Potbelly Sandwich Shop

Potbelly Sandwich Shop

Sandwich Place and American Restaurant$$$$
Garment District, New York
Save
Share
8.2/10
351
ratings
  • J T.
    "Pizza sandwich is great"(6 Tips)
    Adrian J.
    "Make sure to add hot peppers and Italian seasoning."(3 Tips)
    Mehnay H.
    "You can never go wrong with the Italian and an oreo shake!"(2 Tips)
    Rita L.
    "Italian on regular bread with everything and extra peppers!"(2 Tips)
85 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • sandwiches
  • milkshakes
  • live music
  • cookies
  • good for a quick meal
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent
  • John A.
    John AntosNovember 3, 2016
    Large with seating on two levels. Potbelly is famous for toasted sub sandwiches, get the hot peppers, mix of hot / sweet peppers in a vinegar base. Not on the menu: ask for the vegetarian sub.
  • Mandar M.
    Mandar MMarch 11, 2014
    Malts! They have malts! Tons of places sell shakes very few still sell malts. When the cashier says shake you shake head from side to side emphatically NO and say: No Gimme a MALT! :)
  • Denis S.
    Denis SosnovtsevOctober 11, 2013
    Roast beef, whole wheat, thin cut, mayo, lettuce, onion, oil and Italian seasoning, plus an IBC cream soda. Been ordering this for a decade. Can't go wrong.
  • Marcia H.
    Marcia HeardFebruary 10, 2016
    the chicken salad, salad is soo good but you have to get the potbelly house dressing along with the fat free vinaigrette with a side of hot peppers. mmm good
  • Sagar H.
    Sagar HatekarSeptember 12, 2012
    Try the Mediterranean Sandwich with Lettuce and Tomatoes. Tastes great with their awesome Mixed Berry shake.
  • Liliana
    LilianaNovember 16, 2012
    Had the Wreck and it was one of the best sandwiches I have ever had, very tasty and hearty.
  • Raj S.
    Raj S.December 20, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    Lots of dining-in space here. Great sandwiches at a decent price, as anyone from Chicago will tell you.
  • Aaron R.
    Aaron RameyJuly 16, 2013
    If you want a salad, go across the street to Cosi. Love the sandwiches, though. And the cookies.
  • Helly K.
    Helly KMay 17, 2013
    Sandwiches on the small side, but taste fresh. When you come, be ready to order right away during peak hours
  • Thracian
    ThracianFebruary 11, 2012
    Sandwich taste & size exceed the price, therefore a great value! The bread they use is heavenly.
  • Will K.
    Will KennedyDecember 21, 2011
    Very spacious. Must try the Pizza Sandwich. Pretty reasonable on the prices for a Midtown sandwich shop
  • Cassel K.
    Cassel KrollJanuary 20, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    Tired of the Signature sandwiches? Ask about the "Underground" options. I recommend the Clubby.
  • Adrian J.
    Adrian JankDecember 30, 2011
    Can't go wrong with the wreck. Make sure to add hot peppers and Italian seasoning.
  • Edlin C.
    Edlin ChoiMarch 16, 2012
    Pizza sandwich was solid, but it was kind of small. I've heard rave reviews about this place though, maybe I'm not ordering the right thing. Must go back with a veteran. (2 of 4 petals via Fondu) Read more
  • Jake S.
    Jake SmithFebruary 24, 2012
    The pickles they use are delicious. Try a Boylan's soda with your sandwich.
  • Thracian
    ThracianFebruary 11, 2012
    Make sure you add hot peppers & Italian seasoning. The pickles are good too.
  • Grisel F.
    Grisel FamaniaMay 1, 2015
    The girl standing at the line taking orders is a rude. I didn't understand something she mumbled and talked to me as if I were 5 and being scolded. Everyone else was customer service oriented (nice).
  • Phillip W.
    Phillip WilsonApril 9, 2013
    Been here 25+ times
    Awesome place for a sandwich as well as great customer service
  • Theresa R.
    Theresa RoldanMay 22, 2016
    Cookies, smoothies, and sandwiches are awesome! There's no wrong choice on the menu
  • Ian James R.
    Ian James RobertsJanuary 3, 2012
    Order ahead and pick up, otherwise the check out process here is a bit hectic!
  • Adam S.
    Adam SchuitJune 10, 2015
    Been here 10+ times
    Turkey and Swiss yum. Ask for more mustard cause they skimp out
  • Mike M.
    Mike M.October 14, 2014
    It's all about the Big Wreck! Soo tasty.
  • Peter E.
    Peter EscardóDecember 30, 2014
    Excellent the Roast Beef favorite. Prices are ok
  • Rita L.
    Rita LNovember 20, 2016
    Italian on regular bread with everything and extra peppers!
  • Mehnay H.
    Mehnay HowardApril 18, 2013
    You can never go wrong with the Italian and an oreo shake!
  • Harry R.
    Harry RaymondMarch 20, 2014
    Been here 10+ times
    In and out in 5 minutes every time. Chipotle next door could learn something from this place.
  • Sari
    SariFebruary 22, 2014
    Look up the secret menu... It's the way to go.
  • Linnie D.
    Linnie DJune 29, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    Guitarist/singer is clutch. Nice ambience hearing tangerine by led zeppelin on a Friday afternoon.
  • Mike T.
    Mike TDecember 14, 2011
    Been here 25+ times
    Sandwiches are on the small side. Definitely reflective of the pricing.
  • Kenny L.
    Kenny LoweOctober 19, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    Ask for them to put the Potbelly Vinegarette on your sandwich!
  • christy t.
    christy tharpeAugust 18, 2013
    Pretty much the best sandwich I've ever had with hot peppers. 🔥
  • virtualjared
    virtualjaredMarch 1, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    FIRST TASTE (chili) little too soupy. Take a spoon not a fork. I'd go easy on the ask for onions they tossed in too many. Overall overpriced
  • jamie m.
    jamie mccullaghOctober 26, 2015
    Been here 5+ times
    Surprisingly good soup, great cookies.
  • Kamal J.
    Kamal JonesDecember 20, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    One of the Best bang for buck sandwiches spots!
  • nils j.
    nils jansonDecember 6, 2014
    Italian with absolutely everything and extra peppers.
  • Olivia C.
    Olivia ChengSeptember 4, 2012
    Pickles and hot peppers are a must try!
  • Carla S.
    Carla SchoemanSeptember 5, 2014
    Farmhouse salads are great value for money!
  • Frank
    FrankJanuary 25, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    Long lines at lunch time but they ALWAYS move fast!
  • a. h.
    a. hirataDecember 28, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    pizza sandwich or the wreck with hot peppers, can't lose!
  • Olakunle O.
    Best sandwich I have had in New York
  • Willem O.
    Willem OckhuysenAugust 20, 2014
    Decent price for how much you get. A lot better than subway.
  • Alison T.
    Alison TugwellAugust 31, 2012
    Wouldn't you know, their milkshakes are good. And they have a little circular cookie that fits over your straw. Cuuute.
  • Emmanuel G.
    Emmanuel GalvanSeptember 30, 2015
    The new buffalo chicken sandwich is actually pretty good
  • Amanda J.
    Amanda JabesAugust 28, 2014
    Standard turkey sandwich in a skinny whole wheat and your life is complete
  • Alex B.
    Alex BentonMay 30, 2013
    Make sure you get the hot peppers.
  • Nastassia J.
    Nastassia JimenezFebruary 11, 2012
    The milkshakes here are awesome! :)
  • Reina A.
    Reina AyalaDecember 3, 2014
    Live music what very cool spot.
  • Janet D.
    Janet Del ValleJuly 11, 2013
    Don't come too hungry. Otherwise, for the money u get twice the sandwich at Subways ... just saying.
  • Casie
    CasieMay 15, 2012
    Bad meeting? Get the macaroni salad. Good meeting? Get the macaroni salad.
  • LuisJose P.
    LuisJose PolancoFebruary 17, 2014
    A wreck + chicken noodle soup, delicious
  • Erik H.
    Erik HaydenAugust 18, 2013
    Usually love Potbellys. STAY AWAY from this location.
  • Samuel H.
    Samuel HowardAugust 6, 2014
    Been here 10+ times
    WiFi. GET THE MASSIVE PICKLE.
  • Paul A.
    Paul AmbasDecember 19, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    Long lines. Come early. Try the malts.
  • 🇩🇪 Michael 🇺🇸 🚔
    Great sandwich. Just what I needed
  • Mikey D.
    Mikey DunnApril 12, 2015
    Been here 10+ times
    Get the Oreo Shake. DO IT.
  • Guillermo W.
    Guillermo WeibchenMarch 6, 2013
    Best wifi conection around Penn Station
  • puzzlr.me
    puzzlr.meJune 21, 2014
    Can you solve it in 30 seconds? Download PUZZLR from the apple store www.puzzlr.me 👹
  • Livio M.
    Livio MininoMay 10, 2014
    Great place for a quick lunch
  • J T.
    J TFebruary 17, 2012
    Pizza sandwich w mayo and hot peppers
  • Marc P.
    Marc PatlanNovember 10, 2012
    The cute Puerto Rican guy making sandwiches said to me "Whudda you want papi?" And I blushed. Idiot.
  • Kirk P.
    Kirk PestlinDecember 4, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Turkey for me, turkey for you!
  • Cassel K.
    Cassel KrollDecember 13, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    A Wreck is always a good bet.
  • Rafael Z.
    Rafael ZaccaOctober 6, 2013
    Italian Sandwich... The best in the morning!!!!
  • Rindaanne R.
    Rindaanne RiccioFebruary 2, 2012
    Roast beef sandwich is delicious!!
  • Brittany
    BrittanyNovember 27, 2014
    Workers aren't always the nicest.
  • Kyta
    KytaMay 10, 2013
    Tuna is amazing
  • Matty C.
    Matty CitoMarch 11, 2015
    I don't know. Nothings really amaze a crave-alicious herr
  • Ralph Z.
    Ralph ZApril 8, 2015
    Flatbread sandwich ....oh boy
  • J T.
    J TJanuary 31, 2012
    Pizza sandwich is great
  • Marc W.
    Marc WJanuary 17, 2012
    Good price but not enough sandwich!!
  • Bobby L.
    Bobby LinDecember 19, 2011
    Comparable to Quiznos sandwiches in size and price but much tastier.
  • Kenny C.
    Kenny ChungJanuary 12, 2012
    $5.80 plus tax comes out to $6.31!
  • Randy S.
    Randy SidberryOctober 16, 2014
    Been here 5+ times
    Pizza sandwich
  • Ben G.
    Ben GaliotoMarch 12, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    Definitely get a pickle!
  • Aaron S.
    Aaron ShapiroFebruary 24, 2012
    Get the roast beef
  • Steve C.
    Steve CipparuloDecember 27, 2011
    Wreck with hot peppers ftw
  • Kamel M.
    Kamel McDonaldJanuary 17, 2013
    Old dude is SUPER helpful
  • Suzana U.
    Suzana UenoJune 6, 2012
    Live music =)
  • Sarah Joy
    Sarah JoySeptember 12, 2012
    5 dollar Sammy!
  • Chris Y.
    Chris YimJune 14, 2013
    No bigs here. Don't ask for one!
  • Bella F.
    Bella FonteNovember 28, 2015
    Messy like
  • Will G.
    Will GibbyJanuary 19, 2012
    BULLSEYE!!!!
  • Mark F.
    Mark FranklinFebruary 10, 2012
    Been here 25+ times
    Overpriced nothing special. Also liars told me no line on phone when i got there a huge line
  • Can
    CanSeptember 23, 2015
    Unlu bir zincir rest. Sabah kahvaltisi icin farkli menusu var ve guzel. Subway den ne fazlasi var derseniz,bilemem eh iste.
  • Egor Z.
    Egor ZedMay 4, 2016
    По умолчанию сендвичи идут без начинки, так что без стеснения наполняйте их компонентами (перечень на стене за прилавком).
197 Photos

Related Searches

  • potbelly sandwich shop new york
  • potbelly sandwich shop new york photos
  • potbelly sandwich shop new york location
  • potbelly sandwich shop new york address
  • potbelly sandwich shop new york
  • pot belly new york
  • potbelly new york
  • potbelly sandwich shop new york
  • potbelly sandwich shop garment district new york

Foursquare © 2017  Lovingly made in NYC & SF