Paradise Bakery & Cafe
(Now Closed)Bakery, Coffee Shop, and Sandwich Spot$$$$
Castleton, Indianapolis
36 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Owned by the Panera Bread Co, meal menu is now nearly the same! Ambiance and space are nicer, and you still get a cookie with your sandwich. Baked goods are less in quantity now.
Alanna Alboher-rayApril 27, 2012Try the bacon turkey bravo and tomato soup! Its My favorite. Love the sause on the sandwich and the cheese!
You don't have to get a chocolate chip cookie as the free cookie with your entree; you can select from any of their cookies.
Broccoli soup and avocado turkey sand is the bomb. Add Gouda cheese!
The Fire Roasted Tomato Soup + Sourdough Grilled Cheese is the best "comfort food" lunch!!
Talk to Tiana. Her smile will make your day! What a super nice person!!
Ryan DillmanMarch 23, 2012Sandwiches all come with a chocolate chip cookie unless you ask for something else when you order or checkout.
There is no better cookie on the planet than a Paradise Cafe cookie. Fact.
Mason GrayAugust 16, 2011Waited for a long time to place a order while staff stood around. All the tables hadn't been cleaned after lunch rush. And to top it off, I found HAIR IN MY SANDWICH!
CharminApril 23, 2014Uhm...this is pretty much a Panera. Rebranded or Copied but different in name only
Joe ShoemakerNovember 22, 2009Substitute balsamic vinaigrette for the regular dressing on the Crumbly Bleu Cheese salad.
37 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Paradise Bakery & Cafe
8540 Castleton Corner Dr (at 86th & Allisonville)
Indianapolis, IN 46250
United States
Indianapolis, IN 46250
United States
Freshly Prepared Sandwiches, Salad, Soups, Coffee
& Baked Goods
(317) 570-0300
Features
Credit Cards
Yes
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch
See More
You might also like
- 6.1
"Great place to grab a quick bite! Love the jalapeño cheddar bagel, triple berry muffin and the apples, cranberries & blue cheese salad. Great spot to people watch on Monument Circle!"
Mindi - 9.0
"Everything! Cinnamon Fries, blueberry cake, yeast... list is endless!"
Sam - 8.6
"Best spot in the city for a mommy daughter date, like visiting "a real princess castle". Cake, adorable cookies & milk for kiddos. Decor is even more magical over the holidays. It is expensive though!"
Natasha Shallon
Places people like to go after Paradise Bakery & Cafe
- 6.9
"Great mall. Very spacious. Security presence."
Hard Rocker - 8.9
"The BEST! They do a lot of community outreach too."
Seanne Spangenburg - 8.2
"Saturdays are the best for fresh seafood! The meat department always has high quality meats @ killer prices! Gas is always @ least $.05-.15 cheaper. Over a year that alone pays for ur membership."
New Radar
Appears on 4 lists
Created by Tim Mace
37 items • 5 followers
Created by Kristin Collignon
8 items • 1 follower
