Eleni's New York
(Now Closed)Dessert Shop, Cupcake Shop, and Candy Store$$$$
Chelsea, New York
The folks at Food Network and Serious Eats like this place. Would you agree?
50 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Elizabeth LeeOctober 24, 2016Their cookies are so tasty and in such varied flavours - great for gifts. I recommend the butterscotch and ginger snap cookies. The bakery is also nut free.
Harumi USeptember 20, 2014Sugar cookies decorated with every inch of imagination they have. At the moment store is full of Halloween cookies. Don't leave the shop without having some tasting
The Corcoran GroupFebruary 25, 2011Stop in a gawk at all the beautiful cakes on display and have a free sample cookie. Great place to order event specific baked good – like their Oscar Cupcakes!
Overlooking Eleni's New York is something done at your own peril. Cookies & cakes galore if one wishes to take up the venue's goodies, despite the expense, it's worth every penny.
Jess OzJuly 2, 2015Amazing hand-iced cookies. Also do custom cookie designs. They put photos on cupcakes too - always a hit when I take them to parties
Serious EatsDecember 13, 2013The decorated sugar cookies at Eleni's come in every conceivable shape and style (and actually taste good to boot).
Food NetworkAugust 8, 2011Sandra Lee, of Food Network's The Best Thing I Ever Ate, recommends the classic cookie company, Eleni's for their cupcakes and artistically decorated sugar cookies. Find more tips at FN Local. Read more
Lyn HastingsJanuary 12, 2014Eleni's location across from the Chelsea Wine vault is a dream combination. "Too pretty to eat" is taken to a whole new level.
Nicole M TuckerAugust 30, 2011One of the best cupcake bakeries! Their products are moist, flavorful cake and the perfect balance of sweetness in the icing. 100 TIMES better than Magnolia! Read more
I AmosMay 5, 2013This place looks like a sugar-coated hellmouth, but the cupcakes are above average overall and certainly the best I've found within Chelsea Market.
ToshieApril 11, 2014The flourless chocolate cupcake with cream cheese frosting is something out of this world!
Halstead PropertyDecember 3, 2012Whether you’re indulging in treats for Hanukkah or Christmas, this is a holiday dessert paradise. Try the “Christmas Diva” cookie, or the “Dreidel Dreidel Chocolate Chip Gift Tin”
New York HabitatApril 23, 2012If you visit the Chelsea Markets DON'T forget to stop at Eleni's to try one of the gorgeous cupcakes they make! It's a real treat! :-)
Cupcake CrusadersApril 20, 2012We've only tried the Boston Cream and the Raspberry Raspberry and both were AMAZING! Can't wait to visit again!
Neringa DaJanuary 26, 2013Oh My Cupcake! Forget all the bakeries in the markets and go straight for this shop, can't go wrong.
Collette SNovember 17, 2015Cupcake happy hour from 6-8pm! 40% off baked goods. Delicious, but even better during HH!
Inside New YorkMarch 22, 2012Buy one get one free cupcakes 7-8 PM Monday through Friday and 6-7 PM Saturday and Sunday!
Roberta ArcoverdeApril 14, 2012I dont really care for the cookies; they're beautiful, but thats all. The red velvet cupcake, however, is fabulous!
S COctober 23, 2011Although they are known for their incredible cookies, don't overlook their very tasty cupcakes.
Meagan KirkpatrickAugust 4, 2010Love this place - the cookies, the experience, everything about it. Especially the day after holidays when everything is half off...
Gilt CityDecember 12, 2011Eleni’s has a themed cookie for every occasion. For “Twilight” fans, they’re selling edible “Team Jacob” t-shirts.
You can personalize with a quick turnaround and delivery anywhere in the US.
Pick a cookie any cookie - you can't go wrong. It's a total sugar rush - I go daily. I need help.
Great chocolate chip cookies, the chips just melt as you eat them.
Caitlin ClementsFebruary 10, 2013They do amazing (but PRICEY) themed cookies for the Oscars and Tony Awards.
Paige CMay 9, 2011Everything tastes good, but is SO expensive. A box of cookies was $65. No amount of sugar could make me spend that much.
Laurel ToubyMarch 3, 2010I am truly addicted to the cookies here. Typically, the better decorated cookies look, the worst they taste. Eleni's actually are delicious.
K. SchneiderOctober 4, 2011Sorry bit Oreo Madness cupcake was dry. Wouldn't make it on Cupcake Wars!
282 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Eleni's Chelsea Market store offers their signature "playfully unique" cookies, cupcakes, and artisan candies that vary from season to season. They also frequently open their doors to corporate tours, in-store parties and more. Their bakery is certified OU Kosher, and they are completely nut-free!
(888) 435-3647
Features
Credit Cards
Yes
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Parking
Street
Food & Drink
Menus
Dessert, Happy Hour
See More
Other places inside Chelsea Market
You might also like
- 8.4
"Delicious to-go Japanese dessert shop from mochi to icecream."
Netsirk - 8.6
"So many wonderful cakes! You must try the layered crepe-style cake in lemon or matcha flavors, but pretty much anything here will cure your sweet tooth."
Julie Soscia - 8.5
"Such an amazing place, had the hardest time deciding what to get there were so many options!! Decided to get the toasted marshmallow ice cream it was a unique amazing unforgettable flavor thatI loved!"
Gentiana
Appears on 118 lists
Created by Cupcakes Take The Cake
44 items • 106 followers
Created by Jessica Shim
121 items • 59 followers
Created by Colleen Sullivan
63 items • 54 followers
