Planning a trip to San Francisco?
Foursquare can help you find the best places to go to.
Hot Cookie
Bakery and Dessert Shop$$$$
Castro, San Francisco
The cookies at Hot Cookie is a can't miss
"Favorite after Cocoa Cayenne and Coconut Macaroons"(8 Tips)
"Suprise your friends with the macaroon."(7 Tips)
"strongly recommend the Cocoa Cayenne and the White Chocolate Toffee."(10 Tips)
"Eminem cookies snickerdoodles fudge Packers"(2 Tips)
112 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- cookies
- cocoa cayenne
- toffee
- casual
- lively
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Margarita IbrahimDecember 27, 2015Fun little cookie shop, I love how the second you walk in you can smell warm baked cookies :) The walls are definitely fun to look at lol I plan on going back soon :P
Steven WakuuMay 18, 2018Cookies that come in all shapes and sizes. Try their penis on a stick! Good, but nothing spectacular. Tip: Avoid going here on the weekend. There are no lines during the weekday evenings.
Come to The Castro for the nightlife...but stay for the cookies. I can honestly say that the pecan/chocolate chip cookie is the BEST thing that's ever been put in mouth...EVER.- Meghana DharMarch 31, 2014Suprise your friends with the macaroon. Besides that, the cocoa cayenne is great (has a kick), as is the pretzel one and the toffee one
Peanut Butter Milk Chocolate and White Chocolate Macadamia are the winners here. For just a small taste, the mini Almond Butter Cookies are delicious.
PerceptusNovember 1, 2016Not sure why the ratings are so good (except if you get kick out of cookies in genital shape)... I found this to be a disapointment.
@JaumePrimeroAugust 14, 2013you must come here for a warm cookie right out of the oven while you are in SF. A must I'm telling you, a must! :)
Natalie MSeptember 20, 2015So yummy! The cookies are large and hot. Their ice cream is soft serve though not regular ice cream like the sign outside says
Ashley LNovember 12, 2012Crunchy on the outsides and soft in the middle. I like the pokie and white chocolate Mac nut! Sold by the pound- 5 regular cookies cost me $12.95
Adam SchwenkFebruary 5, 2012The cookies are tasty but rich. I can only eat one before I'm stuffed. They're a little on the soft side...I prefer more crispy chocolate chip cookies normally but they are tasty here!
Keenan PattersonSeptember 8, 2014A San Francisco institute. All the cookies are amazing, and it's nearly impossible to pick a favorite. Make it your goal to try them all.
David DyTangMay 1, 2016Stop in for the smell of all the fresh baked cookies, be sure to grab a toffee milk chocolate!
JennyDecember 8, 2014Getting a bunch of yesterday's cookies (3/$2) is a surefire way to make people like you. However, be prepared for the occasional hordes of high schoolers giggling over/Instagramming penis cookies
M Aldoss βApril 2, 2016Yummy Cookies πI recommend Peanut Better with Milk Chocolate Chip and White Chocolate.
Andrew GAugust 14, 2014The cocoa cayenne was really good and the girl working the counter was adorable and funny??? yes to this place
Tim PursellJuly 15, 2015Ignore the obvious cock cookie and try the chipotle chocolate or their coconut macaroons. Yummy.- Rich And Toby MonsterDecember 20, 2015It does Eminem cookies snickerdoodles fudge Packers and yeah...πͺπͺπͺπͺπͺπͺπͺπͺπͺπͺπͺπͺπͺπͺπͺπͺπͺπͺπͺπͺπͺπͺπͺπͺπͺππππππππππππππππππππππππππβ€οΈβ€οΈβ€οΈβ€οΈβ€οΈβ€οΈβ€οΈβ€οΈππΌππΌππππ
KarstenDecember 15, 2014The penis "cookies" (macaroons) are overrated, get the toffee chocolate chip
Amazing cookies! Get the Chocolate Molasses and don't forget some milk!
Small spot with really good cookies. So be quick with the orders and also sober.
Anthony WilliamsMarch 20, 2011The undies they sell are actually women's undies, so for a guy, S=L and so on. We bought some, tried them on in the hotel, called back and exchanged for a bigger size. They tried to act a fool, tho.- California Chip is incredible! Favorite after Cocoa Cayenne and Coconut Macaroons
Get acquainted with the Toffee Milk Chocolate cookie goodness. You're welcome.
Classic destination for out-of-towners...and the cookies are good too.
Kevin SmoklerApril 21, 2015Seems to be better for funny underwear than cookies. I've never found their cookies very good except after midnight.
Lucas GardnerOctober 28, 2019The chocolate chip cookie was delicious...if not in the classic shape. ;)
Daphne GoonOctober 21, 2018Famous in the Castro district. Just a stoneβs throw away from the Castro Theatre.
Tasty tasty hot cookies! And some other genitalia shaped baked treats.
Nicole MaciasJune 6, 2010Love the toffee cookie and the chocolate peanut butter "butch" bars are like crack. Makes a great snack for a movie at Castro theater.
Erin MerchantJanuary 30, 2015Coconut dick macaroons. The thought of eating one making you blush? They have non-dick ones too. Ya puss.
Amy Keiko EnglishSeptember 11, 2009Go to Hot Cookie on Castro and Market. If you like being adventurous, get a Cocoa Cayenne. If you love macaroons and penis, get a chocolate covered penis on a stick. Oh, Castro
Buttercup DJuly 3, 2011Great cookies and a fun bakery! Don't go in here if you're easily offended by penis or boob shaped cookies.- Gal OppenheimerOctober 3, 2011I strongly recommend the Cocoa Cayenne and the White Chocolate Toffee.
433 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Fun and racy experience with exceptionally large selection of freshly baked cookies.
Open until 2:00 AM (Show more)
- MonβFri
- 11:00 AMβ11:00 PM
- SatβSun
- 11:00 AMβ2:00 AM
(415) 621-2350
View menu on https://hotcookiebakery.com/product-category/cookies
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
No
Outdoor Seating
No
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dessert
See More
You might also like
Appears on 194 lists
Created by Joe Bertino
76 items • 14 followers
Created by Joe Bertino
57 items • 47 followers
Created by @JaumePrimero
69 items • 184 followers
