Potbelly Sandwich Shop

Potbelly Sandwich Shop

Sandwich Place
22 E 17th St, New York, NY 10003, United States
Hours:
Open until 9:00 PM (Show more)
  • Mon–Fri
    • 11:00 AM–9:00 PM
  • Sat–Sun
    • 11:00 AM–8:00 PM
Price:
$ $ $ $
Menus:
Brunch, Lunch
Credit Cards:
Yes (incl. American Express & MasterCard)
Outdoor Seating:
No

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - Good vibes, great sandwiches at your neighborhood sandwich shop.

7.7/10

Based on 151 votes

People like this place

Total Visitors
3,126
Total Visits
7,856
Save
Share
  • What you need to know
    Mary A.
    "And the Oreo shake is also delicious"(4 Tips)
    Cesar S.
    "Good atmosphere, dude playing guitar, go with the pizza sandwich!"(3 Tips)
    Justin L.
    "Mediterranean sandwich with hot peppers"(2 Tips)
    Christopher T.
    "Pick up a sugar cookie with it to get the savory/sweet combo down :)"(8 Tips)
Log in to leave tips at this venue!
Sort:
  • Recent
  • Popular

59 tips. Filter by taste:

  • all tips
  • sandwiches
  • wreck
  • dream bar
  • milkshakes
  • cookies
  • good for a quick meal
  • oatmeal
  • great value
  • live music
  • Arnold Palmers
  • smoothies
  • roast beef
  • vegetarian food
  • turkey
  • grilled chicken
  • salads
  • hot peppers
  • lunch
  • bacon
  • multigrain bread
  • Potbelly Sandwich Shop

    New Turkey, Bacon & Cheddar FLATS are here, NYC! Hand-sliced turkey, melted cheddar and thick-cut award-winning Nueske’s applewood bacon…all on delicious multigrain FLATS! Get one today.

    Potbelly Sandwich Shop · 2 weeks ago
    Save
  • Maksim A.

    ~10$ lunch. Dine in possible. Worth it.

    Maksim Alipov · February 24
    Save
  • Joey J.

    Sandwiches are just okay. This was a daily lunch spot for me in college at Ohio State. I still prefer to go to your typical NYC deli for my sandwiches over PotBelly.

    Joey J · February 15
    Save
  • Sarah

    Solid solo Union Square lunch choice. They could use a better ventilation system in here, though. Smoky!

    Sarah · January 15
    Save
  • Pookie P.

    Can't go wrong with italian & Oreo shake try their potato salad it's surprisingly yum

    Pookie Puffs · November 5, 2014
    Save
  • Michael D.

    If you do not get hot peppers, you are a fool.

    Michael Danahy · October 1, 2014
    Save
  • Daniel M.

    The line may look long but it moves super fast. Wait it out.

    Daniel McDonough · June 24, 2014
    Save
  • Deivinson T.

    Grilled chicken is awesome!

    Deivinson Tejeda · June 10, 2014
    Save
  • Kai B.

    "Thin-cut, double-meat, original turkey breast on multigrain" ...And now my Potbelly order has become longer than my Starbucks order.

    Kai Brinker · May 9, 2014
    Save
  • Nick S.

    Definitely get the hot peppers

    Nick Smith · February 10, 2014
    Save
  • David S.

    Smells like burnt plastic in here. I'm gonna hurl.

    David Schorr · December 21, 2013
    Save
  • Nina L.

    A 'classier' version of Quiznos.

    Nina LoSchiavo · September 7, 2013
    Save
  • Eddie J.

    Great people who remember their regulars. The grilled chicken cheddar is great but you can always change up the classic wreck.

    Eddie Jennings · August 22, 2013
    Save
  • Annette L.

    Mayo is a must... They need more sauces for the sandwiches.

    Annette Lilly · August 9, 2013
    Save
  • Elliot G.

    Didn't like their Oreo shake. Very basic and the cookies-component is too finely minced. I prefer chunks of oreos in my shake!

    Elliot G · August 4, 2013
    Save
  • Alex S.

    If you're going to get something sweet, make it the Chocolate Brownie Cookie. Yes, that's a thing.

    Alex Stein · July 30, 2013
    Save
  • Thomas R.

    Great combo

    Thomas Reintjes · July 8, 2013
    Save
  • Josh C.

    The turkey breast is super filling for being so low in calories!

    Josh Clapper · July 1, 2013
    Save
  • David S.

    Why does this place smell like burning plastic every time I go inside?

    David Schorr · March 13, 2013
    Save
  • Walter B.

    They sometimes give away free cookies right before they close.

    Walter Blaurock · January 20, 2013
    Save
  • Harry P.

    Nowhere near as crowded as its Chicago siblings, despite being in Union Square.

    Harry Pujols · December 21, 2012
    Save
  • Kim W.

    Omg. The mediterrean sandwich is so good. Hummus and feta with veggies. Delish!

    Kim Williams · October 5, 2012
    Save
  • david ' dj shakez ' t.

    Make sure you grab an Oatmeal Chocolate Chip cookie, they put crack in it, possibly Molly too!

    david ' dj shakez ' thai · October 3, 2012
    Save
  • Evan K.

    Simple. Turkey & Swiss on Whole Wheat = Delish!

    Evan Kraut · September 27, 2012
    Save
  • Chris C.

    As good as chain fast casual gets. Only Chipotle can compare when it comes to ingredient quality and consistency. Italian with everything, bag of Zapps and a fountain made Arnold Palmer is the winner

    Chris C · September 10, 2012
    Save
  • Christina K.

    The mediterranean sandwich is phenomenal!! Now I just have to try to recreate it at home! Highly recommended!!!!

    Christina Koharski · August 19, 2012
    Save
  • Sami

    As a Chicagoan I'm so happy this is finally in NYC! Smoothies are heavenly and my friends are obsessed with their dream bars.

    Sami · July 23, 2012
    Save
  • Ginna O.

    Love the coffee milkshake!

    Ginna Ozuna · July 19, 2012
    Save
  • Ryan T.

    Word to their Pizza Sandwich!

    Ryan T · June 19, 2012
    Save
  • Justin L.

    Get the Mediterranean sandwich with hot peppers and experience a glimpse of Heaven long before judgment day.

    Justin Luke · June 18, 2012
    Save
  • Victoria W.

    im leaving another comment since this is seriously the best food place ever. so much love! came in after their closing time and they were still so friendly and helpful <3

    Victoria Wong · June 17, 2012
    Save
  • Lauren S.

    Roast beef on multigrain! Sooo good.

    Lauren Shia · June 9, 2012
    Save
  • Arif K.

    Sandwiches are good, but I wasn't too impressed with the side salads.

    Arif Kostak · May 19, 2012
    Save
  • Christopher T.

    Everything's good here, but my staple is a wreck on white, everything no mayo no mustard. Pick up a sugar cookie with it to get the savory/sweet combo down :)

    Christopher Tai · April 17, 2012
    Save
  • Victoria W.

    Best sandwich shop in town! Or ever! Never forget the hot peppas! Yum

    Victoria Wong · April 10, 2012
    Save
  • Kristen M.

    Oreo milkshake.. So good! And yes, the hot peppers are a must. Makes me miss Dallas, TX

    Kristen Mongrain · April 2, 2012
    Save
  • Eric S.

    Haven't lived in New Orleans > 15 years still buy #NOLA products when I see them Zapps Chips for sale here

    Eric Strauss · March 18, 2012
    Save
  • Jigar B.

    Superslow staff...takes forever

    Jigar Bhadra · March 9, 2012
    Save
  • Christina B.

    Decrease your caloric intake and get thin cut bread. 1/3 of the bread left off

    Christina Buquid · February 28, 2012
    Save
  • Michael H.

    Roast beef sandwich. Hands down. Also the pickles and milkshakes are the jimmy jam.

    Michael Harrington · February 28, 2012
    Save
  • Micah F.

    Free cookie if you check in with Yelp. (Late Feb 2012.)

    Micah Freedman · February 27, 2012
    Save
  • Chris W.

    Get the wrecking ball... Shh!

    Chris Walsh · February 23, 2012
    Save
  • Arshan S.

    The absolute best chain sandwich place around. Fresh cold cuts and amazing milk shakes are their forte. If u like meat try the Wreck or Pizza. Always toasted always delish. (4 of 4 petals via Fondu) Read more

    Arshan Sadri · January 17, 2012
    Save
  • Mike T.

    Chicken Salad with hot peppers is a score!

    Mike Taylor · January 17, 2012
    Save
  • Teresa W.

    yummy cookies

    Teresa W · January 9, 2012
    Save
  • ben m.

    Helps this Chicagoan when homesick... now we just need Portillo's & Lou Malnati's to move east.

    ben m · January 5, 2012
    Save
  • Sandra N.

    Best sandwich in the city. Waited 6 years for it to come to NY. Get mini oatmeal cookies to finish the meal. You won't regret it.

    Sandra Nam · December 23, 2011
    Save
  • Shaina M.

    A Brooklyn sandwich chain that does toasted sandwiches rather nicely. There isn't much seating, but the staff is friendly and there's live music at lunchtime.

    Shaina M · December 20, 2011
    Save
  • Roberto T.

    Pizza sandwich is delicious!

    Roberto Thais · December 14, 2011
    Save
  • Kiril S.

    Live music during lunch, and it's really pretty good.

    Kiril Savino · December 1, 2011
    Save

Appears on 67 lists

See all »

More from Potbelly Sandwich Shop

Is this your business? Claim it now.

Make sure your information is up to date. Plus use our free tools to find new customers.