The Pie Store

Bakery$$$$
Montclair
Save
Share
8.7/10
57
ratings
  • Ranked #3 for bakeries in Montclair
  • Linnie D.
    "All the sweet and savory pies looked delicious."(3 Tips)
    Bernadette B.
    "New are channa masala and dhal giant pasties."(3 Tips)
    Emily R.
    "Love the meat pies!"(2 Tips)
    Stacee R.
    "totally not a dessert pie."(2 Tips)
22 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • pies
  • savory pies
  • pasties
  • pastries
  • desserts
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Recent
  • Popular
  • Linnie D.
    Linnie DJanuary 13
    All the sweet and savory pies looked delicious. Particularly the key lime pie. The shopkeeper is friendly and so are the patrons. Just wish they had gluten and dairy free options.
  • Nom N.
    Nom NomFebruary 25, 2016
    English chocolate bars
  • Lisa R.
    Lisa RubinichFebruary 15, 2016
    The chocolate chip scones are delish
  • Russell Z.
    Russell ZackNovember 17, 2015
    They serve both traditional British meat pies as well as US dessert pies. Their fruit pies are fresh and dont have the 'grocery' store shelf taste. The apple, raspberry, blackberry pie is a must taste
  • Stacee R.
    Stacee RonaeNovember 12, 2015
    I waited all day to dig into my pumpkin pie...it's totally not a dessert pie. It's a pie that could be served as a vegetable side dish. I want to try their meal pies. The place smelled yummy!
  • Daryle A.
    Daryle AbrahamsSeptember 22, 2015
    Pie! All of them. The turkey and stuffing is outrageous. Consistently fabulous place. Sam is a genius with quality food and real biscuits.
  • Jim M.
    Jim MazzeiAugust 8, 2015
    I started with the desserts but they talked me into trying the savory pies. They were great! I no go there at least once every two weeks to try something new! Great plac5, don't miss it
  • Tom H.
    Tom HalleranJuly 31, 2015
    Tried the Cornish pasty. Very nice!
  • Tom H.
    Tom HalleranJuly 18, 2015
    Carry away only, parking is tight, but pies are brilliant! Fill your pantry with UK staples while you're here.
  • Tom H.
    Tom HalleranJuly 18, 2015
    Excellent savory pies! Chicken curry "soccer" pies were excellent - a small bit of spice, but not enough to deter my six year old. Will be back for more!
  • Erin
    ErinMarch 14, 2015
    St. Paddy's cupcakes are going on right now :)
  • Eric C.
    Eric CAugust 8, 2014
    Love the owner here, she's extremely funny and makes amazing pies. You can't go wrong with anything ordered here
  • Nicole
    NicoleMarch 16, 2014
    Been here 10+ times
    Best place for all your British food needs. Love it!
  • Alison C.
    Alison CurtinDecember 29, 2013
    Steak & Ale pie is to die for!
  • Chris L.
    Chris LJune 20, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    Yay for the pasty fix! Also adore the cheddar scones. So pleased a place like this exists around here...
  • Bernadette B.
    Bernadette BaumMay 5, 2012
    Also where I restock on basics like Cadbury chocs, Ribena and (British) Heinz baked beans :)
  • Bernadette B.
    Bernadette BaumMay 5, 2012
    Best pies ever. Chicken tikka is fab, and steak and ale. New are channa masala and dhal giant pasties. Yum!
  • Diana M.
    Diana MarksJanuary 1, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    The best place to go to for anything English. If you love english food then this is the place to get it. We know the owners and the food is great.
  • Richard B.
    Richard BaumDecember 30, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    You don't have to be British to love the top-quality pies at this Montclair gem. Pick up some UK tea, biscuits and sweets while you're here
  • Emily R.
    Emily ReesApril 13, 2011
    Love the meat pies! Yum!
  • Victor J.
    Victor JungOctober 2, 2010
    Been here 10+ times
    The Scottish pie, pork pie and soups are awesome meals for the fall.
  • Krista H.
    Krista HarrisApril 22, 2010
    Try the pie!
25 Photos

Related Searches

  • the pie store montclair
  • the pie store montclair photos
  • the pie store montclair location
  • the pie store montclair address
  • the pie store montclair
  • pie store montclair
  • the pie store montclair

Foursquare © 2017  Lovingly made in NYC & SF