People tend to check in during these times:
Chowdah & chicken sandwich- my winning combo every damn time
Unfortunately, we get our wooden nickels maybe two out of every five visits.
You can't go wrong with the chowder, beer selection is fantastic, and the chicken sandwich is one of my favorite things to eat on this entire island
The stuff is good and the food is delicious.Try buffalo wings:-)
Try the Offshore Nut Brown Ale
Open all season! Personal favorites are the fish and chips, newes burger, and roast beef. Get the beer sampler for the table.
Why and HOW is their chicken sandwich so amazingly good?!?!
We've been coming here since the day they first opened. Great atmosphere, food and micro brew. I've been collecting those wooden nickels for years.
Lobster mac & cheese and artichoke dip. Get them. You're welcome.
Local brews and wooden nickels. This place is an institution.
The BEST Fish and Chips I've ever had.
Limited vegetarian options as to be expected for pub fare. But a really tasty porter beer, brewed locally.
Cool menus shaped like newspapers accompanied by really great sandwiches. Make sure you try the crab dip!
Get a beer rack! Five beers for $13.50.
Every new restaurant I go to I start with a burger. If you screw that up, nothing else is good. Well, I tried that her about twelve years ago. I now have one two to three times per visit to the island
French onion soup was delicious, BLT salad was average. Had chicken breast added, was cold chicken, would have been better grilled. All in all, pretty good.
It might be the start of the off-season, but it's prime time to get Shipyard's Pumpkinhead Ale. Onion soup & pulled pork sandwich, definitely. Colossal chocolate cake was out of control good. Go. Now.
Good clam chowder; I would pass on the chicken piccata pasta
Great chowder and beer selection.
Great Pub, great beer, great food, great live-music!!
In the off season they have some great "Wee Bites"! Our favorite is the Fried Four Mac n' Cheese!!! http://hungrynative.com/?p=262
Come visit Ashley she rocks socks
This is my place... Rack o beers please and don't forget the wooden nickels! The only spot I am willing to buy a turkey sandwich from... Roquefort Stilettos and pretzel fried chicken mmmmmmm
Get the Lobster Roll, the best I've had!
Tall beer, calamari & fish & chips. Save your nickels!
No such place. It's "Newes" and "Kelley" street.
The Caesar is good, but the dressing could be more even.
They have a great pulled pork sandwich.
Fish& chips and tall beers.