See all
236 photos

Fat Witch Bakery

Bakery$$$$

Chelsea, New York

Save

Fat Witch Bakery

7.9^/10

218

ratings

Ranked #1 for brownies in New York
The experts at The Corcoran Group and Serious Eats recommend this place
"5pm-close is “witching hour” with $1.50 unwrapped brownies"(5 Tips)
"Come after 5pm for their "Witching Hour"- so worth it!!"(4 Tips)
"The pumpkin brownies here are TO DIE FOR."(3 Tips)
"These decadent brownies make great gifts for friends w/ sweet..."(3 Tips)

56 Tips and reviews

Filter:

brownies
witching hour
free samples
family-friendly
s'mores
cake
desserts
coffee
casual
good for a quick meal
caramel
bakeries
chocolate
cherries
gifts
well
lemon
city
town
(14 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Ashley ChanApril 27, 2017
Come after 5pm for their "Witching Hour"- so worth it!! All their large brownies are only $1.5 each. A great way to sample lots of flavors.
Serious EatsOctober 26, 2011
Pumpkin Brownie, the sweet and soft cake is cinnamony and moist, gently spiced. It's more akin to a pumpkin cake with only a whisper of chocolate, than it is to our general understanding of a brownie Read more
Erik CintronOctober 18, 2013
A store dedicated to brownies!!! All different types and even brownie gift baskets. A small store in Chelsea market. A great after dinner snack and just can't have one. right by the high line too.
The Corcoran GroupOctober 31, 2013
The pumpkin brownies here are TO DIE FOR. Trust us - you must stop in and see for yourself. The other brownies are delicious too!
Jenn PAugust 10, 2014
I have never met a brownie here taut I didn't like. They have lemon right now as a flavor of the month and it's so yummy.
Natasha TaylorOctober 9, 2011
Oh yes, I have been coming here for years and it still produces one of the best brownies in New York. Love the original, the snow and the blondie.
Jessica de OliveiraDecember 8, 2015
While the brownie flavor selection is impressive, sometimes simpler is better; definitely go for their classic chocolate.
Jinnie LNovember 18, 2014
gotta try their brownies, best brownies ever!♥ this place is well worth a visit!
COOLHAUSAugust 13, 2012
These decadent brownies make great gifts for friends w/ sweet tooths. Stop by for a free sample and we're sure you won't leave empty handed!
Heejung KimJuly 12, 2015
The original is good but the caramel satisfied my sweet tooth.
Zara KhanAugust 22, 2018
The brownies are divine ! Well balanced, Soft and decadent!
Michael Fox-RabinovitzSeptember 27, 2015
Brownies galore. Plain, caramel and cherry are all great choices.
Get My Grub On! www.getmygrubon.coSeptember 22, 2015
Lobster rolls are okay but small and pricy. Maybe try the humongous whole lobsters instead.
Ghadah AbabtainJune 20, 2019
Good brownies .. I like the brownies ends ! 😍👍🏻
NetsirkJune 6, 2015
Java brownies are delicious!
Valentina De CarloAugust 6, 2015
Brownies which melts like butter in the mouth!
John ADecember 19, 2014
Free samples of decadent brownies... Buy them in singles or multi-packs... Recommend the original.
Yan PMarch 3, 2013
They have smaller cheaper brownies at the counter. Get more types, for less money.
KarenNovember 17, 2019
Overpriced baked goods. But, they’re interesting enough to be maybe worth it, depending on what you’re trying to buy.
Caitlin ClementsFebruary 23, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Go for half price brownies at the "Witching Hour"
Janice LeungSeptember 4, 2013
Witch hour starts at 5:00pm and you can get brownied for $1.5/pc!
Thomas MoAugust 14, 2014
Awesome brownies. But i'd like them to be fudgier.
Bianca EvangelistaOctober 28, 2014
Caramel brownie is definitely a must try!
Kelsey LJanuary 16, 2019
Coffee witch ☕️🍫❤️
Greg KnaussApril 9, 2012
Pumpkin Brownie, the sweet and soft cake is cinnamony and moist, gently spiced.
Kimmie OhhDecember 5, 2019
They have decadent brownies:)
allisonMay 13, 2015
Yummy Brownies!
Gary HorMarch 18, 2013
Yummy brownies! Rich and dense, what more could I ask for?
Sandra VegaSeptember 29, 2017
The brownie were great
Lindsey KimDecember 30, 2014
All open brownies are only $1.50 after 5pm!
HowardMarch 3, 2013
My favorite was the caramel brownie.
Caitlin ClementsJanuary 6, 2018
Been here 10+ times
5pm-close is “witching hour” with $1.50 unwrapped brownies
SusumuDecember 18, 2014
The brownie I've ever tried
Maja DrabczykJune 18, 2015
Caramel brownie... a big wow!!!
Uwvie ObodoAugust 17, 2014
After 5pm unwrapped brownies are only $1.50
Biz TraveldudeNovember 10, 2014
Great name for a bakery in this part of town
BB MadiloggovitAugust 7, 2012
Superb brownie but a bit too sweet for me
Jessie WJuly 18, 2015
BEWITCHING HOURS! $1.50 for unwrapped ones.
Ginny WuJuly 5, 2016
Brownies are the best!
Kelvin ChicoJanuary 26, 2010
the Wicked Witch brownie is my favorite! It's topped with green, sugar crystals.
Elaine ChanOctober 25, 2013
Unwrapped brownies are cheaper after 5!
Alston GreenJune 16, 2015
Been here 100+ times
All there brownies
jessica m. hintermeisterDecember 13, 2011
The Wicked Brownie uses mint chocolate chips to fuel us peppermint addicts
Diego ZambranoAugust 15, 2011
Hands down best brownie I've ever had.
Caitlin ClementsFebruary 10, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Best brownies in the city
Jorge CMOctober 5, 2013
Smores are the best!
Carlos Wavel Chaves FilhoOctober 18, 2010
The brownies are just perfectly delicious.
Shirley LiuMarch 11, 2018
Brownies galore!
Pepe TajaMarch 11, 2013
Best brownies ever!!!
kate wangMarch 23, 2011
Unwrapped brownies are $1.50 after 5pm!

1 2

236 Photos

Fat Witch Bakery

Related Searches

Other places inside Chelsea Market

You might also like

Places people like to go after Fat Witch Bakery

Appears on 247 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.