The Pie of Port Jefferson

Pizza Place, Italian Restaurant, and Wine Bar$$$$
Port Jefferson
Save
Share
8.0/10
43
ratings
  • Nikolas F.
    "Some of the best pizza in Port Jeff."(2 Tips)
    Scott C.
    "Classic thin brick oven pizza."(2 Tips)
    William Z.
    "Great family place..try the clam pizza!"(2 Tips)
    David R.
    "staff at the pickup counter was the friendliest!"(3 Tips)
17 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • pizza
  • family-friendly
  • lively
  • great value
  • authentic
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent
  • Debbie C.
    Debbie CraigOctober 7, 2012
    The mixed green salad with Gorgonzola cheese, cucumber, red onion and toasted crusted walnuts was Fabulous! A large serving for ten bucks. Great pizza and meatball subs too.
  • Kelly
    KellyJune 24, 2012
    Great food, reasonable prices, great service & a very family friendly spot for a sit down meal in the heart of town. We love coming here!
  • Jake S.
    Jake SmithAugust 17, 2014
    Undecided? Give the Di Parma and Casino pizzas a go, although I don't think you'll be disappointed in any of the pies from here.
  • David R.
    David RicciMarch 3, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    In addition to making a mean brick oven pizza, the staff at the pickup counter was the friendliest!
  • Alice G.
    Alice GlassAugust 15, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    My favorite table is the little one in the front window. The restaurant is rather loud, but this table seems to be the best.
  • Katy R.
    Katy RayJanuary 17, 2014
    Every time I come here I remember how lax the service is...after I order my food and don't see the server until they deliver the bill. Everything else is great though!
  • Scott C.
    Scott CohenFebruary 18, 2012
    Classic thin brick oven pizza. Yea its on the pricey side, but worth it.
  • Explore L.
    Explore Long IslandFebruary 20, 2013
    We dubbed The Pie as one of the 10 "Long Island's best pizza pies" worth the drive! Read more
  • John F.
    John FeinbergOctober 6, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    Best pizza in Port Jeff. Tad expensive but expected in a tourist area.
  • William Z.
    William ZezelicOctober 16, 2014
    Great family place..try the clam pizza!
  • Jen🎀 M.
    Jen🎀 MooreAugust 4, 2013
    This isn't a tip but there's hot waiters ;)
  • Nikolas F.
    Nikolas FlorosJanuary 25, 2015
    Some of the best pizza in Port Jeff.
  • AnneMarie S.
    AnneMarie ShultzMay 15, 2011
    Best garlic knots around.
  • Shawn
    ShawnDecember 7, 2013
    This thin crust Chicky Cheeses is way too loud and disorganized for the high prices.
  • Rei
    ReiMarch 12
    Nice place!
  • J D.
    J DoctorJune 29, 2010
    Bomb thin crust pizzas!
  • Sean
    SeanApril 18, 2010
    Pizza looks good .. Too thin tho
20 Photos

Related Searches

  • the pie of port jefferson port jefferson
  • the pie of port jefferson port jefferson photos
  • the pie of port jefferson port jefferson location
  • the pie of port jefferson port jefferson address
  • the pie of port jefferson port jefferson
  • pie port jefferson
  • pie of port jefferson port jefferson
  • pizzeria napolentana port jefferson
  • pizzeria napoletan port jefferson
  • the pie port jefferson
  • the pie of port jefferson port jefferson

Foursquare © 2016  Lovingly made in NYC & SF