The Bagel Store Brooklyn's Best Bagels And Cragels

The Bagel Store

Bagel Shop, Café, and Bakery$$$$
Williamsburg, Brooklyn
Save
Share
7.9/10
420
ratings
  • Addison H.
    "My personal favorite is the cragel - so delicious."(6 Tips)
    Nick V.
    "Try a bacon, egg, and cheese on a french toast bagel... Trust me."(10 Tips)
    Roadify App
    "Bacon, egg & cheddar on an everything bagel, toasted."(5 Tips)
    Lana W.
    "Cannoli cream cheese and lox cream cheese on the everything"(3 Tips)
115 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • bagels
  • cragel
  • breakfast food
  • lively
  • authentic
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent
  • Chris G.
    Chris Gonzales1 week ago
    Rainbow bagel is a must-try. They've got a bunch of specialty cream cheeses like Funfetti, Nutella, and maple bacon—and they give you a ton of it—but the bagels go good even with plain ol' butter.
  • Elvis R.
    Get here by Saturday 1030am to wait in.The rainbow bagel with funfetti was that et al! The nutella crmchse was outstanding 2!Make sure u pay respect to their get CROGEL with veg cream! Friendly staff!
  • Mariana P.
    If you like bagels this is the place. The most interesting thing are the rainbow bagels they sell. However, it took me 3 hours and a half to buy them. Two hours waiting outside an more waiting inside.
  • Tommy C.
    Tommy ChenMarch 6
    The birthday cake cream cheese is a must with the Rainbow Bagel, it's meh without it. The cragels are extremely dense. The french toast and bacon, egg and cheese bagels are my fav. Service is SLOW!
  • The Corcoran Group
    The Corcoran GroupSeptember 9, 2013
    THE go-to spot for bagels you can't find anywhere else. The French Toast Bagel is amazing, but nothing beats the Bacon, Egg & Cheddar Cheese Bagel. Great lox cream cheese too!
  • Brian G.
    The bagels are delicious, and they have a good variety of flavors. An egg sandwich on a bagel from here is the perfect weekend hangover cure. The line often extends out the door on Sundays!
  • Faith
    FaithMarch 4
    Come early to get the bagels fresh! Amazing rainbow bagels with funfetti creamcheese! And a must get: bacon egg and cheese bagel with bacon egg and cheese on it!!
  • A Great Big City
    A Great Big CityDecember 3, 2010
    The French Toast bagel is fantastic! And if you're still craving some deliciousness, take home a big variety bag of bagels (near the drinks at the front). A bag of eight bagels for less than $3!
  • Aileen T.
    Aileen TanApril 24
    came here for the rainbow bagels expecting it to taste like real bagels... unfortunately they don't taste anything like bagels... it's just like eating colors... not worth my drive from jersey 🙁
  • FreshNYC p.
    FreshNYC p}-:{>January 1, 2015
    At first glance it looks like any other bagel shops - but with an extensive lineup of hybrid bagels and creative sandwiches options, The Bagel Store is anything but your typical breakfast bagel joint. Read more
  • Adam
    AdamMarch 1, 2011
    Where is this hostility coming from? Amazing bagels, great selection, nice staff... I love the tiny girl behind the counter, she's friendly and hilarious. Careful, this place can get crowded fast!
  • Nicholas D.
    Nicholas DoyleAugust 23, 2014
    Juicy Plump Capers, Slivered Red Onions, Crisp Tomato, with Cream Cheese and Fresh Lox piled high make for an unforgettable bagel munching experience.
  • KrM V.
    KrM VasquezJune 18, 2012
    Sun dried tomato spread is pretty dope. Prepare to spend 15 mins here waiting for your order if you are not the only customer there. Make sure you count your change also. Some of the staff are douchey
  • Greegg C.
    Greegg CeeeeMarch 19, 2013
    Best bagels in the city. French toast bagel with cannoli cream cheese. Or a bacon egg and cheese bagel with bacon egg and cheese. U can't go wrong with anything u order here.
  • Brandon K.
    Brandon KeeneNovember 1, 2015
    They never charge the same amount twice, watch out! I order the exact hing every time and it has cost anywhere from $6 to 11. Counter lady does not have it if you inquire why. Done with this place.
  • JARET F.
    JARET FERRATUSCOMarch 10, 2015
    So many damn bagels and a rad personnel. Good prices, affordable, fast and delicious. If you like bagels make a stop here and check out the 200 spread options.
  • Andrew P.
    Andrew PerezApril 13
    Rainbow bagels are a fun novelty but they're not very tasty and will raise a certain level of concern when you use the toilet.
  • Jon P.
    Jon ParkerDecember 15, 2012
    As others have said, definitely the best bagels in the neighborhood (was formerly a Bagelsmith enthusiast), however the slow service can often more than offset the better bagel.
  • Angie H.
    Angie HJuly 10, 2013
    Don't let the tofu spreads drive you away. The tofu sun dried tomato spread is so delicious you'll forget you were trying to be healthy.
  • TheBagelStore
    TheBagelStoreFebruary 20, 2015
    Friday Is "French Toast" Bagel With "Nutella" Cream Cheese Day *Nutella Can Cure Anything...#brooklyntours #brooklynNY #brooklyn # welovethiscity #made_in_ny #bkny #newyorkcity#newyork
  • Addison H.
    Addison HuffDecember 21, 2014
    Specialty bagels and cream cheeses are the way to go. There are better "standard" bagels elsewhere. My personal favorite is the cragel - so delicious.
  • Max S.
    Max SklarDecember 22, 2013
    The new location tastes just as good and is just as authentic - but service is much better. Pumpernickel all the way!
  • Matt R.
    Matt RichardsonMarch 19, 2012
    Line up in the back to order, then get in the cashier line to pay. When it's crowded, be sure the order-taker puts your name on the slip... mixups happen.
  • Jacek R.
    Jacek RolnikApril 7, 2012
    live the bagels here BUT service is insanely slow. busy or not. today for example the staff to customer ratio was about 3-1 and I still waited about 15 min for my bagel
  • Amandalyn F.
    Amandalyn FerriAugust 2, 2009
    Try and get the cashier to hand you your money instead of putting it down on the counter. Bonus points if she doesn't lick her fingers when counting back your change
  • Chegge
    CheggeApril 27, 2012
    Not cheap example: everything thats NOT listed is an extra. 70 cents each. You want lettuce & tomato on your sandwich...thats an extra $1.40
  • Rachael G.
    Rachael GeeeOctober 8, 2011
    Lots of amazing tofu cream cheese options--just make sure your bagel doesn't have milk or eggs in that flavor if you're vegan.
  • Jordan F.
    Jordan FiguraSeptember 28, 2013
    Today I had the sweet potato / apple bagel with pumpkin pie cream cheese and it was the best bagel I've ever had
  • Matt K.
    Matt KiserJuly 15, 2012
    don't be foolish, get a bacon, egg, and cheese on a toasted multi-grain everything bagel. get your coffee from oslo.
  • Daan V.
    Daan V.November 24, 2011
    My favorite bagel place in New York. I'm a sucker for the whole wheat everything with any of the tofu cream cheeses.
  • Danielle C.
    Danielle CarrickOctober 28, 2013
    Cool bagel flavors but somehow my egg sandwich and iced coffee was $9. I gave them a ten and didn't get any change.
  • Brett J.
    Brett JossMay 19, 2014
    Go here to avoid the crowds at Bagelsmith on 7th and Bedford--it's just as good. Cash only but ATM inside.
  • Nicole F.
    Nicole FormicaJuly 2, 2015
    It's like the Willy Wonka factory for bagels. So many flavors of bagels and cream cheeses to choose from. Beware of the SLOW service.
  • Lana W.
    Lana WangOctober 14, 2013
    Delicious. Absolutely delicious. Cannoli cream cheese and lox cream cheese on the everything was cheap and tasty
  • Russell Allen E.
    Russell Allen E.May 2, 2010
    delicious bagels and great ingrediants. try the bagel/egg sandwich.. I liked the 'everything' bagel!!!
  • Jacek R.
    Jacek RolnikApril 28, 2012
    bring your patience! Slow, slow, slow. Waited 30 minutes for a bagel with egg and ham. And this is not an exception .. The norm
  • Priscilla M.
    Priscilla MartinelliNovember 25, 2012
    Great place! Amazing food and gentle service! Stop by and try a coffee and a bagel!
  • Im J.
    Im JffJanuary 19, 2015
    The garlic bagel was supreme. The Mexican omelette was simple and great. Love this place
  • G.S.A
    G.S.AMarch 15
    Biggest waste of time and money. Worst bagels in NYC and that is a big feat to accomplish. Do yourself a favour and just don't.
  • Thai C.
    Thai ChuDecember 10, 2009
    If you go in the evening, you MUST toast your bagel! Wireless is through "Netgear" not "Bagel Store"?
  • Jastine K.
    Jastine KhoJanuary 26
    The bagels and cream cheese are delicious! Not cheap though
  • Rebecca M.
    The rainbow bagel with confetti sprinkles is a dream for someone with a sweet tooth
  • Sean L.
    Sean LodgeOctober 9, 2012
    Who charges for lettuce and tomato? My tuna and cheese on a bagel and a can of soda cost $10.
  • Alina M.
    Alina Maria3 weeks ago
    A bit overrated. The bread is okeish, the cream works; overall ok, but not breathtaking.
  • Valentina M.
    Valentina MonteApril 28, 2013
    Ok so the bagel here was so fluffy and perfect it kind of changed my life.
  • Arnaud R.
    Arnaud RéautéNovember 15, 2015
    Large choice of bagels and cream cheese. Cragel is a good sweet treat.
  • Daniel K.
    Daniel KimNovember 2, 2010
    Best bagels in Williamsburg. Try the blueberry bagel when they have them
  • John D.
    John DeelyDecember 4, 2013
    Top notch bagels, but every time I go, they get smaller and smaller
  • Caleb
    CalebDecember 8, 2012
    If you order a French Toast with sausage, egg and cheese, it's pretty much a fabled MCGRIDDLE.
  • Matt K.
    Matt KiserDecember 16, 2011
    best bagels in williamsburg. oh, and locally owned so support it, dodos.
619 Photos

Related Searches

  • the bagel store brooklyn
  • the bagel store brooklyn photos
  • the bagel store brooklyn location
  • the bagel store brooklyn address
  • the bagel store brooklyn
  • bagel store brooklyn
  • bagle store brooklyn
  • the bagel store brooklyn
  • the bagle store brooklyn
  • the bagel store williamsburg brooklyn

Foursquare © 2016  Lovingly made in NYC & SF