See all
371 photos

Rick's Cafe Boatyard

Seafood Restaurant$$$$

Eagle Creek, Indianapolis

Save

8.8^/10

293

ratings

Ranked #8 for seafood restaurants in Indianapolis
"The rico dip also, was amazing."(3 Tips)
"Beautiful view, specially around sunset."(12 Tips)
"The oysters here are fabulous!"(5 Tips)
"... cocktail and the key lime pie. You'll thank me"(2 Tips)

71 Tips and reviews

Filter:

seafood
scenic views
good for dates
rico dip
good for groups
healthy food
trendy
desserts
pork tenderloin
spacious
gumbo
cake
Reuben sandwiches
chicken teriyaki
casual
brunch food
pies
dinner
bar
coffee
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Gene ParsleyAugust 5, 2018
They have a great menu and the food tasted very good. It's an awesome place for a wedding or any other event. The staff is great and the restaurant is very clean.
Upvoted Feb 24
Amanda SmithJuly 29, 2017
It was awesome! We sat outside on a perfect Saturday night and got the Salmon Rousille and Rainbow Trout. Cleared the plates!
Upvoted 1 day ago
SusanFebruary 19, 2019
PowderpuffPersians.com loves this place great oysters on the half shell. Yummy seafood. Great service. Nice location on the lake. Patty atmosphere in the summer😉
Ree GtzJune 19, 2023
Excellent for our first time. Love the FOOD and the exceptional customer SRVC. OMG! The drinks were on point to go with the beautiful sunset atmosphere. We will definitely see you later, Rick.
Paul LarsonApril 4, 2019
Amazing mahi-mahi! Flakey and delicious and a beautiful presentation.
QZ SmithFebruary 20, 2018
Been here 25+ times
Great customer service! Always friendly and helpful! Clean restaurant! Excellent service! GREAT VIEWS!
Douglas MeisselApril 26, 2022
The food was lackluster and pricy, the atmosphere was loud and even the children complained on how loud the outdoor space next to the bar was. I have definitely eaten at better places on the water.
Rory ParnessApril 8, 2021
Nice outdoor seating right on the water. Start with some oysters and gumbo and then splurge for the double lobster tails
Qahhar IslamJune 28, 2012
It's a great weekend spot. Great food and staff. The deck wraps around for an outstanding view to share at sunset with the special person.
PJ SteeleApril 1, 2016
Been here 50+ times
Seafood is wonderful! Mud pie is the best!!
Ebin FordJune 30, 2012
The pasta could use a little more cheese. Other than that it was great!!! The rico dip also, was amazing.
QZ SmithFebruary 20, 2018
Been here 25+ times
Seafood is wonderful and tasty here! Views are amazing!
CS_just_CSAugust 17, 2015
Been here 5+ times
Moscow mule and several other varieties. Try the Caribbean Mule!
Patrick HarveyJuly 28, 2012
Been here 25+ times
Ricks catering is the BEST!!! Order the shrimp cocktail and the key lime pie. You'll thank me
Ryan DillmanMarch 23, 2012
Go here in warm weather and sit outside for a great view of the water and the sailboats.
Paula HenryMay 10, 2011
Best Calamari I have ever had. Always a nice escape for a weekday lunch with views of Eagle Creek.
Steven ParrettJanuary 31, 2013
Amazing calimari....they were as so thick! Awesome food and great service!
DavidDecember 9, 2016
Been here 5+ times
Our service (for a party of 8) was excellent.
Kip FultonJune 10, 2018
Been here 5+ times
Seafood is great here crab lobster shrimp
Mike KivettAugust 5, 2012
Been here 5+ times
#1 place in Indy for a fun night out. Great food and drinks on the deck overlooking Eagle Creek.
Bryan LeniskiJune 24, 2023
Had the short rib grilled cheese for lunch and some waterside brews
Deborah FrancoSeptember 21, 2018
The food was delicious. The service was great. The bar drinks were just okay.
Indy Boot CampsOctober 30, 2012
Been here 25+ times
Couldn't find any local beer! Support local microbrews!!!!
Wendy ReedDecember 31, 2014
On Tuesday nights there is a good singer in the bar .
Ricky PottsMay 12, 2012
Grab a seat in the bar while you wait for your table.
Jen SOctober 19, 2012
The steak with blue cheese butter salad is awesome!!!!
Carol RamosAugust 13, 2016
Awesome service great atmosphere and food is delicious
Wendy ReedSeptember 6, 2014
The oysters here are fabulous! Try them Provence style. Nom nom nom
Raneem KattanOctober 6, 2015
Beautiful view, specially around sunset. The food was good but nothing special
Carie JonesAugust 1, 2011
The key lime pie's excellence was superseded only by Jodi's service!
Krystal MichaelisJune 20, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Great service! Great view. It's my birthday!
Reggie BNovember 12, 2014
Been here 10+ times
Blackened chicken Ceasars salad. That's all that I every eat here.
Dana ParkerApril 15, 2016
Great dessert
Rachel HarrellOctober 10, 2011
Been here 25+ times
Request Rach H. If you tip BIG. Request Grey if you don't tip at all!! :p
Josh KannianenApril 10, 2012
If you aren't a fan of spicy food, skip the Szechuan sauce on anything.
Mary PohlmannMay 13, 2013
The oysters Rockefeller are very good.
StefanoAugust 29, 2012
Death by chocolate: the best dessert i ever had in Indiana
Carolle GriffinApril 15, 2018
Best Bartender!!! #Scotty 👊🏽
Paula BrownJune 21, 2013
Great view. Awesome food and service.
Cecilia H.August 2, 2016
Amazing sunset view.
Carol RamosAugust 13, 2016
Service is excellent food comes fast
Susie H.April 4, 2012
Been here 10+ times
Lunch time hostess was rude when we asked for different table with water view. It's why we come here!
Meg RichmondOctober 18, 2013
We heard this was a nice restaurant but the "Cougar Bait" & "Cougar in Training" shirts made it more like Hooters for baby boomers. Gross. The food is mediocre. At least our server was sweet.
Jon BrewerJune 2, 2010
Great food! Great view and location. Good beers on hand too.
Chris StringfellowFebruary 28, 2012
Been here 100+ times
Teriyaki chicken is a great deal! Get it too share!
Brian ReinhardSeptember 20, 2013
Cab cakes are the best in Indiana
J. Todd CampiJune 3, 2012
Grouper reuben is outstanding!
Yajaira HempelDecember 13, 2013
Eat the black bean soup. yummy
John ZupancicMay 28, 2012
Been here 25+ times
Get the oysters on the half shell.
LaceyDecember 24, 2012
Get their stuffed French toast or breakfast pizza.

1 2

371 Photos

Rick's Cafe Boatyard

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Rick's Cafe Boatyard

Appears on 42 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.