Sunset Beach

Lounge and Restaurant$$$$
Shelter Island
Save
Share
8.2/10
193
ratings
  • Laurie P.
    "The lobster summer rolls are light, fresh and delicious.. :)"(2 Tips)
    Léna Le Rolland
    "Take the seaplane to come over here from NYC !"(2 Tips)
    sam p.
    "Go early for a cocktail & enjoy the incredible sunset on the beach."(9 Tips)
    Josy H.
    "Sunset beach rosé is lovely"(4 Tips)
43 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • sunsets
  • seafood
  • lobster summer rolls
  • roses
  • lively
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent
  • sam p.
    sam pezzulloNovember 15, 2013
    My favorite spot on Long Island. Cannot beat the atmosphere, or the food. Go early for a cocktail & enjoy the incredible sunset on the beach. Must try the mussels, grilled octopus, and veal Milanese.
  • Josy H.
    Josy HamrenJuly 15, 2015
    Get a table on the top balcony - it's cooler, quieter, and the view is amazing. Head downstairs and on Sunday afternoons the vibe will make you feel like you're in Europe. Sunset beach rosé is lovely
  • The Corcoran Group
    The Corcoran GroupMarch 14, 2011
    Waterfront French bistro and bar. Mojitos at sunset! Great people watching and a NY Strip Steak au poire to die for! Plus 20 rooms, each with private sundeck. All the sundrenched sports you, the child
  • Léna Le Rolland
    Léna Le RollandOctober 5, 2013
    Take the seaplane to come over here from NYC ! All the food is really great, the service is great too. Rooms are cute ! There is nothing else to do on the island for the record... The beach is nice
  • robert n.
    robert nicholsonAugust 28, 2015
    Expensive, poor service - really not the same as blue marlin / St tropez! If you want to eat a decent meal pop down the road to the Pridwin, a more relaxed crowd but better seafood! Bar is good.
  • Rianne V.
    Rianne Van RompaeyJune 14, 2015
    We got a big plate of raw vegetables. It made no sense. And it cost 26 dollars. Also not a big fan of the pretentiois half french/half american menu. Very premium prices for not so premium food.
  • Vishal G.
    Vishal GuptaSeptember 2, 2014
    It's pretentious, overpriced, and sceney. But isn't that why you head out east? It made for a nice getaway, grab an expensive snack and enjoy the beach/view.
  • Willem V.
    Willem Van LanckerSeptember 6, 2015
    Sunset Beach is owned by the Standard but definitely takes the worst aspects of their other hotels more than anything else... overpriced cocktails, unbearable clientele, crummy beachfront.
  • James U.
    James UnderbergSeptember 6, 2015
    Love breakfast here ! The "UnHampton" our favorite spot for breakfast ! Parking easy in the morning - leisurely - relax and enjoy !!
  • sam p.
    sam pezzulloJuly 14, 2013
    The best nightlife spot in the Hamptons if you don't mind a ferry ride and a short drive. Great atmosphere, and a classy crowd all around.
  • Aditya B.
    Aditya BasuAugust 28, 2014
    Don't come here after it gets dark. The hefty prices are only worth it combined with the water views, daytime of course. Good food overall.
  • Corinne P.
    Corinne PulitzerJuly 17, 2013
    Great Bar/Lounge and excellent restaurant. Reservations for Lunch& Dinner a must. Try to sit on the upper deck to enjoy the view!
  • Lindsay C.
    Lindsay CJuly 19, 2015
    Watch the sunset while drinking their signature Gimme Shelter cocktail and dining on fresh seafood. Later in the evening it becomes a party.
  • Alexandra T.
    Alexandra T.July 29, 2014
    Skip the watermelon salad. Yes to the cold-pressed watermelon cocktail.
  • Matthew M.
    Matthew McMillanJuly 29, 2013
    A very boring weekend. By that I mean there is this giant machine boring a tunnel to the other side of the bay where the sun sets. Very interesting to watch.
  • The Standard
    The StandardJuly 26, 2011
    NY(Fly!): Welcome to our sister property! Remember The Standard hotel's seaplane, StndAIR takes off right here! We hope to see you get on board soon!
  • Nicky K.
    Nicky K.August 30, 2014
    It can get so euro trashy and gross here but there really is no competition for nightlife in shelter island at all.
  • Erica B.
    Erica BergerJune 23, 2013
    The rose sangria is delicious--not too sweet, and brimming with peaches.
  • ellen r.
    ellen resnickAugust 30, 2010
    Sit in the cafe the view is great and less crowded than a roof top area
  • Laurie P.
    Laurie PilaJune 26, 2011
    The lobster summer rolls are light, fresh and delicious.. :)
  • Explore L.
    Explore Long IslandFebruary 19, 2013
    We featured Sunset Beach in our guide for "Top 10 hotels for a staycation" on Long Island! Read more
  • Annet S.
    Annet Sagal3 weeks ago
    The best place on Shelter Island 😍 The food is amazing here🍤
  • Hugo R.
    Hugo RamosJuly 23, 2011
    dont park on the streer with out a permit or you'll get a fine
  • Lisa H.
    Lisa HuaJuly 23, 2013
    Baileys coup...expresso beans, baileys and cappuccino ice cream....just get it
  • Joel
    JoelAugust 11, 2012
    Great sunset forget about the attitude we are all cool!
  • Big T T.
    Big T TJune 18, 2012
    Beautiful women and scenery. You'll need a neck brace after enjoying a day/night here.
  • Michael B.
    Michael BassikJuly 5, 2011
    Great beach, atmosphere, staff and food! Read more
  • Bill O.
    Bill O'LearyFebruary 13, 2015
    Beautiful setting with beautiful people.
  • Ben C.
    Ben CarbonneauJuly 7, 2013
    Lobster summer rolls are good
  • Daniel K.
    Daniel KornAugust 6, 2011
    Get a mojito and watch the mega yachts anchor.
  • Molly W.
    Molly WinstonAugust 24, 2013
    28$ a glass for sparkling rose. They didn't mention a thing. Fuck. That.
  • Michael B.
    Michael BSeptember 7, 2009
    watch out for the trash. it's all over....
  • Tom M.
    Tom MaximSeptember 9, 2014
    Good view. Average food.
  • Adam J.
    Adam JustinMay 26, 2014
    Terrible service, really disappointed.
  • Elysia M.
    Elysia Mann2 days ago
    Bougie as hell but gorgeous
  • Jon D.
    Jon DiJuly 29, 2012
    Wicked place!
  • Kevin C.
    Kevin CavanaughAugust 31, 2014
    DJSACKMANN.COM BOUGHT ME 4 BOTTLES OF ROSÉ!!!
  • Jon D.
    Jon DiJuly 29, 2012
    Cool spot!
  • Aaron K.
    Aaron KaufmanAugust 17, 2014
    Scene and be seen
  • Olivier S.
    Olivier S.June 8, 2014
    Cars here are crazy
  • Christina T.
    Christina TMarch 18
    Summer Sunday's.
  • Rex S.
    Rex SorgatzJune 16, 2013
    Keep your wife away from the boys.
  • Ben B.
    Ben BradyJuly 7, 2013
    This place is douche central
575 Photos

Related Searches

  • sunset beach shelter island
  • sunset beach shelter island photos
  • sunset beach shelter island location
  • sunset beach shelter island address
  • sunset beach shelter island
  • sunset beach shelter island
  • sunset beach restaurant shelter island

Foursquare © 2016  Lovingly made in NYC & SF