The Seafood Shanty

Seafood Restaurant and American Restaurant$$$$
  • Ranked #2 for seafood restaurants in Edgartown
  • Danyel S.
    "get the lobster roll or the fish 'n' chips."(7 Tips)
    Andrea B.
    "Decent food but the upstairs bar is like going back to high school."(4 Tips)
    Jessie A.
    "Get the lobster quesadilla!"(3 Tips)
    Dory M.
    "Great view of Chappy Island and Edgartown lighthouse!"(15 Tips)
50 Tips and reviews
  • scenic views
  • chappy
  • Bloody Marys
  • decent food
  • rooftop
Log in to leave a tip here.

  • Recent
  • Popular
  • Bryce S.
    Bryce StewartSeptember 19, 2016
    Verify your order. Make sure you know what it comes with. My large to go order was not as expected based on how it was placed and I ended up having to spend more money to get what I actually ordered.
  • Jeffrey
    JeffreyJuly 24, 2016
    Fish sandwich, salmon roll, fries
  • James K.
    James KiernanAugust 9, 2015
    Come for the view and to get a buzz on but not for the food or service
  • Robert D.
    Robert DiPadovaJuly 20, 2015
    Food and views
  • Kris S.
    Kris Shockley RiceJuly 11, 2015
    Wonderful fish and chips!
  • Mat B.
    Mat BurnettJuly 3, 2015
    Yes I had the lobster roll. And I'd do it again.
  • James
    JamesMay 29, 2015
    Good views, bad food.
  • Courtney
    CourtneySeptember 23, 2014
    Generous lobster rolls
  • Andrea B.
    Andrea BarrezuetaAugust 31, 2014
    Decent food. Lobster salad roll doesn't have a ton of mayo (good thing). Avoid the upstairs bar unless you are into frat parties
  • Andrea B.
    Andrea BarrezuetaAugust 30, 2014
    Decent food but the upstairs bar is like going back to high school. Music wasn't bad but ended up wearing everybody's drinks. No one even apologizes!
  • Katie (.
    Fish, bloody marys, views. Awesome.
  • Jeffrey G.
    Jeffrey GlueckAugust 15, 2014
    This is a tourist trap to avoid unless you just like cocktails with a harbor view. The lobster rolls are pre made and not hot. Lobster quesadillas cold. Nothing fresh. Good French fries for kids
  • Rob H.
    Rob HavasyAugust 9, 2014
    Harbor views from the deck are great. Decent food too.
  • Lits R.
    Lits RussoMarch 24, 2014
    Get there early its always really busy. And theres free popcorn!
  • Ellie R.
    Ellie RountreeSeptember 14, 2013
    Go upstairs to the outdoor bar, order beers and little neck clams from the waitresses. The bloody Mary's and lobster rolls look good, but I haven't tried 'em.
  • Dory M.
    Dory MacielSeptember 14, 2013
    Great view of Chappy Island and Edgartown lighthouse!
  • Rebel H.
    Rebel HoffmanSeptember 8, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Bourbon & popcorn. Oh, and a lobster roll!
  • Suyin
    SuyinAugust 7, 2013
    Root beer Float. Yes. Root Beer Float. Best ever and I don't even like them.
  • Carroll & Vincent R.
    This view is as good as it gets in Edgartown
  • Brian F.
    Brian FarrowJuly 23, 2013
    Great spot good chowder
  • Mark G.
    Mark GraciaJuly 6, 2013
    Been here 10+ times
    Get the green monstah ipa, love that dirty water!
  • Tatyana S.
    Tatyana SharoubimJuly 4, 2013
    Bloody Mary all the way is awesome. Lobster roll if its our first time is def a good start. Crab cake sandwich or mussels are another top choice. Fun party place at night with friends also.
  • Eric A.
    Eric AndersenJuly 4, 2013
    Late nite hits the Vineyard! Open til 1AM on Thursday, Friday, and Saturday…and special occasions like July 3/4
  • Robert
    RobertJune 14, 2013
    Try the food here it's their specialty.
  • Chris F.
    Chris FohlinJuly 21, 2012
    Decent food, plenty of drinks, and probably the best view of the Edgartown harbor. Try to sit on the top deck for the full effect--bring a sweatshirt if it's breezy!
  • Erik A.
    Erik AJuly 18, 2012
    Stay away from the Captains Platter - tough whole belly clams, previously frozen shrimp, and flavorless haddock. The french fries were OK. Do yourself a favor and get it from Nancy's in Oak Bluffs.
  • Terrell S.
    Terrell SandefurJuly 15, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    Try the New England Clam Chowder - Probably the best chowder in Edgartown
  • Eric A.
    Eric AndersenJune 21, 2012
    Go upstairs, grab a table on the deck, and enjoy fantastic views of Edgartown Harbor!
  • Eric A.
    Eric AndersenJune 20, 2012
    The Vineyard Style crab cakes are tender and delicious…
  • Eric A.
    Eric AndersenJune 20, 2012
    Be adventurous and try the local Katama oysters!
  • Eric A.
    Eric AndersenJune 20, 2012
    The lobster quesadilla is a must-try!
  • Jackie
    JackieJune 9, 2012
    Best View in town!
  • Renée G.
    Renée GreeneSeptember 2, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    Sit at bar on deck. It's beautiful water view of Chappy! My see GaGa!
  • QueLindaMami
    QueLindaMamiAugust 26, 2011
    The calamari at American Newes is better. Mussels had no flavor at all. Our server was rude. Not worth the $$$.
  • Claire B.
    Claire BarthelemyAugust 25, 2011
    If in Edgartown this place is a must! Head up to the roof deck for amazing views
  • Courtney T.
    Courtney TincherAugust 17, 2011
    Take a picture with Ray Shanty!
  • Danyel S.
    Danyel SmithAugust 16, 2011
    don't even think about it. get the lobster roll or the fish 'n' chips. done.
  • Jessie A.
    Jessie A.August 11, 2011
    Get the lobster quesadilla!
  • Sonya V.
    Sonya ViolanteJune 26, 2011
    Best clams!!!
  • Imran J.
    Imran JafereyJune 26, 2011
    Mussels are awesome
  • Sanaz L.
    Sanaz LimoueeJune 25, 2011
    Order the best bloody mary with jumbo shrimp or the blueberry & acaia vodka with pink lemonade!! Portions are huge, sushi is good, you can't go wrong.
  • D. H.
    D. HJJune 21, 2011
    Shrimp and scallop scampi is mouth-watering. Buttery olive oily garlic-y goodness of pasta. Large portion so you won't leave hungry.
  • HungryNative
    HungryNativeJune 18, 2011
    Been here 25+ times
    On a sunny afternoon, grab a couple mudslides and a table on the upstairs deck. Great view of Edgartown harbor.
  • WhatsUpMartha
    WhatsUpMarthaDecember 21, 2010
    Been here 25+ times
    If you're looking to sip some dangerous sizzurp: Order up a Grapeful Dead - you will thank us the next morning - with well, whoever you "meet" ; ) - Zennan behind the bar is a god and patron saint Read more
  • Gus
    GusSeptember 6, 2010
    Been here 5+ times
    Do order drinks from Dan @ the bar. Do request Tamzin for a server. Do get the oysters.
  • Holly I.
    Holly InnocenziAugust 10, 2010
    Been here 10+ times
    Ask for Justin or Damaris they really go above and beyond- made our experience great!
  • Shane S.
    Shane ShapsAugust 2, 2010
    Peel n eats great. Expensive for lunch but great view
  • WillMcD
    WillMcDJuly 31, 2010
    Great outdoor seating. Recommend the MV Tea. Really good.
  • Danyel S.
    Danyel SmithJune 16, 2010
    gt the shrimp cocktail. the fish 'n' chips. sit outside on the downstairs level. watch for the swan. it swims by, hoping for a snack.
  • Fer C.
    Fer CJuly 2, 2015
    El sandwich de langosta no está mal, pero yo le pondría mantequilla al pan. Cuando hay mucho viento conviene sentarse adentro, es algo molesto y se vuela la comida, literal.
264 Photos

Related Searches

  • the seafood shanty edgartown
  • the seafood shanty edgartown photos
  • the seafood shanty edgartown location
  • the seafood shanty edgartown address
  • the seafood shanty edgartown
  • seafood shanty edgartown
  • seafood shsnty edgartown
  • shanty's edgartown
  • shantys edgartown
  • the seafood shanty edgartown

Foursquare © 2017  Lovingly made in NYC & SF