• Photo taken at Stars Cafe by Sarah E. on 4/17/2013
  • Photo taken at Stars Cafe by Fay R. on 4/9/2013
  • Photo taken at Stars Cafe by Rob B. on 7/1/2012
  • Photo taken at Stars Cafe by Stephanie B. on 6/28/2013
  • Photo taken at Stars Cafe by Ellen J. on 10/5/2013
  • Photo taken at Stars Cafe by Maria S. on 4/25/2015
  • Photo taken at Stars Cafe by Josh C. on 10/2/2012
  • Photo taken at Stars Cafe by Ellen J. on 8/25/2013
  • Photo taken at Stars Cafe by Sam G. on 1/1/2013
  • Photo taken at Stars Cafe by Fay R. on 3/27/2013
  • Photo taken at Stars Cafe by Jason U. on 9/8/2012
  • Photo taken at Stars Cafe by Fay R. on 5/11/2013

Stars Cafe

Café and Breakfast Spot
Shelter Island Heights
Save
Share
7.7/10
32
ratings
  • Christina H.
    "Love the cranberry walnut muffin!"(2 Tips)
    miriam w.
    "I live for the hazelnut iced coffee and corn muffins!!!"(4 Tips)
    Cara C.
    "Large iced hazelnut with splends"(2 Tips)
    Megan R.
    "They have soy milk!"(2 Tips)
14 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • pastries
  • muffins
  • bagels
  • green tea ice cream
  • gardens
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Recent
  • Popular
  • Rei
    ReiJune 16
    Lots of treats and iced coffee, wish they stayed open a little later though
  • Andrea C.
    Andrea CarnesDecember 23, 2015
    There are vegan options here!
  • Nicky K.
    Nicky K.August 24, 2014
    Great coffee shop in shelter island. Feels like the type of place you'd find in the city. Love the garden burrito.
  • Jake R.
    Jake RubinMay 25, 2014
    Enjoy your croissants, bagels, and coffee out back by the water and beautiful boats.
  • miriam w.
    miriam williamsJune 9, 2013
    I live for the hazelnut iced coffee and corn muffins!!! You should too.
    Downvoted 3 hours ago
  • Liza
    LizaOctober 8, 2012
    It turns out that God doesn't mind if you don't tip. True story.
  • Megan R.
    Megan RascalAugust 8, 2012
    They have soy milk!
  • Sarah L.
    Sarah LimJune 9, 2012
    Delicious scones!!
  • Jacqie R.
    Jacqie RutzlerJune 1, 2012
    Great spot to sit on a rainy day or relax on a sunny afternoon.
  • Marisa M.
    Marisa MossAugust 18, 2011
    Get the stars morning wrap with egg whites!
  • Christina H.
    Christina HenslerApril 10, 2011
    Love the cranberry walnut muffin!
  • Nicole K.
    Nicole KeaneAugust 28, 2010
    Make sure to try the Green Tea ice cream downstairs!
  • Kevin F.
    Kevin FitzpatrickJune 12, 2010
    Go for a cranberry walnut muffin. You will love it
  • Cara C.
    Cara CMay 25, 2010
    Large iced hazelnut with splends, skim milk and a touch of half n half!! Nothing better!
12 Photos

Related Searches

  • stars cafe shelter island heights
  • stars cafe shelter island heights photos
  • stars cafe shelter island heights location
  • stars cafe shelter island heights address
  • stars cafe shelter island heights
  • stars shelter island heights
  • stars cafe shelter island heights

Foursquare © 2016  Lovingly made in NYC & SF