See all
142 photos

Make My Cake

(Now Closed)

Bakery$$$$

Central Harlem, New York

Save

Make My Cake

73 Tips and reviews

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Alexandra MaesenOctober 1, 2014
At my previous job, we made them custom design our Event Cakes. They can actually print your picture on a cake. Besides delicious fillings, cake by cake a true masterpiece! Down for double chocolate!
Harlem AmbassadorMarch 28, 2013
The cakes and pies here will put your grandparents and great aunts out of business. The cafe is large and roomy, which allows the traffic to flow. Ask for pumpkin cheesecake and you'll be hooked.
Col MerschbachApril 18, 2013
The desserts are tasty but very, very sweet. Sugar is the star in this bakery. The baked goods are beautiful here, flawless. Free wifi and tasty coffee makes it a great place to go each day.
TYreeJune 3, 2015
Wow very beautiful intimate little shop, with great selection of specialty baked goods, cards and novelties
Sexy LFOctober 27, 2014
Been here 10+ times
This is the one and only place you should purchase buttercream frosting cake in Harlem. Only here. Get it by the slice and thank me later. Sorry but the cupcakes don't have enough frosting for me.
S EJuly 27, 2015
A little pricey but the cake was awesome. I bought a half red velvet/half yellow cake and my co-workers loved it.
Sara 🌈⚔🍾October 1, 2014
Yummy! The red velvet is so moist and I also love the lemon frosted. Each cupcake is huge- good for sharing!
Kassaundra G-TAugust 2, 2012
Been here 10+ times
Really great iced coffee, not cheap, but always better to support locally owned verses Starbucks. Don't think their cakes are THAT great, but I do like their chocolate moose cups.
TYreeJune 3, 2015
The sweet potato cheesecake was lite, tasty and resonably priced for the portion.
darnisha bishopJanuary 12, 2016
Such a cute little gem in Harlem. Looking for a coffee or a quick treat? This is the place.
A. Kenyatta ParksFebruary 18, 2013
The owner is nice. Staff is wonderful. The desserts are delicious and sinful.
TheMobileBrokerNovember 28, 2015
Been here 5+ times
Fresh pastries and deep dish cakes made to order! I've always had a good experience!
Sam McCrimsonSeptember 27, 2014
Very underwhelming cake. I was expecting a bit more from a place recommended for lunch dessert by Liz Lemon in 30 Rock. Perhaps it was merely a bad batch but #IdoNOTwanttogotothere
Cheryl YBRJuly 25, 2010
They make the best Buttercream cake I have every had. Love it! And their Red Velvet is to die for! Save you Weight Watcher flex points for this - it's worth it!
The Corcoran GroupMay 10, 2010
Family-run bakery known for colorful, customized birthday & wedding cakes. The layer cake will make you call when birthday time comes around - half a slice just might be enough. Read more
Abiola AbramsApril 22, 2012
Think Soup Nazi like on Seinfeld but with cupcakes. Delish though for us sugar addicts. Unkind on the waistline... But we've gotta live, right? :-)
Meg MandibleAugust 23, 2013
Normally I don't like cream cheese on the red velevet cupcakes, but this was delish!!!!!! For once the hype was true!!!
David ZhangMarch 30, 2013
One of the places Tina Fey mentions as her favorite cupcake places in NYC on 30 rock. Go with the red velvet
TYreeJune 3, 2015
The selections are varied and we'll priced for excellent portions
Meagan LongAugust 5, 2014
FYI: Came here this morning because the hours on the website said open at 8 am. They were closed and I was informed that they have changed the store hours.
TheMobileBrokerApril 11, 2012
Been here 5+ times
Fresh pastries and deep dish cakes made to order! Worth every penny!
Tameka GDecember 28, 2012
They're famous for their red velvet, but their buttercream is also amaaaazing
Junior GarciaMay 29, 2013
Hey &Y'all the Red Velvet cup cake is one of the best I have tried.
NataliOctober 27, 2012
Been here 5+ times
Love this place, amazing red velvet cupcakes and pretty darn good coffee
Roger SchonfeldDecember 28, 2014
Like this place very much. Wish their coffee was one tier higher.
TYreeJune 3, 2015
Very intimate and casual
Anthony ChoulouteMay 19, 2014
The sweet potato cheesecake is very good.
Hatu KanuFebruary 16, 2015
Cupcakes are really good
Rike PoMay 10, 2016
Great cupcakes and Cookies!!!
ConcepcionSeptember 29, 2012
$10 minimum for credit/debit cards. Cupcakes are good. Typical buttercreamy goodness.
Tariq AhmadApril 30, 2017
Get the Red Velvet cake.
Henry-Daniel KouameAugust 1, 2013
Hummmmm yummyyyyyy. Love this place for their red velvet....
Kamal JonesMay 11, 2016
Best Red Velvet cake on Planet!
David V.June 22, 2013
Been here 5+ times
The blueberry cobbler is fantastic!
S LadyMay 13, 2013
Delish cookies!!! Love the red velvet cake!
Youshin SongApril 26, 2014
Get a slice of the red velvet cake!
amrigJuly 17, 2016
Apple turnovers are randomly my favorite thing.
Yanzy BearSeptember 13, 2015
Need to puty order in. So love their cakes
Nikki ZimmermannAugust 12, 2017
Yummy butter cream frosting!
Percy HolmesJuly 16, 2017
Incredible!!
Percy HolmesJuly 16, 2017
Incredible!!
Michael PaulinoMarch 11, 2012
The Sweet Potato Cheesecake is a masterpiece
Romain TyackApril 9, 2016
Chai tea and a cupcake!
Raena WilliamsFebruary 9, 2012
Must order sweet potato cheesecake!!!
TYreeJune 3, 2015
Nice location
D BJuly 20, 2013
Red velvet cupcake was amazing.
Bella FonteFebruary 4, 2016
So tasty...
Myles C.August 2, 2010
Buying a cupcake here felt like asking for a Budweiser at a posh bar in soho. Customer service needs work.
Tariq AhmadDecember 20, 2011
Get the Red Velvet slice of cake.
Henry-Daniel KouameJuly 24, 2013
Love the red velvet.

1 2

142 Photos

Make My Cake

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Make My Cake

Appears on 105 lists

Is this your business? Claim it now.