Mini burgers are great. Appetizers are good
Wonderful winter spot in Lincoln Center, gets busy during shows/events. The Cadillac burger is awesome!
Really greasy and flavorless :(. Avoid the eggplant sticks
10% discount for NYPhil subscribers.
Liked the cadillac burger, the mac and cheese. Bread pudding was also good
I like the original much better, but the burgers are pretty good here too.
They changed the mac and cheese! Now with green onions and bread crumbs. Still good, but it's no peas 'n bacon mac 'n cheese. Cadillac Burger is perfectly cooked and has a hint of sweetness. Get it.
Had the best blue burger yet. The apple pie can be divided by two people and it's extremely hot. So I recommend an ice scoop of vanilla ice cream to cool it off.
Fish&Cips is perfect 😍
Brilliant place! A very cosy and beautiful dark wood pub full of NY atmosphere. Burgers are great and I also ❤️ the Skirt Stake, Oysters, and the Chicken Pot Pie. The service is top notch.
Way overpriced for the amount and quality of food—you're better off going to a cheaper Bar & Grille for half the cost. Also note—NO substitutions.
The cheeseburger is good but uninventive
The Clarke Punch is pretty awesome and refreshing!
Lovely staff. Took no time to grab a table during Fashion Week. The mac & cheese with peas and bacon is honestly incredible. Order it!
The burgers are one of the highlights of the menu. It was cooked perfectly but definitely lacked seasoning. Wouldn't come back here again. Oh and stupidly over priced for what you get.
The atmosphere is welcoming and bustling, but way overpriced. We had a Turkey Burger, a BBQ Burger, the Cadillac Burger, Mac n Cheese and my kids ❤ the Chicken Fingers and Grilled Cheese.
BEST OYSTERS EVER: The Roast Oysters Rockefeller. Try it ;)
The sister Mary walks funny is a must try
A good burger, but not the best as many claim.
The best burger of NY. A must go!!
Kale salad was super good.
Cool authentic place which gets you in Great Gatsby movie! Bartenders and waiters are mature aristocratic professionals. Good choose of beer.
Had lunch with my brother and sister here the other day. Food can take some time to come out as it's generally packed, but their burgers never disappoint. You can't leave a bite untouched here.
One of the best burgers on the island. Bonus points: they cook their meat on the rare side. For sides, get the spinach, brussels, or Mac and cheese.
McCarthy the bartender!
BBQ Bleue Cheeseburguer is awesome!!
Good for breakfast. A little pricey
Best Mac n cheese ever!
Tuna tartare tacos are unreal!! Kale and avocado salad is great too
Above average pub fair, ok service, awesome views of Battery Park marina.
Can't go wrong with a burger here
A true classic. Get the cheeseburger. Add lettuce tomato caramelized onion and bernaise sauce. You can thank me later.
Of course burgers, but they have other really good options as well.
I work across the street and come here often. The bartenders always take care of me! Some of the best bartenders I've seen in the city! John is my man!
Don't bother coming here if you'll be seated downstairs... Awful room and service.
Amazing place, a bit expensive but great food and atmosphere.. Mac and cheese was amazing
I truly saw nothing special in this joint. I've also been to the classic one on the East Side too, and the ones in my hometown (São Paulo). Overpriced and puzzling menu. The atmosphere is great tho.
Friday Special. Lobster Mac n cheese. Nuff said.
Try the turkey burger. It's the best in the history of turkey burgers! Perfectly moist.
The BLTE is delicious. A bacon cheeseburger topped with a fried egg! Parmesan tater tots are a must, as well!
Fantastic. Service wonderful
The House Made Veggie Burger has.become a personal favorite!
Mac and cheese is perfect!!!!!!!
Worst service in NYC and the kitchen has lost its touch.
The food is good, just had bad luck with the server. Just because we were rolling w/ a younger crowd doesn't make it ok to say that you "royally screwed up our table." I would have added the 20%, too!
Not a fan of their Chicken Pot Pie. Take a pass.