See all
162 photos

The Old Spaghetti Factory

Italian Restaurant$$$$

Downtown Indianapolis, Indianapolis

Save

7.8^/10

194

ratings

Ranked #10 for pasta in Indianapolis
"Try the browned butter and mizithra cheese, it's to DIE for!"(4 Tips)
"Spinach and Cheese Ravioli is AWESOME!!"(2 Tips)
"Lasagna was very good and can't go wrong with ice cream."(4 Tips)
"Excellent service!! Excellent food!!! Try the #2 meal!!!"(2 Tips)

59 Tips and reviews

Filter:

mizithra cheese
good for dates
great value
ice cream
good for groups
minestrone soup
trendy
dinner
cotton candy
casual
salads
bar
lunch
brown butter
cream soda
garlic
marinara
bread
pesto
takes reservations
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Maria AlvizJune 15, 2018
The perfect spot for classic Italian for all ages. You can either eat in a railroad car or in their huge classic velvet chairs. Don't forget to ask for the complimentary spumoni ice cream for dessert!
Tyler BennerApril 15, 2013
Been here 5+ times
I've been going to the OSF for a really long time. Any time I'm in Indy, I eat here. I always get the fettuccine alfredo. For about $12, you get salad, bread, pasta, and ice cream. It's a great deal!
Billy BrayFebruary 11, 2019
The house salad dressing is good, I like the minestrone soup too, the mizithra pasta is excellent along with the tortellini. Classic good eat.
StuartDecember 11, 2019
The spinach artichoke dip was great, as was the pesto penne chicken. Come hungry because you'll leave full!
Brian PalmerApril 24, 2011
The chicken parm isn't that great (breading is a little odd tasting) but the chicken alfredo is knock your socks off fantastic. Also I would recomend the Italian cream soda. You get to keep the glass!
Charley csChasManJanuary 17, 2015
Eat here with Matt and Heather. ok food nice Italian sodas, kinda nosy, reasonably priced, better and cheaper Italian around town, but close to action downtown.
Ken GrossDecember 17, 2015
Great downtown choice. Service and food was good. They can handle a busy evening very well
Doran EastSeptember 8, 2012
I can not recommend this place enough! The staff was EXCELLENT! We had my daughters B-Day party here and they took great care of us!
Kristi CrispJuly 29, 2013
My kids cleaned their plates. We'll be back. Did I mention ice cream comes with every meal? Yum!
Kristie CarterApril 14, 2013
Having a romantic or fun night out? Leave the transportation and parking to the pros. www.317limousomes.com or 317.716.1201
Jenna ReneeMarch 30, 2014
Get the manager's special (mizithra cheese and marinara combined) omg!!! Best ever!
Anthony PaladinoNovember 12, 2011
Been here 5+ times
Can't decide? Try the Manager's Special, just make sure one of your choices is the browned butter & mizithra cheese!
Kathie Williquette SmithApril 26, 2013
Excellent service!! Excellent food!!! Try the #2 meal!!! I loved it!! :)
Robert GoadOctober 9, 2012
I love the bar upstairs for a quick meal but avoid Tuesday night. The bar tender is not very skilled and tends to forget about tables.
Hard RockerApril 6, 2015
Busy place. Friendly staff. Upstairs dining available. Good food.
Amanda BeasleyDecember 30, 2013
Food is excellent. Bathrooms have creeped me out since I was a kid!
Ellen HurtNovember 1, 2014
Lasagna was very good and can't go wrong with ice cream.
Brian Van GheemFebruary 2, 2019
Make your reservations early and on weekends, ask for a 5:59 PM reservation instead of 6:00!
Jessica JourneyApril 15, 2011
Order one of the premiere combos. Double the food for just a dollar more. Leftovers for lunch the next day!
Andrew LefflerAugust 29, 2011
Very cool place to eat... easy way to skip the long lines is just to eat upstairs at the full service bar
Spencer MartinFebruary 15, 2013
The Mizithra cheese with brown butter is DELICIOUS!!!!!
Jamie BurkeSeptember 14, 2015
Great service, decent cocktail selection
Cliff O.February 21, 2012
Beautiful bar area, terrific spaghetti and meat sauce.
Jenny LewisDecember 31, 2016
Went for my birthday loved it!
Leigh HirniseyApril 5, 2013
The Mizithra spaghetti is the best item on the menu!
Lauren RyanApril 9, 2011
Been here 25+ times
Come see me for dinner! Weekends are blast in the bar with a side of Lauren, Dondi, and Eddie!
Scott VowelsAugust 10, 2013
Come for lunch on a Saturday. The staff was great.
Jenny Love KaufmanOctober 13, 2012
Mizithra is very good mixed with another sauce.
David KellyMay 28, 2011
The italian cream soda with vanilla is amazing!
Patrick FlanaganDecember 28, 2012
Call ahead or make a reservation if you a party of 5 or more
David KuczmanskiJuly 24, 2012
Get the milk... 2%! Clutch
Ty'Anna HowellMay 11, 2013
Creepy bathrooms in the basement. Okay pasta. Huge rooms for big parties
Chris EssexApril 14, 2013
Food was awesome. Bread was awesome. Server sucked. Can't win them all I guess.
MC7576June 28, 2014
Love the cotton candy sprite w chi marssla!!
ArcyDecember 21, 2016
Been here 10+ times
Meat lovers combo 👍
MC7576June 28, 2014
Love the cotton candy sprite w chx marssla!!
Amber JamesMarch 20, 2015
Great atmosphere not impressed with the food
Crystal GrohowskiJune 29, 2012
the spinach and cheese ravioli was yummy
Joshua McGeeJuly 13, 2012
Ask for Dave! Awesome server!
Kelsee HankinsMarch 19, 2010
Try the browned butter and mizithra cheese, it's to DIE for!
Clyde PeachJanuary 29, 2012
Nobody's at the bar. Plenty of room for SB Village patrons.
Bethany KittleOctober 22, 2011
This place is great! Bobby Is a great waiter!!
Clint McCollumApril 15, 2017
Good food, but our waiter was below average. Not attentive and acted inconvenienced when we asked for anything.
Rob BaberApril 28, 2013
Lexi is an awesome server!
David KellyMay 28, 2011
Avoid the restroom elevator...we were stuck for 40 min. But the manager paid for our meal! Great service!
Charley csChasManJanuary 17, 2015
Decent food reasonable prices
🏈Heather Adams🏈January 18, 2012
Spinach and Cheese Ravioli is AWESOME!!
ShannonSeptember 1, 2013
Cool looking place.
Tresa AndersonSeptember 15, 2018
The pesto ranch dressing was good. The rest was mediocre.
Rhonda DelisaDecember 3, 2013
excellent food!!!!!

1 2

162 Photos

The Old Spaghetti Factory

Related Searches

Places inside The Old Spaghetti Factory

You might also like

Places people like to go after The Old Spaghetti Factory

Appears on 29 lists

Top places in the area

Other The Old Spaghetti Factory locations

Is this your business? Claim it now.