See all
108 photos

The Amish Market

Grocery Store and Food and Beverage Retail

Turtle Bay, New York

Save

The Amish Market

8.1^/10

296

ratings

Ranked #5 for a buffet in New York
"Best salad bar in the city"(8 Tips)
"Best coffee AND made to order brick oven pizza"(4 Tips)
"The breakfast buffet is the best value for breakfast in the area!"(10 Tips)
"And the beet salad in the cold bar is delicious."(2 Tips)

75 Tips and reviews

Filter:

sandwiches
buffet
coffee
salads
healthy food
delis
breakfast food
cake
yogurt
quinoa
meats
spinach
lunch
cheese
fresh food
soup
market
vegetables
bar
city
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

The Corcoran GroupAugust 29, 2011
One of our favorite markets in the city, but also a great take-out lunch place with yummy sandwiches – try the Fresh Turkey with Brie. Coffee is top notch too!
Karina Mireles GzaNovember 2, 2013
Its a great market! Looks small on the outside but you will be surprise how big it is once you are in, perfect place I did many organic and healthy food, amazing salads !
ZenFoodsterFebruary 3, 2014
My pepperoni & mushroom pie was greasy & salty. Altho' I like their tomato sauce, overpowered by overly marinated 'shrooms. $12's still value 4 freshly made 14" pie & def better than Domino's.
Jose Antonio Lopez ArquelladasJanuary 2, 2012
A good market with fresh food bakery and lot of special bio product. Have good selection of olives and they have Olive oil from Huelma-Jaen (Spain) aKa. the best one and Ines Rosales!! :-P
Luz AndujarAugust 21, 2012
Can't leave the place without going to the salad bar. The roasted vegetables are delicious. The brick oven pizzas and the mozarella, basil and portobello mushroom sandwich a must!
paiJuly 25, 2014
Good breakfast buffet choices + they're not dried out like Café Olympia around the corner. Yummy turkey bacon! Hash browns!
Kelly AhearnJanuary 12, 2016
Best sauerkraut ever!!!! Great place to find some different style yogurt too- a probiotic and dietitians dream;)
Katya PugachevaSeptember 12, 2014
Nice selection of cheese and veggies, decent buffet for breakfast or lunch, including coffee and pastries.
Willy DantasSeptember 1, 2013
I love this place! Good food from all the world...to drink a coffee with a cake's slice in front of.
Olessya KuzFebruary 22, 2012
Fantastic salad and hot food bar. Fresh and ridiculously cheap. Delicious healthy lunch for under $7 in midtown? Yes, please!
Meg TownerOctober 21, 2013
Great pasta options here on the hot bar. Made to order pizza and sandwiches too!
Maria R.February 17, 2011
The salad bar is hidden away in the corner, but try the sundried tomatoe vinegar on your salad. The crouton's are fresh and delicious too.
Filip F.December 10, 2017
Wide cheese and cold cuts selection. Hot buffet for reasonable price.
DanielJuly 16, 2012
Best brick oven thin crust pizzas in midtown east , also 10 dollar whole rotisserie chickens !!!
KarenJuly 16, 2019
Fresh fruit and vegetables. Less pricey than you'll see elsewhere in Manhattan.
Ryan AmbsAugust 28, 2015
Spaniard sandwich good not great. Huge list of options means I'll go back and try some more.
Grace KijjaroenvisalMarch 21, 2017
Been here 5+ times
It's a grocery store with a deli and their pies are so good.
Kelsey✨February 26, 2019
Decent salad bar, but it can get a bit crowded during the lunchtime rush
Ryan LaffertySeptember 12, 2012
Been here 10+ times
The cold buffet is great for lunch. Try the special chicken salad and the quinoa
Deborah SchmidtNovember 4, 2016
Been here 100+ times
The custom salads are great, and the best price in the area by far!
Faryan ASeptember 7, 2015
Pro tip: hot bar = ~1/2 the cost of dishes, 2/3 the quality.
Lauren MelcherApril 7, 2012
Tomato cheddar soup! So good. And the beet salad in the cold bar is delicious.
Majed AlashariNovember 18, 2017
Nice shop where you can find all your needs
Joe DAugust 19, 2015
The Russian dressing in their sandwiches is amazing. Try one with it!
Natalie MiyakeSeptember 2, 2012
Been here 50+ times
Great salad bar - wide variety and lots of cooked vegetable and protein options.
Nina ZhangDecember 21, 2012
Can't go wrong with any of the sandwiches toasted. Parisienne is my winning choice.
Linda MiklowitzJune 5, 2016
Been here 5+ times
Deli, hot & cold bars, coffee bar, pizza bar
Dr. Jenn (Wynestainedlips)November 3, 2011
Been here 5+ times
Amazing salad bar!!! Coffee Lovers: Get a Vanilla Nut coffee w/ steamed cream. You're welcome.
TimelessnomadMay 3, 2013
Neat market that is pretty big. Ill have to come back and explore more.
SaifSeptember 22, 2013
This market got everything that u need!! Organic and Fresh
BexJanuary 2, 2012
Been here 10+ times
All sandwiches are great, especially the Italian which has 4-5 freshly sliced meat including Prosciutto and Sopressata
Lili BazJune 18, 2019
Good salad special. $8 (4 toppings + protein)
Marcin KucJune 16, 2012
If you like brick oven pizza, Bianca Spinaca Pizza is a must!
Linda MiklowitzApril 4, 2014
Been here 5+ times
I don't think I saw any Amish. Why the name? Wonderful hot & cold buffet, deli and supermarket.
Michael RiderJanuary 12, 2012
The breakfast buffet is the best value for breakfast in the area!
Boberto PatricioOctober 18, 2012
Been here 25+ times
The $6 sandwiches near the sushi are quite the deal
Sara YMay 4, 2016
Been here 25+ times
Amazing selection of imported delicacies.
Ian AndersonApril 14, 2018
Fantastic range of fresh food
Matthew KennedyJuly 17, 2012
BEST BEST BEST store on the East side Midtown for anything. Just GO.
Jacob KNovember 30, 2011
Best produce and meats/cheeses around. Heard the pizza is good too
Joshua JavierAugust 20, 2014
Coffee decent. They warm up the milk which is nice
Shelley YangApril 26, 2011
Been here 5+ times
Look for the free baskets of bread in the soup and salad area! Grab as much as u want if ure shameless.
Sara YApril 15, 2016
Been here 25+ times
Such a nice alternative to the shitty grocery stores nearby.
Sara YApril 26, 2016
Been here 25+ times
Love the sandwiches from the deli counter.
paiNovember 20, 2011
The UN one has an AMAZING international cheese section!
Lauren SteinJanuary 9, 2012
Been here 10+ times
Best coffee AND made to order brick oven pizza
Thiago LinsAugust 14, 2012
Been here 50+ times
The brick oven pizza is very underrated.
Kristin HaranAugust 29, 2012
Best place on Earth. Beats the North Pole and Disney world.
John Saeyong RaJuly 10, 2011
Go find the salad bar and hot buffet - great fish selection!
Andres RipollMarch 28, 2012
Been here 5+ times
Try the "dominican cake". Reaaaaally good.

1 2

108 Photos

The Amish Market

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after The Amish Market

Appears on 186 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.