Sarabeth's Bakery
Bakery, Coffee Shop, and Café$$$$
Chelsea, New York
"Pain du Matin and a large latte...perfection."(3 Tips)
"the blueberry scone is probably the best in ny."(6 Tips)
"Get the chocolate pudding!"(2 Tips)
"Best Creme Brûlée I've ever had outside of Belgium!"(4 Tips)
50 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- pastries
- pain du matin
- scones
- breakfast food
- cookies
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Ina LiMarch 2, 2016Fresh, filling and super delicious. Try: pain du matin, ginger pecan tart, and most definitely their raisin scone! (Maybe better biscuit too?)
Heejung KimJuly 10, 2015Their breakfast muffin was very filling. I love cornbread and i love eggs and it was a good combination of the two. Yum!
Rick NijhuisNovember 17, 2016Hardly any place to sit down, but don't let that hold you back from ordering their delicious lemon ricotta pancakes,
John BarnhamDecember 28, 2015With so much to choose from in Chelsea market, I'm sad we chose here. Had a little cherry pie and it was far too sweet. Grumpy staff too
Conor KellyMarch 9, 2014A bit pricey and the staff chats up their friends loudly, forgetting to take your order. The crem brûlée is waaaay overrated--it's really not that good. Still, cozy place for coffee after a meal.
marcy stoneNovember 7, 2013The morning muffin has a full hard boiled egg baked inside and rhe muffin is delicious.
John LeVineJune 18, 2012For breakfast: get a scrambled egg sandwich on a croissant with cheese and an iced coffee with whole milk. A perfect start to the day
- abbyJuly 18, 2011the blueberry scone is probably the best in ny. i'd pass on the goat cheese and spinach omelette
Homi HomaidDecember 31, 2021below average. French toast was not ordered but it’s put on our table. was bad quality w/ very strong egg taste/smell. couldn't complete 2 bites. Sourdough bread in there is just regular toast!!
Neringa DaJanuary 26, 2013Pretty good interpretation of apple crumble. Would be even better if they offered to warm it up.
Sibel AkcekayaJanuary 17, 2018Standard croissant does not have sugar in it , but their croissant contains sugar..not good
SarahbethOctober 11, 2011I love Sarabeth's hazelnut coffee... also it doesn't hurt that I have the same name as this place! :)
Smoked Mozzarella sandwiches on the counter include smoked mozz, avocado, tomato, and other tastiness. Kinda pricey at $6.75, but worth it!
AmateurConciergeNovember 18, 2017Poorly run, coffee is barely passable. Only bright spot is the jars of jam for sale
Lauren HansenJune 28, 2015This place sucks, they screwed up my (uncomplicated) order twice in a row and their scrambled egg sandwiches are dry and have no taste.
Chloe BrownsteinMay 25, 2011Probably the worst service in the entirety of Chelsea Market. Pretty depressing!
239 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Located in Chelsea Market, this location features cafe style seating and amazing baked goods.
Open until 8:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Sat
- 8:00 AM–8:00 PM
- Sun
- 9:00 AM–7:00 PM
(212) 989-2424
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes
Wi-Fi
No
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Breakfast, Lunch, Dessert
See More
Other places inside Chelsea Market
- 9.1
"Absolutely love the food and friendly staff at the sushi counter. Killer Salmon belly. If you're a regular, check out their loyalty program (info at the register) to get 10% back."
Brad L
- 9.2
"Really good chicken and steak tacos, horchata, and chips and guacamole"
Elizabeth Burstein - 8.0
"Absolutely the best espresso I've ever had. Skip the coffee and go with a macchiato or a cappuccino. You won't regret it."
matthew anderson
You might also like
- 8.0
"Devil's Food Chocolate Cake is the best chocolate cake ever made by man. I've tried chocolate cakes at so many other bakeries, and in many other cities, but this one still reigns supreme."
Reagan Barbosa - 7.9
"Come after 5pm for their "Witching Hour"- so worth it!! All their large brownies are only $1.5 each. A great way to sample lots of flavors."
Ashley Chan - 8.4
"Try the delicious Gâteau aux Marrons which is an almond cake layered with a whipped cream, iced with chestnut-infused cream and topped with walnuts."
Luca DL
Places people like to go after Sarabeth's Bakery
- 9.5
"Gorgeous place to walk in NYC. Go early or late to avoid the crowds and you’ll have a wonderful experience 🌳 🏙"
Jon Moore - 9.2
"Lobster rolls are on point here. Great options."
Jonah Engler
- 8.8
"A beautiful little park amongst the governmental and financial buildings, City Park is a great place to bring a packed lunch, and sit around the fountain, surrounded by old timey oil lit lanterns."
ArtNerdNewYork
Appears on 162 lists
NYC: Favorite coffee shops, bakeries & food trucks
Created by K-Þórır D.
27 items • 18 followers
Created by Tomoya Kuramochi
199 items • 12 followers
Created by Jeffrey Zeldman
296 items • 111 followers
