Weak, slow service, food took way too long. Ok veggie burger, probably wouldn't come back.
Amazing food - meatballs!!
The chicken meatball salad is a game changer. Who would have thought that you could crave a salad?
Veggie burgers are great here
Don't understand why it's so busy here, service was slow and food was very average. Having said that, the ketchup they sell is quite good.
Super OVERRATED. Nothing was too special or too delicious during my brunch experience here. Cramped table space, tiny plates, long waits to get seated.
Great for brunch, indulge in the Nutella French toast!
The beet salad is incredible for a light dinner.
Get the Nutella French toast if you're looking for something sweet.
The only really good breakfast spot in the area. Get here early- it fills up quickly during the AM breakfast rush.
On our last visit,we waited over an hour for a table, then an additional 1.25 hours for our food (which was just eggs). That's a 2.25 hour wait for brunch! Love Penelope, but NO food is *that* good.
The monkey bread is on point
Great spot for breakfast/brunch, cozy and busy place.
Orange juice and coffee are so good. Food is great. Be ready for a great breakfast over there !
Lovely and delicious breakfast. Forgot American portions though so had to leave half of it. Nice service too. Good brunch menu.
Chicken meatballs gosh
Best place to start a day in NY!
Nice breakfast for a decent price. Especially given the part of NYC it is located in. Unfortunately no WiFi.
Delicious traditional america. breakfast, try pancakes.
Nice little restaurant with really great pancakes for breakfast!
Extremely friendly service, good food and relaxed mood.
Super cute place. We loved going there for brunch.
Yummy yummy! Makes sure to have a brunch cocktail
Nice brunch, get there early...it's usually full of people
The wait is almost always 1 and a 1/2 hour. Make sure to stop by early to reserve. Cute brunch spot!
The chorizo egg sandwich is amazingly good!!! Do it with the croissant. Definitely hit the spot and more!!! Also, the service is extremely attentive!!!!
Nutella French toast - but swap bananas for strawberries.
Try the French toast with Nutella. Massive portion and delicious.
Great for brunch! The Nutella French toast is highly recommended!
Mediocre food for dinner with terrible service. The staff just chat away as of there are no customers.
Be prepared for at least an hour wait
The Nutella French toast
100% worth the wait. Try to beat the crowd by opting for breakfast instead of brunch.
Great lobster rolls
Food is above average. Service is a bit slow though.
Arugula salad with chicken meatballs were a unique item and delicious. Slight overload on arugula. Love the atmosphere
We had a great Monday breakfast. Saturday and Sunday brunch fills up quick. Try a week day breakfast to avoid the crowd.
Chicken meatball sandwich was so good and moist! Yummy fries too.
A great place for breakfast but they do not open until 8:00am. Their chicken pot pie is the best in the City.
The Penny Egg sandwich is delicious.
I love the Punkin' Waffles. The maple-style butter with pumpkin waffles is a heavenly combination.
Only 3 words... Nutella French Toast. Yum