie dough surprise! It has peanut butter, vanilla cream cheese & chocolate chips!
Big sandwiches! Try the Elvis with a glass of milk!
S'mores sandwich was very good
I only ever eat the Jerry Seinfeld because it's so darn goooood - I always intend to change my order but get reeled in at the last minute
The Elvis 👌 it can't go wrong! Recommended with Crunchy PB. During nice weather enjoy this delicious taste at Washington Sq. Park 👍
Sort of plain, but definitely worth trying. The white chocolate Wonderful wasn't all that bad of a sandwich! :-)
The Peanut Butter BLT sounds weird but it's phenomenal. You'll never look at bacon + PB the same way again.
All sandwiches come with chips and carrots, just like elementary school days.
You can't go wrong with any item on the menu. Great variety of peanut combinations and drink selections of milkshakes and smoothies. ❤️ the Elvis with bacon and the Cinnamon and Raisin is delightful.
Eat the Elvis and get a jar or two to go. You can eat their peanut butter by the spoonful.
This is heaven. Eat everything.
Gluten free bread
I'm not a doctor, but I think I may have diabetes now. Place is full of cracky goodness. Warmed the cockles of my heart :)
Great people, messed up sandwich but made it right and then some! Highly recommend...
Get the Pregnant Lady - so good
Yummy! Get the Maple with bacon!!
SO yummy! Sad that the gluten free bread was so small. I felt jipped but it was too tasty to be too mad. Really would suggest a bigger loaf brand like Udi's or something guys.
Surprisingly filling, and comes with (terrible) potato chips and carrot sticks. Still can't quite condone paying the $7+ for a PBJ
I still haven't tried the 9-bite PB&J, but I have seen it and I want it!
This sounded more interesting than it was...
Fluffernutter with maple flavor. Get it.
Peanut butter shake!
Get the Elvis - a grilled peanut butter sandwich, stuffed w/ bananas, honey, & bacon. One of NY Magazine’s 101 Best Sandwiches. Choose the maple peanut butter to go with it.
When they realized our original order was going to take a while, they gave us another item from the menu AND the original order at the end. This is service! (And both were great by the way)
The people who work here take themselves a little too seriously, but the food is great. Grab a sandwich, milkshake, and a friend and picnic in nearby Washington square park!
The Elvis with the mighty maple and bacon is really good
Childhood favorite dressed up for adults. PB&J club... the bees knees...
Yay! This place is so cute.
Great atmosphere and delicious sandwiches. The dark chocolate peanut butter is unreal.
This was beyond delicious. And they were so so nice. I loved the tuna melt!
Mighty Maple: a sandwich with bacon and maple peanut butter. Are those not two of the greatest things in life?
The chocolate peanut butter pie is delicious, highly recommend it
Check out the amazing How About We deal!
Nice sandwiches but not impressed with the service - we were treated to a surly response when other patrons were not. Won't be returning.
The cinnamon raisin gourmet sandwich is the bomb.
If you like peanut butter, this is the place. The peanut butter sundaes use real fudge.
The Elvis is delish! Peanut Butter + Banana + Honey on grilled bread. Suggest it with chunky PB.
They know how a Peanut butter jelly sandwich should be. Creative pb&j sandwiches!! You can choose your type of texture or flavor for pb & flavores of jelly! Yeah :)
Don't be afraid of their strange-sounding combinations. We're fans of the mighty maple - with maple peanut butter and bacon.
Delicious, but overpriced.
Do NOT get the Elvis shake!!!
Try the Peanut Butter Sampler - 8 different kinds of peanut butter! My favorites: "The Heat is On" "Mighty Maple" "Cinnamon Raisin Swirl"
This place is fun inside and certainly a novelty. The sandwiches are a bit pricey, but the Peanut Butter Brownie was a delicious treat.
The White Chocolate Wonderful Sandwich is so good, it's a little unfair to the other sandwiches.