The Sardine Sandwich
Captain's Daughter (sardines, pickled eggs, capers on foccacia) is delicious, beautiful, and unlike any other sandwich I've ever eaten.
Best sandwich in NYC. Scuttlebutt. It will end you.
Thursday-Saturday 6:30-10:30 it becomes Mr Curry and man is it excellent. Veggie curry is satisfying with a little kick & the meatballs are nice and spicy.
The scuttlebutt is my everything
Homemade sea salt focaccia is perfectly chewy/crispy. Try and hunt down the BLT in Summer, Balmy or Captain's Daughter all other times.
Best sandwich in town. But make sure you have an appetite. Personal favorite: the Scuttlebutt
Order any sandwich. Shove it in your cakehole. Rejoice.
The most satisfying, unique sandwiches on fluffy foccacia bread. Can't go wrong with Captain's Daughter, Scuttlebutt or the Balmy. Try them all.
The sandwiches are fantastic, especially the veggie options.
Scuttlebutt and Turmeric drink!
The Scuttlebutt is one of the most unique (and delicious) sandwiches I've ever had
The Spanish Armada is pretty damn close to the real thing. Soft, smooth and filling.
Awesome pastries and sandwiches
The Scuttlebutt was delicious but almost broke me. You'll need extra napkins.
Scuttlebutt is default perfect sandwich. Turmeric tonic and pastries are refreshing. $ 4 $ best food in Williamsburg if you like well seasoned, considered sandwiches.
Scuttlebutt every single time
If you are feeling super hungry, get the Scuttlebutt!
There’s the pickle-palooza Scuttlebutt, the Clean Slate, an open-faced Middle Eastern kitchen sink, all housebaked focaccia and chewy naan; bright, piquant dressings; and flurries of fresh herbs.
The balmy is like the quaint New England-seaside-town version of a bahn mi. I could eat this everyday and not get tired of it
who knew ricotta cheese & scrambled eggs made for such a great sandwich?
Come here for the most awesome sandwiches with the most uncomfortable seats.
They upped their prices... And I'm saltie about it. 😡 Those $2 are the difference between twice a month, and twice a year.
Cute sandwich shop that always makes a good, interesting lunch.
Tumeric tonic is refreshingly tasty. And any sandwich is delicious, healthy and filling.
The scuttlebutt is surely one of the best sandwiches i've ever eaten
Get here before or after the lunch rush. People tend to forget it's a small place and there's limited seating, so they continue to occupy space when they've finished eating.
A tiny restaurant but the sandwiches there are definetely a must-try. Very yummy and all the ingredients are fresh/organic. ~10$ for a sandwich
Scuttlebutt for life
Come here for breakfast and get the Ship's Biscuit - it'll change the way you think about cheese in your breakfast sandwich!
Fact. Salty. Delicious and filling.
Clean slate is amazing!
I can't get enough of the Captain's Daughter. The focaccia that they use in their sandwiches is addictive.
The Clean Slate - Warm housemade naan is warmed and smothered with hummus, quinoa, and matchstick-cut pickled beets. To finish, yogurt, a handful of shaved fennel, parsley and toasted sesame seeds.
Scuttlebutt is amazing, but apparently it takes 4 hours to craft a sandwich here. Not good in a rush.
I shoulda know when I saw an excess of pale white women in here that Saltie is vegan..damn..
The Scuttlebutt is delicious & messy.
This place is amazing.
Try the Vanilla Maple Bean Lassi
Try the Ribolita - #vegetarian
The "Scuttlebutt" sandwhich is good but if they have the Kedgeree bowl special (salt cod, saffron rice, hb egg, yogurt sauce, chutney) going on DO IT! Yum!