Potbelly Sandwich Shop

Potbelly Sandwich Shop

Sandwich Place and American Restaurant$$$$
Turtle Bay, New York
Save
Share
7.8/10
138
ratings
  • Don't forget it is Washington's Birthday today. You may want to call to confirm this place is open.
  • NearSay NYC
    "their notorious oatmeal chocolate chip cookies."(2 Tips)
    Evelyn L.
    "Get the A Wreck sandwich with all the toppings!"(2 Tips)
    Salina G.
    "I had a signature pizza sandwich and it wasn't that great."(3 Tips)
    Kirsten P.
    "A Wreck Salad with avocado & bacon 👍"(2 Tips)
54 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • sandwiches
  • oatmeal chocolate chip cookies
  • live music
  • milkshakes
  • good for a quick meal
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent
  • Ryan B.
    Ryan BenderOctober 16, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    In my opinion his place is one of the best lunch deals in otherwise horribly overpriced Midtown. 6 bucks for an awesome Italian sandwich that's twice as good as Subway? Yes please!
  • NearSay NYC
    NearSay NYCJuly 22, 2011
    Looking for a quick and cheap tasty sandwich? This is the place for you! We suggest the Reuben! Also, make sure to try one of their notorious oatmeal chocolate chip cookies.
  • Stan B.
    Stan BashmashnikovSeptember 1, 2011
    The "Italian" signature sandwich is fresh, high-quality meats, and very delicious. Add mayo, tomato, lettuce, and pickles -- you're good to go! Tastefully speaking, this place beats Subway.
  • Sean L.
    Sean L.August 26, 2011
    New York you are privileged to have this Chicago institution in your midst. Prices will rise b/c they are currently the same as Chicago. Don't fret have a Wreck and Mocha shake. It'll make your day!
  • John C.
    John CassilloDecember 20, 2012
    Gets pretty hectic during lunch, especially with live music. If you spend time in the SF Bay Area, this is pretty analogous to Toaster Oven.
  • Evelyn L.
    Evelyn LingAugust 7, 2014
    Been here 5+ times
    Love meat? Get the A Wreck sandwich with all the toppings!
  • Colleen P.
    Colleen PierreMay 27, 2013
    Nice sandwich shop! Great milkshakes and the bathrooms are clean and have changing tables :-)
  • Alex
    AlexDecember 16, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    Malt milk-shakes are wonderful. Pizza sandwich with the peppers are a personal favorite.
  • ZenFoodster Eats
    ZenFoodster EatsOctober 29, 2011
    Decent Straight-forward $7 salads, soups, & sandwiches under $6. If you're watching your carbs, order it "thin-cut" for 1/3 less bread.
  • Rebecca P.
    Rebecca PlaineAugust 9, 2011
    their non-free vinaigrette is actually delicious. and also is low-cal! id recommend the wreck salad.
  • Sean K.
    Sean KennedyAugust 1, 2011
    Try my favorite sandwich: roast beef with everything except onions. Also try the Free Wi-Fi!
  • The Corcoran Group
    The Corcoran GroupJuly 24, 2013
    A great place to grab a delicious sandwich or salad on the go. We love the Wreck sandwich the most!
  • ZZubin
    ZZubinOctober 21, 2015
    If you add enough of their great hot peppers you might not even notice that the chicken is not real
  • Ryan A.
    Ryan AmbsAugust 8, 2014
    Finding a good italian sub is harder to do in this city than you'd think. This'll do in a pinch.
  • Ron J.
    Ron JAugust 1, 2011
    The meatball on wheat...with lettuce, hot pepper mix, italian seasoning...the ONLY thing I order here #faithful
  • Salina G.
    Salina GMarch 8, 2013
    I had a signature pizza sandwich and it wasn't that great. Flavors were good, but they really skimped on meat and filling! There was like two tiny meatballs for the whole sandwich! Very disappointed.
  • Doug B.
    Doug BuffaloAugust 25, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    Peanut butter and banana smoothie for those who are lactose intolerant and want a delicious treat
  • Norman E.
    Norman EllisAugust 1, 2011
    The ordering process is a little hectic. I may wait a few weeks for them to smooth things out before I return. It's a nice alternative to Subway.
  • Angela
    AngelaJuly 23, 2011
    Hot peppers are superb and oatmeal chocolate chip cookies are delicious!
  • Peter B.
    Peter BarkoFebruary 24, 2014
    If you like meat order the Lucky 7(Italian+Wreck) from the secret menu
  • Chris V.
    Chris VenturaSeptember 26, 2012
    You know the PB&J is quality using Skippy & Welchs!
  • Phil B.
    Phil B.November 9, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    The Mediterranean is good. It's even better if you have them add salami.
  • Traci H.
    Traci HumphreyMarch 23, 2012
    Love, love, love the turkey! The peppers are a must.
  • ZenFoodster Eats
    ZenFoodster EatsOctober 29, 2011
    Decent Straight-forward $7 salads, soups, & sandwiches under $6.
  • Marc M.
    Marc MinardoJune 26, 2013
    Been here 10+ times
    Get a whole pickle - it's worth the extra buck.
  • Mariada T.
    Mariada TresMarch 14, 2016
    Roast beef sandwich and delicious brocoli and cheese soup
  • Steven G.
    Steven GreenhillFebruary 13, 2012
    Sandwiches are fresh, nothing too exciting though. The live music is god awful though -- probably trying to get people in and out of there; feel bad for the employees
  • Meagan C.
    Meagan CheekFebruary 18, 2012
    This pizza sandwich is the best thing that has ever been in my mouth!
  • Steve C.
    Steve CatanzaroAugust 8, 2011
    Sandwiches are on the smaller side, but very tasty. Read more
  • Christopher F.
    Christopher FerrisJuly 26, 2011
    I am probably in the minority, but the live music dude at lunch is annoying, and makes it hard to be heard when taking your order.
  • Kirsten P.
    Kirsten PowerMay 13, 2016
    A Wreck Salad with avocado & bacon 👍
  • Clarence L.
    Clarence LDecember 5, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    Try the wrecking ball! The wreck + meatballs!
  • Nicolette R.
    Nicolette RomeroDecember 5, 2015
    Obsessed with their Oreo cookie shake.
  • Christopher F.
    Christopher FerrisJuly 26, 2011
    Very reasonably priced considering other area options.
  • Chris V.
    Chris VenturaSeptember 3, 2012
    Mmmmm. Good stuff.
  • Chelsea R.
    Chelsea ResnickJanuary 4, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    My sandwich came complete with someone's hair!
  • Bex
    BexJuly 25, 2011
    "a wreck" with extra hot peppers is what's up!
  • Ryan A.
    Ryan AmbsAugust 12, 2015
    Live concerts at lunch time
  • Roxanne C.
    Roxanne ChiuJuly 23, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    Roast beef sandwiches are the best!
  • Amy
    AmyNovember 8, 2011
    Get there by 12 avoid the line
  • Dave F.
    Dave FJuly 26, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    Italian with meatball!
  • Steven G.
    Steven GreenhillOctober 25, 2011
    Anything w the hot peppers!
  • Mac
    MacDecember 15, 2011
    Try the Sandwiches!
  • Ruben E.
    Ruben EtienneApril 6, 2012
    Turkey Breast on whole wheat!
  • Meghan Kathleen
    Meghan KathleenAugust 2, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    Chocolate-oreo shake. So good!
  • Aravind R.
    Aravind RJuly 21, 2011
    Try the hot peppers
  • Aimee D.
    Aimee DuellJuly 26, 2011
    briliant addition to the neighborhood Read more
  • Trey
    TreyOctober 25, 2011
    Get it "skinny" for less bread.
  • slam
    slamSeptember 10, 2011
    A taste of Chicago...
  • Mary
    MaryAugust 29, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    Rude service, delicious sandwiches!
53 Photos

Related Searches

  • potbelly sandwich shop new york
  • potbelly sandwich shop new york photos
  • potbelly sandwich shop new york location
  • potbelly sandwich shop new york address
  • potbelly sandwich shop new york
  • potbelly new york
  • potbelly 44th& lex new york
  • potbelly 44thand lex new york
  • potbelly sandwich shop new york
  • potbelly sandwich works new york
  • potbelly sandwich shop turtle bay new york

Foursquare © 2017  Lovingly made in NYC & SF