Olive Garden
(Now Closed)Italian Restaurant$$$$
Flatiron District, New York
92 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
J CrowleyAugust 13, 2015Here for lunch? Go splitty splitty with a friend on the chicken parm with fries and pasta Alfredo. Then dip your fries in the Alfredo sauce for ultimate fat kid points.
Mariana PantalenaOctober 18, 2015I live the shrimp Alfredo! It's great and huge portion. Two people can eat it. The melon, kiwi lemonade is very tasty and you should also order a wine glass of chianti!- J CrowleyAugust 13, 2015The Alfredo sauce for the breadsticks is (surprisingly) different and better than the Alfredo on the pasta. So if you get the pasta, ask for the breadstick Alfredo sauce on the side!
Ashley VelazquezMarch 29, 2014I always prefer to come here over the one at Times Square because there is NEVER a wait for a table. Wine? Try the Moscato Castello or Roscato! Love the wait staff here :)
Allison ThorntonOctober 5, 2011great pig-out pasta place. good share-worthy apps. vegetarians welcome. friendly staff. private door bathroom stalls. they always get me with the 'would you like to sample a wine?' thing. YES i would.
DietsInReviewApril 19, 2011The list of pasta dishes can be overwhelming. Start with a whole grain noodle. Cream sauces will also add up quickly in the calorie and fat count, but a marinara sauce brings that down significantly
Rachelle JaniceSeptember 2, 2013You have to try the sampler: fried calamari, chicken tenders and friend mozzarella. To die for! :-)
OctaneAugust 7, 2014Don't sit by the window if you're on a date because dozen of stunning women walk by here every hour.
Jess HannOctober 17, 2014My best friend and her husband bought the "unlimited pasta," cards so I've been tagging along. The $9 quartinos of wine are actually drinkable!
Caitlin CaldwellSeptember 10, 2011Lindsey, the weird waitress...stickler for the rules when it comes to unlimited pasta...what is she the alfredo queen! But she is pleasantly quirky. Request her!
The food isn't what it is at other OGs...portions are smaller and the food is served messily. Still good, but don't expect the presentation and portions you get at other Olive Gardens.
Thiru Selvan SathiamoorthyApril 6, 2012If you are getting the 6.95 lunch spl. Make sure to stuff up with salad/soup! The main dish is tiny!!
Tamara HFebruary 15, 2013Order the magnum (subtext: GIANT) bottle of wine (you can take it home if don't finish it).
Service here is good. I can never finish my plate though, the portions are huge
Steven LehrburgerDecember 10, 2010If you go for lunch with a dozen people, they'll probably split your table, and your food comes in LIFO not FIFO order... the lemons for our water were the last to arrive :P
Jonathan RomanMay 16, 2014Spaghetti with meat balls !!! Also ask for the breadsticks they're delicious.
Brendan LewisJune 5, 2015I can't believe I'm about to say this: the Lasagna Frittata is actually good
Dee MyaAugust 31, 2010every time i go there i come out feeling stuffed beyond belief, everything is so good u cant stop eating.. not a fan of gettin full from the salad b4 food gets there, if i wanted salad id go elsewhere
KyleAugust 27, 20108.26.10 they don't advertise it, but the unlimited pasta bowl is going on right now! Ask your server about it. Any pasta any sauce for only $8.95 with unlimited refills.
Madison WrightJuly 27, 2012Soup, salad, and breadsticks lunch special is $8.95 in the city. Still a deal??- 陳雄暉 弟兄October 5, 2014Long wait for large groups, even with an advanced reservation. But once seated, service was clockwork. Chef even came out to greet us. 🍝
The people who work here are Great!!!!!! Tip them well, which is 20%( OR MORE) not the included 15% grat! We only make $5.00 an hour and after taxes take comes out to um... Nothing!!!!!!!
Doreen EckertFebruary 12, 2011Such a great surprise! Good service. Gorganzola shrimp ravioli were yummy
Norman EllisAugust 30, 2015First time ever in an Olive Garden and I don't get the hype. The famous breadsticks were unremarkable as was the salad. Maybe they had an off night.
The Capellini Pomodoro is filling, not heavy & tasty. Give it a try.
Anna FrenkelDecember 21, 2012Treat yourself to the fettuccine alfredo paired with a refreshing pinot grigio.
Ryan WilliamsAugust 19, 2012Ask for the never-ending pasta bowl. They will not give you the menu for it unless you ask.
Don't forget to tip your To-Go Specialist--he's great!
Anita CriolloNovember 10, 2015I don't know what bread sticks are supposed to taste like but these taste like salty play dough. I would not recommend the bread sticks.
Esther LeibelOctober 12, 2010Servers are really nice, but the best food you can have here is the salad :-(
310 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Olive Garden
696 Avenue Of The Americas (btwn 22nd & 23rd)
New York, NY 10010
United States
New York, NY 10010
United States
Olive Garden offers a variety of delicious Italian specialties for lunch, dinner or take out. Enjoy our freshly baked garlic breadsticks and your choice of homemade soup or salad with any entree.
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Thu, Sun
- 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 11:00 AM–11:00 PM
(212) 255-1240
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
Drinks
Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Olive Garden
- 8.9
"The best TJ in the city. All one floor. Good coffee & munchies like pizzas on offer always. Find the fresh produce here better than other TJ's, also wider variety."
Sameepa Shetty - 6.0
"Check out open box items! Usually really good deals on products that are in excellent condition."
Albert Tong - 7.6
"For me the best bar gay in NYC, I come to New York once a year and I can always now that Andre will remember me and greet me like home far away from home"
Antonio Luiz
Appears on 41 lists
Flatiron Schmancy Sitdown Lunches
Created by J Baxter
62 items • 13 followers
