The Original Goodfella's Brick Oven Pizza

The Original Goodfella's Brick Oven Pizza

Pizza Place, Brewery, and Italian Restaurant
1718 Hylan Blvd (at Seaview Ave), Staten Island, NY 10305, United States
Hours:
Open until 11:00 PM (Show more)
  • Mon–Thu, Sun
    • 11:00 AM–9:45 PM
  • Fri–Sat
    • 11:00 AM–11:00 PM
Price:
$ $ $ $
Reservations:
No
Menus:
Lunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks:
Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails
Credit Cards:
Yes (incl. American Express)
Wi-Fi:
Free
Outdoor Seating:
No

Welcome to The Original Goodfella’s Brick Oven Pizza in Staten Island, where it all started!

8.5/10

Based on 81 votes

People like this place

Total Visitors
879
Total Visits
1,487
Save
Share
  • Ranked #4 for pizza places in Staten Island
  • What you need to know
    Visit i.
    "Gotta try the tequila sunrise pizza."(2 Tips)
    Visit i.
    "perfection and the Pizza Alla Vodka"(2 Tips)
    Visit i.
    "The vodka pie was the best I ever had."(7 Tips)
    Visit i.
    "Fried calamari is to die for"(4 Tips)

From The Original Goodfella's Brick Oven Pizza

Special

Every Friday from 10p.m.-midnight, stop in for our two-for-one drink specials!

Cannot be combined with any other offers.

Log in to leave tips at this venue!
Sort:
  • Recent
  • Popular

90 tips and reviews.

  • Filter by taste:
  • all tips and reviews
  • pizza
  • tequila sunrise
  • full bar
  • good for a quick meal
  • good for dates
  • calamari
  • family-friendly
  • authentic
  • lunch specials
  • mussels
  • lively
  • lasagna
  • happy hour
  • steak
  • healthy food
  • cozy
  • good for a late night
  • chicken
  • casual
  • beer
  • Alec N.

    .. been on a mission to try all of their Specialty pies... so far not a single disappointment.

    Alec Nacion · 2 weeks ago
    Save
  • Leo C.

    good service. good food. personal size pizzas big enough to feed 2 folks!

    Leo C · May 6
    Save
  • Mark T.

    Chicken parm. Pasta. Pizza. Great wooden old fashioned full bar room love the food here

    Mark Turok · March 18
    Save
  • The Original Goodfella's Brick Oven Pizza

    Two-for-one drink special Every Friday from 10p.m.-midnight, stop in for our two-for-one drink specials!

    Save
  • Visit i.

    My second time coming and it was jest as good as the first time. No one on Staten Island is doing pizza like these guys. The vodka pie was the best I had ever had and I had some fried calamari th... Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · December 4, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    What a great place. My new favorite to bring the family. The food was amazing and reasonably priced, the service was the best ever and the atmosphere was fun. Place is clean and homey, the staff... Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · December 1, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    Just finished having lunch with my family and our experience was amazing. We shared an order of calamari that was made to perfection and the Pizza Alla Vodka was unbelieveable. Goodfellas definit... Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · November 30, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    Just had the smoking goodfella. Now I understand why it was voted best pizza in the world! Can't wait to go back! Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · November 30, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    Place looks soo nice for the holidays. Pizza was unreal. A must go to place. People are friendly and the owners are attentive. Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · November 30, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    This place always impresses me... Only my third or fourth time here. Nick our waiter was friendly and very attentive, took excellent care of me and my family. My first time there for dinner and w... Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · November 29, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    Jamed packed house but worth the wait!!! Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · November 29, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    Brianna was an amazing waitress. Food was great and I can't wait to go back!! Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · November 28, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    This place is the best. Fast and friendly service, awesome food, clean as can be. Bring your friends Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · November 28, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    Everything here is off the charts. A must try. Fried calamari is to die for Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · November 28, 2014
    Save
  • Andrew S.

    Brick Oven Rib Eye Steak - wood fired

    Andrew Scudera · November 27, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    Came in with 29 of my friends tonight. I am the king. My buddies loved it. Pizza is better then anything I had. Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · November 26, 2014
    Save
  • Brianna S.

    Everything is sooo good at goodfellas

    Brianna Slyman · November 25, 2014
    Save
  • Dana F.

    Pizza all a vodka is the best on the island

    Dana Foley · November 25, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    What a fun great place. They have a nice size bar with cold cold beer and the pasta dish I had was unbelievable; stuffed penne with artichokes and chicken. Super friendly staff and owners and su... Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · November 25, 2014
    Save
  • Ann

    Staff and food is great! I always have a good time when I sit at the bar. All the bartenders are very attentive and friendly. Definitely a good place to hang out and relax.

    Ann · November 25, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    Came back to goodfellas on my lunch break today. It was another great experience. The bartender Lauren was great. Very attentive and friendly. This time I had the grilled salmon with spinach lunc... Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · November 25, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    The food was fantastic! had the lunch special and you can't beat that deal, pasta salad n soda for 9 and change .. Amazing! Service was impeccable, quick and I was able to adjust my order to mak... Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · November 25, 2014
    Save
  • Andrew S.

    Linguini and clams made with fresh baby clams(not canned) at the original Goodfellas

    Andrew Scudera · November 25, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    Gotta try the tequila sunrise pizza. Nothing like it on earth. Shrimp pancetta mango salsa. Unbelievable flavor. The service was awesome even though the place was packed. A must try Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · November 25, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    The pizza guy today made me the best pizza I have ever had!!! I can't wait to come back tomorrow for some more pizza and maybe even a brick oven steak!! Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · November 25, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    The food is always delicious, portions are huge and the service is outstanding ! Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · November 25, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    Excellent food and excellent service. The beer is ice cold and everything is fresh and made to order. Tried the buffalo chicken pie, it was the best pie I have ever had. The staff is very friendl... Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · November 24, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    Awesome pizza and service. Penne Alla vodka is awesome too Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · November 24, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    Had a fantastic lunch today, quickly made and super delicious. Service was awesome Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · November 24, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    Coldest beer in town. Best pizza on the island hands down. Try the vodka pizza Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · November 24, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    Just got done having the brick oven steak and it was the best steak I ever had!! I'll deff be back for sure! Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · November 24, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    Adriana was such a pleasure at the bar. I ate there and was entertained by the Rangers winning 5 to 0. The pizza was unreal, very unique and probably the best I ever had. Can't wait to go back Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · November 24, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    I have the greatest meal today at the goodfellas on hylan blvd. brick oven pizza is to die for. Got try the tequila pizza Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · November 24, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    Best pizza I have ever had in my entire life and I'm a pizza nut. Service was super friendly, fast and professional. Try the vodka pie Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · November 23, 2014
    Save
  • Sean F.

    Best vodka pie. Only good goodfellas on Staten Island.

    Sean Fisher · October 9, 2014
    Save
  • David M.

    Pizza is really good crispy

    David Michael · October 7, 2014
    Save
  • Erin M.

    One of my favorite pizza places in all of NYC!

    Erin Murphy · October 2, 2014
    Save
  • Jimmy

    Try the Pizza Alla Vodka. It's pretty good.

    Jimmy · October 1, 2014
    Save
  • Felix G.

    Mushroom madness!!!! Awesome!!!

    Felix Grushevsky · September 30, 2014
    Save
  • Jake S.

    Here's a day for non SI folk. Bike to Staten Island ferry. Ride it, take the beach path down to goodfellas. Have some pizza and beer. Return from where you came from and wish you lived closer.

    Jake Simms · September 20, 2014
    Save
  • Rossana R.

    The best Quattro Fomagia pizza. And try the Goodfella Chicken: delicious!!

    Rossana R · August 13, 2014
    Save
  • Rajeev I.

    The tequila sunrise pie was amazing. Totally deserves the best pizza award.

    Rajeev Iyer · August 9, 2014
    Save
  • Jen G.

    Love the mussels!

    Jen Grunwald · August 7, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    Awesome pizza Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · March 6, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    Awesome pizza and great service. Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · March 3, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    Delicious pizza. Best service with a smile Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · March 3, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    Great service!!! Best place to eat Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · March 3, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    The food was great and the staff was amazing , would definitely recommend eating here. Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · March 3, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    First timer and I couldn't be more happy service was excellent and food was fantastic .... I got the apricot glazed salmon truly amazing and the pizza as an appetizer also fantastic .. Since I wa... Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · March 3, 2014
    Save
  • Visit i.

    I went to Goodfella's last night with my family and the waitress recommended the Smoking Goodfella pizza. Good thing she did because it was one of the best pies I've ever had. Great mix of flavor... Read more

    Visit iTrueReview.com · March 3, 2014
    Save