Our focus here at The Pony Bar is to bring you a rotating selection of the finest craft beers America has to offer.
Best American craft beer bar in NYC
Lots of beers on tap. No wonder it's the Untappd founder's hangout
It's almost always busy but the beer selection is worth standing for.
Fantastic, rotating craft beer selection on tap, including a number of quite rare ones. One of the best beer places you will find in Manhattan.
Fantastic beer selection and if you're hungry, just go next door for some pizza!
If you love craft beer, this is the place to get it! Go during New York Comic Con for The Defender!
Still one of the best beer bars you could hope to find. Coast to coast coverage of Americas great beer scene. Friendly HK staff, great comfort food to match your brew. Believe the hype, NEW BEER!!!
Great selection of beer
So many types of beers
Always interesting beers on tap. Great wooden interior and the snacks aren't half bad.
Good beer selection
Short rib sandwich is so good.
Tons of beer options. Not a ton of room.
Though I find the digital beer board a bit odd in terms of decor, they have great beers & a cool vibe. The calamari are sweet-spicy perfection.
Happy hour is awesome..some of Americas best beers for a really good price
The beer selection is excellent, lots of local choices
Quality craft beers with a constantly updated digital menu. Too many IPAs and bathrooms are disgusting.
Their beer selection is ever changing. Ask for a sample if you can't decide!
Loved this place! The amount and selection of crafts beers is just amazing. And the original burger is pretty good too for a normal burger.
Large beer selection. Bartender' happy to help you find something new you'll like.
One of the most daunting and exciting lists of beers in the city
Excellent. Went here after leaving the dud Alfie's. Great New York beer selection.
Very good, constantly rotating beer selection.
Pretty small bar with lots of cheap beers costing a total of 6 bucks each. Gets packed on Fridays--sausage fest most nights.
Small, but great draft list
Tip well! The bartenders here are really cool :)
So many beers on tap! Not always seasonal but great variety and great value.
Rotating craft beer selection is awesome. Make sure to participate when they ring the bell!
Excellent beer list and top notch service.
was there last night, beer selection is ok, good balance between price and quality.. but still no comparison with my fav Armsby Abbey in Worcester. Little too loud but mostly cause of many people..
Solid happy hour
Great place for a beer. Popular place that fills up quickly.
great selection of craft beers (20+)
Friendly staff help with your (huge) choice of beers.
Great local bar with rotating beer menu that changes daily. Staff is great, food is delicious.
Beer selection is nice but candied pork belly meat sticks "bacon" are awe inspiring! Word.
A must for any be lover
A lot of beers. Lotta stuff to try.
Lots of good craft beer here. All beers are $6, with glasses changing size accordingly.
A beer lover's paradise. Try everything.
Great beer selection, reasonable prices, good for groups, music at just the right level to be present but not prevent conversations
Craft beer original. Gets crowded but it's worth the visit for sure.
The best beer selection, maybe in all of NYC. If you come here, download the Untapd app on your phone to keep track of which ones you tried and which ones you liked!
A great local. If you can get a seat at the bar, you are set for the night. Great beers and friendly staff.
Wide selection of beer at reasonable prices. Not too crowded on a Friday night.
One of the best beer bars I've ever been to.
They have happy hour♥ great beer bar.
Great selection of rotating craft beers. Reasonably priced for NYC. Calamari, skillet sausage, and buffalo chicken pierogi all very good.